Examine the different natures of the Uk and Us constitution
Codified /uncodified
Entrenched /Unentrenched
Difficult to amend /easy to amend
The first difference between these two constitutional types is their source. A codified
constitution is contained within one single document, whereas the source of an uncodified
constitution and therefore the British one is spread across all sorts of different documents.
In America the whole constitution, both the original text and its subsequent amendments, is
contained entirely in a single document. This gives the constitution clarity and accessibility,
and all citizens and institutions can find and read the document easily. It is also arguable
that having a codified constitution also raises awareness of the nation's constitutional
arrangements, as they are often written after a significant historical event. Furthermore, a
codified constitution protects the individual rights of the American citizens, due to the Bill of
rights which was passed in 1791, shortly after the constitution was created. The bill of rights
is a method to protect the rights of individuals against government power. Nevertheless, the
US bill of rights also focuses on protecting the states against the federal Government to
make sure that the federal Government cannot become a dictatorship and gain too much
power. On the other hand, the British uncodified constitution is spread across all sorts of
different documents and has not got specific documents, which protect the individual rights
in the Uk. Unlike in the United States the British constitution doesn’t protect parliament
from gaining an elective dictatorship, as it almost happened with Tony Blair in 1997, where
he and the Labour party gained a large majority. This could become a massive problem as
the party in power could pass every piece of legislation they would want to.
Another difference is the number of powers, which each Parliament has got. The British
constitution is unentrenched, which means that the power lies in Parliament, while the
United States have got an entrenched constitution, where the power lies in the federal
Government, as well as the states. An entrenched constitution means that there are
entrenched Rights those rights, which are explicitly protected by the Constitution. These
rights have a special status and are immune from change by political whims through
legislation. To change them, a Constitutional Amendment will be required and therefore a
super large majority in both houses of representatives, senate and ¾ of the states.
Furthermore, the powers to reign in the US are fixed, which means there is no chance for
either states, or the federal Government to gain more power. On the other hand, you have
got the British unentrenched constitution, which allows Parliament to give power out to the
devolved countries, like Scotland and Northern Ireland. Unlike in the Us, these powers can
be taken away, as the UK is governed based on the principle of parliamentary sovereignty.
The UK Constitution is easy to amend and change, due to the principle of parliamentary
sovereignty. It can be changed simply by passing an Act of Parliament with a simple
majority. For example, the constitutional relationship between Scotland and the UK was
redefined in the 1998 Scotland Act. In contrast, the US Constitution is much more difficult to
amend. Amendments in the USA must be passed with a two-thirds majority in both the
House of Representatives and the Senate, which makes it almost impossible as both houses
Alle Vorteile der Zusammenfassungen von Stuvia auf einen Blick:
Garantiert gute Qualität durch Reviews
Stuvia Verkäufer haben mehr als 700.000 Zusammenfassungen beurteilt. Deshalb weißt du dass du das beste Dokument kaufst.
Schnell und einfach kaufen
Man bezahlt schnell und einfach mit iDeal, Kreditkarte oder Stuvia-Kredit für die Zusammenfassungen. Man braucht keine Mitgliedschaft.
Konzentration auf den Kern der Sache
Deine Mitstudenten schreiben die Zusammenfassungen. Deshalb enthalten die Zusammenfassungen immer aktuelle, zuverlässige und up-to-date Informationen. Damit kommst du schnell zum Kern der Sache.
Häufig gestellte Fragen
Was bekomme ich, wenn ich dieses Dokument kaufe?
Du erhältst eine PDF-Datei, die sofort nach dem Kauf verfügbar ist. Das gekaufte Dokument ist jederzeit, überall und unbegrenzt über dein Profil zugänglich.
Zufriedenheitsgarantie: Wie funktioniert das?
Unsere Zufriedenheitsgarantie sorgt dafür, dass du immer eine Lernunterlage findest, die zu dir passt. Du füllst ein Formular aus und unser Kundendienstteam kümmert sich um den Rest.
Wem kaufe ich diese Zusammenfassung ab?
Stuvia ist ein Marktplatz, du kaufst dieses Dokument also nicht von uns, sondern vom Verkäufer GoodEssays2022. Stuvia erleichtert die Zahlung an den Verkäufer.
Werde ich an ein Abonnement gebunden sein?
Nein, du kaufst diese Zusammenfassung nur für 4,99 €. Du bist nach deinem Kauf an nichts gebunden.