Summary

OCR Religious Studies A Level A* Ontological argument Summary notes

0 purchase

Course
G571 - AS Philosophy of Religion

Institution
OCR

Book
OCR Religious Studies A Level Year 2

I achieved an A* in the 2021 A Level Religious Studies exam and am now going to study at Imperial College London. I have uploaded my detailed summary of the AS philosophy topic - The Ontological Argument- which includes the content (AO1) as well as the main strengths and weaknesses of each schol...

[Show more]

Preview 2 out of 7 pages

View example

Summarized whole book? No
Which chapters are summarized? The ontological argument
Uploaded on September 6, 2021
Number of pages 7
Written in 2020/2021
Type Summary

religious studies
philosophy
ethics
ontological argument
arguments from reason
ocr
a level religious studies
a level
rs

Book Title:OCR Religious Studies A Level Year 2

Author(s):Michael Wilkinson, Michael Wilcockson

Edition:december 2016
ISBN:9781471866708
Edition:Unknown

Study Level
A/AS Level
Examinator
OCR
Subject
Religious Studies
Unit
G571 - AS Philosophy of Religion

$5.29

Add to cart

Save

100% satisfaction guarantee
Immediately available after payment
Both online and in PDF
No strings attached

The existence of God; arguments based on reason

The ontological argument is a deductive, a priori argument for God’s
existence. The very definition of God logically entails his existence.
However, can we leap from definition (de dicto) to reality (de re)?
Just because a pixie ‘is’ a little man with pointed ears doesn’t mean
a pixie ‘is’, or exists.

ST ANSELM OF CANTERBURY’S ONTOLOGICAL ARGUMENT
 Medieval monk
 OA found in his work Proslogian, a prayer addressed to God
rather than a philosophical thesis
 Believed true understanding was only a consequence of faith
 Proslogian Chapter 2 is a proof by contradiction;
 Anselm refers to the ‘fool’ in the Bible Psalms who says that
he knows the definition of God and what he is supposed to be,
‘that than which no greater can be conceived’ (TTWNGCBC),
but doesn’t think anything with that definition actually exists.
 Anselm says that things exist both in the mind and in reality
 The fool is contradicting himself because if God is TTWNGCBC,
and he does not exist in reality, he can’t be the greatest thing
that we can think of because existing in reality is greater than
in the mind (a real life painting is better than one in the
painter’s mind + £1 million is better in reality than in the
mind)
 In Aristotelian logic, a contradiction is impossible
 Therefore; God is TTWNGCBC, it is greater to exist in reality
than in the mind, therefore God exists in reality because a
God in reality is greater than a God only in the mind.
 Proslogian Chapter 3 (second form) argues for his necessary
existence;
 God is TTWNGCBC. It is greater to have necessary existence
than contingent. Therefore God must have necessary
existence. God exists

STRENGTHS OF ANSELM WEAKNESSES OF ANSELM
 If we treat the word God as  Guanilo’s criticism
analytic, the same way as  Is it always greater to exist in
2+6=8 and that a triangle has reality? (a murderous
three sides, then God’s thought, pandemic, war)
existence is self evident as it  Gaskin says moving from
is deductive definition to reality is a
 Logical contradiction to ‘transitional error’
believe he doesn’t exist  Can never be certain that
because if he didn’t exist then God’s exact definition is
anything that does exist is TTWNGCBC (Aquinas) so the
greater than God but God is premise is not 100% accurate,
TTWNGCBC therefore the conclusion is not
 Is it fair to attack Anselm for accurate

, not proving God to the  You can only go so far as to
unbeliever as he stated that say that if God exists then he
his work was ‘faith seeking exists necessarily
understanding’?  If God is ‘wholly other’ we
cannot accept Anselm’s
definition of God or what he is
like. If he is ineffable then
Ayer would argue we are
talking nonsense if we try to
know what he is like
 Russell- statements about
cannot be made unless we
know that God exists. The
‘present king of france is bald’
is not true or false if there is
no King of France’

GUANILO’S CRITICISM
 Guanilo of Marmoutier
 Benedictine monk
 Contemporary of Anselm
 Anselm’s argument is an exercise of wishful thinking, anything
can be though into existence with it
 In his ‘In Behalf of the Fool’ he puts himself into the position of a
rational non-believer and puts forward the idea of the perfect
mythical Lost Island
 If the perfect island doesn’t exist then it is a contradiction to
call it perfect, therefore it must exist
 This applies to anything that we can think of that is ‘perfect’
by definition
 Guanilo asks his readers to look at the empirical evidence of
the world which shows that these perfect things don’t exist
 If parallel arguments from perfection are absurd, so is the
original ontological argument
 THIS IS NOT COHERENT BECAUSE PLANTINGA SAYS THAT
ISLANDS HAVE NO INTRINSIC MAXIMUMS

ST ANSELM’S RESPONSE TO GUANILO
 The OA only applies to God, a supremely necessary being.

The benefits of buying summaries with Stuvia:

Guaranteed quality through customer reviews

Stuvia customers have reviewed more than 700,000 summaries. This how you know that you are buying the best documents.

Quick and easy check-out

You can quickly pay through credit card or Stuvia-credit for the summaries. There is no membership needed.

Focus on what matters

Your fellow students write the study notes themselves, which is why the documents are always reliable and up-to-date. This ensures you quickly get to the core!

Frequently asked questions

What do I get when I buy this document?

You get a PDF, available immediately after your purchase. The purchased document is accessible anytime, anywhere and indefinitely through your profile.

Satisfaction guarantee: how does it work?

Our satisfaction guarantee ensures that you always find a study document that suits you well. You fill out a form, and our customer service team takes care of the rest.

Who am I buying these notes from?

Stuvia is a marketplace, so you are not buying this document from us, but from seller chitambarakarelina. Stuvia facilitates payment to the seller.

Will I be stuck with a subscription?

No, you only buy these notes for $5.29. You're not tied to anything after your purchase.

Can Stuvia be trusted?

4.6 stars on Google & Trustpilot (+1000 reviews)

66184 documents were sold in the last 30 days

Founded in 2010, the go-to place to buy study notes for 15 years now

Start selling

Summary

OCR Religious Studies A Level A* Ontological argument Summary notes

Document information

Subjects

Connected book

Written for

Seller

Content preview