Judgments
Bijzondere overeenkomsten jurisprudentie
- Course
- Institution
Samenvatting van alle arresten van het vak Bijzondere overeenkomsten. Bevat alle voorgeschreven arresten en documenten (week 1 t/m 5)
[Show more]
Seller
Follow
RamonavW
Reviews received
Content preview
Jurisprudentie Bijzondere overeenkomstenWeek 1a – Consumentenovereenkomst.......................................................................................8
1. Content Services Ltd/Bundesarbeitskammer............................................................................8
Essentie................................................................................................................................. 8
Samenvatting........................................................................................................................ 8
Hof van Justitie...................................................................................................................... 8
2. Walterbusch............................................................................................................................ 10
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 10
Hof van Justitie.................................................................................................................... 10
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 12
3. Slewo/Sascha Ledowski......................................................................................................... 13
Hof van Justitie.................................................................................................................... 13
4. Amazon EU Sàrl..................................................................................................................... 15
Hof van Justitie.................................................................................................................... 15
Week 1b – Nietigheden algemeen..............................................................................................18
5. Polyproject/Warmond l............................................................................................................18
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 18
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 18
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 19
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 20
Noot..................................................................................................................................... 21
6. Polyproject/Warmond lI........................................................................................................... 23
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 23
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 23
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 24
Noot..................................................................................................................................... 25
7. AZL/Erven Moerman...............................................................................................................26
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 26
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 26
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 27
................................................................................................................................................... 28
Noot..................................................................................................................................... 29
8. Dexia...................................................................................................................................... 31
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 31
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 31
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 33
1
, Noot..................................................................................................................................... 34
9. Esmilo/Mediq.......................................................................................................................... 36
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 36
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 37
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 37
10. Schriftelijkheidsvereiste........................................................................................................39
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 39
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 39
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 40
11. B/H en R............................................................................................................................... 42
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 42
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 42
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 43
Week 2a – Gevolgen van nietigheid...........................................................................................44
12. LRS/Sint Willibrord................................................................................................................ 44
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 44
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 44
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 45
13. BP Europa SE/X................................................................................................................... 47
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 47
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 48
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 51
Noot..................................................................................................................................... 53
14. Gratis mobieltjes II................................................................................................................ 56
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 56
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 57
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 59
Week 2b – Consumentenovereenkomsten.................................................................................64
15. Quelle................................................................................................................................... 64
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 64
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 64
Hof van Justitie EG.............................................................................................................. 64
Noot..................................................................................................................................... 65
16. Gratis mobieltjes I.................................................................................................................66
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 66
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 67
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 70
2
,17. CA Consumer Finance.........................................................................................................72
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 72
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 72
Hof van Justitie EU.............................................................................................................. 72
18. Matei..................................................................................................................................... 75
Hof....................................................................................................................................... 75
Conclusie............................................................................................................................. 77
19. Faber/Hazet.......................................................................................................................... 78
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 78
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 78
Hof van Justitie EU.............................................................................................................. 79
20. LCL/Fesih Kalhan.................................................................................................................81
Hof....................................................................................................................................... 81
21. Radlinger and Randlingerová...............................................................................................83
Hof....................................................................................................................................... 83
22. Ultimo Portfolio Investment (Luxembourg) SA/KM................................................................86
Hof....................................................................................................................................... 86
Week 3a – Koop/schending........................................................................................................88
23. WRA/Oldenhoeck................................................................................................................. 88
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 88
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 88
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 89
24. Van Dalfsen/Gemeente Kampen..........................................................................................91
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 91
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 91
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 93
Conclusie............................................................................................................................. 95
25. De Beeldbrigade/Hulskamp..................................................................................................96
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 96
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 96
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 98
26. Van de Steeg/Rabobank.......................................................................................................99
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 99
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 103
Onderzoeks- en klachtplicht.......................................................................................103
De beleggingsadviesrelatie tussen bank en particuliere cliënt....................................105
27. ABN AMRO/Botersloot.......................................................................................................106
3
, Essentie............................................................................................................................. 106
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 106
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 107
28. FAR Trading BV/Edco Eindhoven BV.................................................................................109
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 109
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 110
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 112
29. Portsight BV/De Vries Werkendam Beh. BV.......................................................................115
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 115
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 116
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 117
