British Political History Since 1900 BPG - Thatcher
Class notes
Full Revision Notes - Thatcher and Major - British Political History Since 1900 BPG -- Oxford PPE
24 views 0 purchase
Course
British Political History Since 1900 BPG - Thatcher
Institution
University Of Oxford
Full revision notes for Thatcher and Major covering most of the reading list 41 pages.
includes: Overviews of Heath's government; Thatchers ascendancy, her criticisms of Heath; Overviews of each term; Reasons for ascendancy; Social changes in 1980s; Reasons for downfall; Legacy; Success?; Labour, ...
British Political History Since 1900 BPG - Thatcher
All documents for this subject (1)
Seller
Follow
JTox
Content preview
BPG FINALS 2020 – Thatcherism
, Conservative Governments 1970-74 and 1979-97
Questions:
1. What best explains Thatcherism? To what extent was it a repudiation of Heath’s government
1970-74? To what extent was it a coherent ideology?
2. Was Thatcherism more ‘new’ or ‘old’ Conservatism? Which ideological label best
characterises the governments 1979-97? Or were they pragmatic rather than ideological?
Was there a tension between Thatcher’s short-term tactics and her overall strategy?
3. Were Conservative governments powerful in the 1980s but weak in the 1990s? If so, why?
4. How innovative were Conservative governments 1979-97?
5. How much did the Conservative Party / its policies change 1970-97, and for what reasons?
Elections / Leaders:
• Conservative leaders post-WW2:
o Sir Winston Churchill 1940-55 (resigned just before the 1955 election).
o Sir Anthony Eden 1955-57 (resigned due to ill health and due to embarrassment
caused by military action over the 1956 Suez Crisis).
o Harold Macmillan 1957-63 (resigned following his controversial 1962 Cabinet
shuffle – the ‘Night of the Long Knives’ in which 1/3 of the Cabinet was dismissed
▪ and due to his credibility being affected by the 1963 Profumo Affair).
o Sir Alec Douglas-Home 1963-65 (resigned a year after losing the 1964 election, but
ensured his successor would be the first to be elected by secret ballot).
o Edward Heath 1965-75 (lost in a 1975 leadership election called by Thatcher).
o Margaret Thatcher 1975-90 (challenged for the leadership by Michael Heseltine
following Geoffrey Howe’s resignation over Europe and the poll tax – despite
winning the first ballot, she was encouraged by her Cabinet to resign).
o Sir John Major 1990-97 (resigned following landslide defeat in the 1997 election).
• For the 1970, February 1974, and October 1974 elections, see notes above.
• 1979 election:
o Called after Callaghan’s government lost a vote of confidence by 1 vote (following
the Winter of Discontent and defeat of the Scottish devolution referendum).
o Thatcher’s Conservatives ousted Callaghan’s Labour to win a majority of 44 seats.
This was the first of 4 consecutive election wins for the Conservatives, and Thatcher
became Europe’s first elected female head of government.
o Led to the Labour Party shifting even further to the left in the 1980s (believing their
defeat had been due to a lack of ideological commitment), leading to the 1981 SDP
break-off and enabling the Conservatives to move further to the right.
• 1983 election (following the Falklands War 1982):
o Incumbent Conservatives increased their majority to 144 seats (the most decisive
election victory since Attlee’s Labour in 1945).
o Returned 61% of MPs on 42.4% of the vote
o Share of vote fell slightly from 1979 (from 44 per cent to 42.4 per cent), they won
an overall majority of 144 seats (Lab narrowly held on to second – 27.6 vs Alliance
25.4)
• 1987 election:
o Incumbent Conservatives lost 21 seats but retained a large majority.
• 1992 election:
o Surprise 4th consecutive win for the Conservatives (now under Major) – a narrow
majority whilst receiving the largest number of votes in British electoral history.
, • 1997 election:
o Blair’s Labour won a landslide 418 seats (Conservatives won 165), the most seats
the Party has ever held.
o Huge Conservative-Labour swing of 10.2% on a national turnout of 71% (the last
national vote where turnout exceeded 70% until the 2016 EU Referendum).
Heath’s Government 1970-74:
Overview:
• PM from 1970-1974
• Harrison: Heath exemplified the philosophy of modernization
• Heath’s early policies were right-wing (some have said proto-Thatcherite):
o Cut income tax in his first budget.
o Lifted £2bn of corporation tax in his second budget.
o Successfully restricted the Post Office strike of 1971.
o Passed the Industrial Relations Act 1971 without consulting the trade unions
▪ required state registration of unions, made collective agreements legally
enforceable, and limited ‘wildcat’ (unofficial) strikes.
• He is most remembered for a number of U-turns, having come into office on a platform of a
largely self-regulating, free enterprise economy:
1. Special Budget of July 1971:
▪ Abolished financial targets for nationalised industries, and provided a fiscal
stimulus to the economy through a £100m public works programme.
▪ 1972-74 actually ended up being the peak of Keynesianism, despite the 1970
‘A Better Tomorrow’ manifesto promising lower taxes and spending.
▪ It seems that Heath was a pragmatist conservative, not a neoliberal
ideologue, so was unwilling to implement neoliberal policies at the cost of
unemployment, discontent, and unpopularity.
