This is a detailed summary of the book 'States versus Markets' of Herman Schwartz for the course Political Economics at the University of Amsterdam. The writer got graded an 8.5/10.
Introduction
Modern states and markets intertwined
states shape market outcomes
markets create state revenue states vs. markets
2 trends:
1) Globalization: greater movement of people, capital and firms in a global market.
2) Upswings and downswing linked to the emergence of leading sectors
creative destruction (Schumpeter)
SAMENVATTING BOEK
Chapter 1: The Rise of the Modern State
Rise of modern state: money necessary for bureaucratic apparatus (+ monopoly of violence)
states force economies in global market (more taxation possibilities)
Agriculture: sets limits on the forms of state organization; limited surplus available for
extraction.
20 km radius micro-economies; low division of labour/productivity/trade
Three ways to increase radius:
1) Water / wind power mills (easier transportation)
nobles
2) Water transport
kings (connecting microeconomies into one bureaucratic state)
3) Money (goods with high value-weight ratio)
merchants
State-building:
1) Lawyers: definition of property rights and political obligations
2) Guns: monopolies of violence
3) Money: bureaucracy of revenue extraction
4) God: national myths to unite the population
Mercantilism: externally oriented policy by which states tried to create inflows of bullion
(specie or metallic money).
bullion best way for kings to monetize power (bypass nobility)
trade as a way to decrease power of nobility (through competition/linkages)
China & India vs. Europe:
In China (kings) and India (merchants) one single group was dominant, whereas in Europe
the kings, merchants and nobles struggled continuously, pressuring them to develop better
,forms of organized violence. In the end, this was the cause of the European victory over the
East.
Indian Ocean trade:
1) Portugal – organized violence
2) Netherlands – monopoly of luxury goods
3) England – bulk commodity trade
Chapter 2: States, Markets and the Origins of International Inequality
Inequality between regions/nations:
1) Neoclassical economics (NCE):
- economic growth in one place does not cause poverty elsewhere (system level)
- international markets/trade affect all economies in the same way
- success/failure is due to local institutions (unit-level)
- property rights innovation
- there is only relative inequality; no relations between countries
2) World systems theory (WST) / dependency theory:
- economic growth can only occur due to exploitation of other regions (system level)
- international markets/trade sort areas into core, semiperiphery and periphery
- local institutions matter very little (unit-level)
Core: creation of high-value added goods; cheap imports from periphery
Periphery: creation of low-value added goods; expensive imports; little opportunity for
economic development.
Semiperiphery: trades low- and high-value goods to core and periphery. Exploited by core;
exploits periphery.
3) Intermediate position:
- global markets create a hierarchy with different income levels (system-level)
- local institutions determine which possible outcome emerges
through Ricardian/Kaldorian strategies
- there is relational inequality, but countries can move up/down ladder
Von Thünen model: explains concentric agricultural (core-periphery) circles.
- lower transport costs nearer to town higher landowner rents
high-value production to pay higher rents (higher productivity wages)
more substitution of capital nearer town
Not necessarily underdevelopment:
1) Lower food prices in periphery due to lower transport costs (higher real income)
, 2) Depends on land/labour ratios
3) Capital may substitute for labour, increasing productivity (Australia)
Source of underdevelopment: coerced peasants entering markets (irrational)
not market forces per se (WST), but institutions entering the market
Krugman model: explains concentric industrial (core-periphery) circles.
- lower transportation costs manufacturing agglomerates
economies of scale, higher productivity in town-region
relatively lower demand (+ productivity) in other industrial regions lower wages
Product cycle model: new industries emerge in areas with high income/wage/skills areas.
core manufacturing agglomerates produce high-value, high-wage products
Ricardian strategy: export-oriented strategy where a country exports the goods with a
comparative advantage (mainly low-value/agricultural).
falling food prices (lower terms of trade)
no increasing returns to scale
Ricardian collective action problems:
1 - social overhead capital (infrastructure)
2 - capital for producers
3 - creation of labor supply
Long-term Ricardian success: higher value
1) Find new agricultural/mineral exports
2) Link other industries to export sector; use export growth Kaldorian strategy
Kaldorian strategy: invest in sector through Verdoorn (learning) effects, lowering production
costs.
funded by Ricardian exports
manufacturing best sector increasing returns to scale
Kaldorian collective action problems: collective action problems concerning, the growth of
productivity; as industrial products are not competitive on world markets per se, like
Ricardian products.
Problems of growth strategies:
1) Low production in periphery limiting opportunities for collective action investment
2) Less military power than developed countries
3) Low state autonomy due to concentrated landownership (labour coercion)
Chapter 3: Economic and Hegemonic Cycles
The benefits of buying summaries with Stuvia:
Guaranteed quality through customer reviews
Stuvia customers have reviewed more than 700,000 summaries. This how you know that you are buying the best documents.
Quick and easy check-out
You can quickly pay through credit card or Stuvia-credit for the summaries. There is no membership needed.
Focus on what matters
Your fellow students write the study notes themselves, which is why the documents are always reliable and up-to-date. This ensures you quickly get to the core!
Frequently asked questions
What do I get when I buy this document?
You get a PDF, available immediately after your purchase. The purchased document is accessible anytime, anywhere and indefinitely through your profile.
Satisfaction guarantee: how does it work?
Our satisfaction guarantee ensures that you always find a study document that suits you well. You fill out a form, and our customer service team takes care of the rest.
Who am I buying these notes from?
Stuvia is a marketplace, so you are not buying this document from us, but from seller Bolhuis. Stuvia facilitates payment to the seller.
Will I be stuck with a subscription?
No, you only buy these notes for $5.89. You're not tied to anything after your purchase.