30. Oude boerderij.................................................................................................................... 119
Inhoudsindicatie.................................................................................................................119
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 119
31. Woonboerderij.................................................................................................................... 121
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 121
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 121
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 122
Noot................................................................................................................................... 123
32. MBS/Prowni........................................................................................................................ 127
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 127
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 127
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 128
33. Tennispark.......................................................................................................................... 129
Inhoudsindicatie.................................................................................................................129
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 129
34. Hoist/Vodafone................................................................................................................... 130
Inhoudsindicatie.................................................................................................................130
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 130
35. X/Street One....................................................................................................................... 132
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 132
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 132
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 133
Noot................................................................................................................................... 133
36. Albert Heijn......................................................................................................................... 135
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 135
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 135
4
, Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 136
Week 3b – Koop/schending......................................................................................................138
37. ECLI:NL:HR:2020:1240......................................................................................................138
Inhoudsindicatie.................................................................................................................138
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 138
Week 4a – Opdracht/lastgeving/bemiddeling/agentuur.............................................................140
38. T-mobile Netherlands/Klomp..............................................................................................140
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 140
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 141
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 143
Noot................................................................................................................................... 146
39. X/NBG Finance................................................................................................................... 148
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 148
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 148
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 150
Noot................................................................................................................................... 151
40. ECLI:NL:HR:2016:660........................................................................................................152
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 152
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 152
Redactionele aantekening.................................................................................................153
41. ECLI:NL:HR:2017:567........................................................................................................154
Inhoudsindicatie.................................................................................................................154
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 154
42. Tio Teach............................................................................................................................ 155
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 155
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 155
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 156
Redactionele aantekening.................................................................................................156
43. ECLI:NL:HR:2018:141........................................................................................................157
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 157
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 157
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 158
Redactionele aantekening.................................................................................................160
44. ECLI:NL:HR:2017:935........................................................................................................161
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 161
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 161
Week 4b – Verzekeringsovereenkomst/subrogatie en regres...................................................162
5
,45. ECLI:NL:HR:2017:694........................................................................................................162
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 162
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 163
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 164
Noot................................................................................................................................... 165
Week 5a – Vaststellingsovereenkomst / borgtocht...................................................................167
46. Meurs/Nederland Woningfinanciering Maatschappij...........................................................167
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 167
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 168
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 169
47. Merck/Euromedica.............................................................................................................. 173
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 173
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 173
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 174
48. X/Velthuyzen Van Zanten Beheer.......................................................................................176
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 176
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 177
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 180
Noot................................................................................................................................... 181
49. Van Leeuwen/Lips e.a........................................................................................................184
Inhoudsindicatie.................................................................................................................184
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 184
50. C/Heesen Yacht Builders BV..............................................................................................185
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 185
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 185
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 186
Noot................................................................................................................................... 187
51. Blue Taxi/Stichting Sociaal Fonds Taxi...............................................................................189
Inhoudsindicatie.................................................................................................................189
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 189
52. X/Rabobank Hilvarenbeek..................................................................................................190
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 190
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 190
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 192
Noot................................................................................................................................... 193
53. Dulack q.q./X...................................................................................................................... 194
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 194
6
, Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 194
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 195
Noot................................................................................................................................... 197
54. A/Aruba Bank..................................................................................................................... 199
Inhoudsindicatie.................................................................................................................199
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 199
Week 5b – Samenloop.............................................................................................................200
55. Boogard/Vesta.................................................................................................................... 200
Feiten................................................................................................................................ 200
Hof..................................................................................................................................... 200
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 200
56. Petri/AVO............................................................................................................................ 201
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 201
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 201
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 202
Noot................................................................................................................................... 202
57. Groeneveld/Staat................................................................................................................ 204
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 204
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 204
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 205
Noot................................................................................................................................... 206
7
, Week 1a – Consumentenovereenkomst
Jurisprudentie
1. Content Services Ltd/Bundesarbeitskammer
2. Walterbusch
3. Slewo/Sascha Ledowski
4. Amazon EU Sàrl
1. Content Services Ltd/Bundesarbeitskammer
Essentie
Verzoek om een prejudiciële beslissing, ingediend door het Oberlandesgericht Wien bij
beslissing van 26 januari 2011. Op afstand gesloten overeenkomsten. Voorlichting van
consument. Verstrekte of ontvangen informatie. Duurzame drager. Hyperlink op website van
leverancier. Herroepingsrecht.