2. Nationalisations:
▪ Nationalised the aero-engine division of Rolls Royce in 1971 when it went
bankrupt (because its production was necessary for the armed forces).
▪ Bailed out Upper Clyde shipbuilders in 1972 after a Communist-led sit-in.
3. Industry Act 1972:
▪ The government promised to promote and subsidise industry, which was a
precursor to Heath’s “dash for growth”.
▪ Resulted from the announcement that unemployment had broken 1m in
January 1972, and the humiliation of the miners’ strike in February 1972.
4. Introduced a statutory incomes policy in 1972:
▪ This was despite the Conservatives having campaigned in opposition to
abolish Labour 1966 incomes policy, and bringing back free collective
bargaining without government intervention in 1970.
▪ Introduced against the backdrop of an international oil crisis which
quadrupled energy prices, but was unsuccessful in controlling inflation – it
peaked at 26.9% in the 12 months to August 1975.
▪ Led to repeated strikes throughout 1974.
• Heath was persuaded to call the “Who governs Britain?” election of February 1974 as a
result of the ongoing industrial crises (in particular the miners’ strike) and the three-day
week – Labour emerged as the largest Party despite the Conservatives winning the most
votes and, when the Conservative coalition talks failed (the Liberals could not uphold a
defeated government), Wilson formed a minority Labour government.
, • He then fought the October 1974 election on a consensus platform, having lost faith in his
own government to govern, and was replaced by Thatcher as Conservative Leader in 1975.
Despite the U-turns, there were some achievements:
• Long-lasting achievement – Britain’s entry into the EEC in 1973 (it was the Conservatives
who were the pro-EEC/EC/EU Party compared to Labour in the 1970s), achieving 3 goals:
avoiding war in Europe, economic stimulus, and a world role for the UK post-empire.
• Short-lived achievements:
o Power-sharing in Northern Ireland (shattered shortly after February 1974 election).
o Reorganisations of health and local government.
o Industrial Relations Act 1971 (until repealed by Wilson in 1974).
• And we must remember the external constraints on Heath’s government:
o His Chancellor (Macleod) had a heart attack and died within a month.
o Rise of militant unionism and the student movement – law and order was declining,
and Heath had to impose five states of emergency.
o Three major shocks to the world economy:
▪ Nixon ended the Bretton Woods Agreement (which had fixed world
currencies against the Dollar) in August 1971, creating instability.
▪ Huge rise in commodity prices when Heath was seeking to curb inflation.
▪ OPEC oil crisis in 1973, which quadrupled energy prices.
Thatcher’s criticism of Heath:
• Despite his 1970 ‘A Better Tomorrow’ manifesto promising lower taxes and spending,
Heath was ‘wet’ and U-turned on this (e.g. promising a £100m public works programme in
the July 1971 Special Budget), and 1972-74 ended up being the peak of Keynesianism.
• Harrison: Thatcher had no time for the mid-1970s defensive constitutional reform package
– devolution along with PR – which some Conservatives hoped would restrain socialist govs
• Defence of Heath:
o The country was not yet ready for this right-wing assault – it needed to experience
the failures of the Heath government and stagflation under Labour 1974-79. Had
Heath been more right-wing, the Conservatives would probably have performed
even worse in the two 1974 elections.
o He set the tone for Thatcherism, promising what she actually delivered:
▪ His first Conference speech as PM promised a “quiet revolution”,
challenging the post-war consensus.
▪ The abandonment of the 1970 manifesto (based on free-market economic
policies) led to the creation of the ‘Selsdon Group’ in 1973, whose policies
influenced the Thatcher and Major governments.
Thatcher’s ascendancy:
• In the 1975 leadership election, she won 130 votes vs. 119 for Heath, due to:
o Her ‘conviction politician’ personality – the fact she was not Heath.
o The fact she was willing to challenge Heath when others would not (she was the
only candidate in the first round – Whitelaw entered too late in the second round).
o The skill of her campaign manager (Neave) – he deliberately underplayed her
strength ahead of the first ballot, thus encouraging MPs to vote for her who would
otherwise have abstained. This momentum carried her through the second ballot.
• She did not appear radically right-wing at this point:
o She was the daughter of a grocer from Grantham.
The benefits of buying summaries with Stuvia:
Guaranteed quality through customer reviews
Stuvia customers have reviewed more than 700,000 summaries. This how you know that you are buying the best documents.
Quick and easy check-out
You can quickly pay through credit card or Stuvia-credit for the summaries. There is no membership needed.
Focus on what matters
Your fellow students write the study notes themselves, which is why the documents are always reliable and up-to-date. This ensures you quickly get to the core!
Frequently asked questions
What do I get when I buy this document?
You get a PDF, available immediately after your purchase. The purchased document is accessible anytime, anywhere and indefinitely through your profile.
Satisfaction guarantee: how does it work?
Our satisfaction guarantee ensures that you always find a study document that suits you well. You fill out a form, and our customer service team takes care of the rest.
Who am I buying these notes from?
Stuvia is a marketplace, so you are not buying this document from us, but from seller JTox. Stuvia facilitates payment to the seller.
Will I be stuck with a subscription?
No, you only buy these notes for $39.99. You're not tied to anything after your purchase.