Samenvatting
Art. 5, lid 1, van Richtlijn 97/7/EG (art. 6:240m BW) van het Europees Parlement en de Raad
van 20 mei 1997 betreffende de bescherming van de consument bij op afstand gesloten
overeenkomsten moet aldus worden uitgelegd dat een handelspraktijk die erin bestaat de in
deze bepaling bedoelde informatie voor de consument enkel toegankelijk te maken via een
hyperlink op een website van de betrokken onderneming, niet aan de vereisten van deze
bepaling voldoet, aangezien deze informatie niet door deze onderneming wordt ‘verstrekt’ en
evenmin door de consument wordt ‘ontvangen’ in de zin van deze bepaling, en dat een website
als aan de orde in het hoofdgeding niet als een ‘duurzame gegevensdrager’ in de zin van dit art.
5, lid 1, kan worden beschouwd.
Hof van Justitie
Het verzoek om een prejudiciële beslissing betreft de uitlegging van artikel 5, lid 1, van Richtlijn
97/7/EG van het Europees Parlement en de Raad van 20 mei 1997 betreffende de bescherming
van de consument bij op afstand gesloten overeenkomsten (PB L 144, p. 19).
Dit verzoek is ingediend in het kader van een geding tussen Content Services Ltd (hierna:
‘Content Services’) en de Bundesarbeitskammer over de wijze waarop de consument die via
internet een overeenkomst op afstand heeft gesloten, de informatie betreffende deze
overeenkomst moet ontvangen.
Uit het verzoek om een prejudiciële beslissing volgt dat de consumenten vóór de sluiting van
een overeenkomst op afstand, enkel toegang hebben tot de informatie met name inzake het
herroepingsrecht door een link aan te klikken die hen doorverwijst naar een onderdeel van de
website van Content Services. Tevens volgt eruit dat deze consumenten, na het opgeven van
hun bestelling, van Content Services een e-mail ontvangen die geen enkele informatie over dit
recht bevat, maar waarin een link staat naar de website van Content Services waarop bepaalde
informatie inzake het herroepingsrecht kan worden verkregen.
8
The benefits of buying summaries with Stuvia:
Guaranteed quality through customer reviews
Stuvia customers have reviewed more than 700,000 summaries. This how you know that you are buying the best documents.
Quick and easy check-out
You can quickly pay through credit card or Stuvia-credit for the summaries. There is no membership needed.
Focus on what matters
Your fellow students write the study notes themselves, which is why the documents are always reliable and up-to-date. This ensures you quickly get to the core!
Frequently asked questions
What do I get when I buy this document?
You get a PDF, available immediately after your purchase. The purchased document is accessible anytime, anywhere and indefinitely through your profile.
Satisfaction guarantee: how does it work?
Our satisfaction guarantee ensures that you always find a study document that suits you well. You fill out a form, and our customer service team takes care of the rest.
Who am I buying these notes from?
Stuvia is a marketplace, so you are not buying this document from us, but from seller RamonavW. Stuvia facilitates payment to the seller.
Will I be stuck with a subscription?
No, you only buy these notes for $4.81. You're not tied to anything after your purchase.
Can Stuvia be trusted?
4.6 stars on Google & Trustpilot (+1000 reviews)
54879 documents were sold in the last 30 days
Founded in 2010, the go-to place to buy study notes for 14 years now