Summary
Samenvatting methoden van gedragswetenschappelijk onderzoek: verdieping
- Course
- Institution
Samenvatting van methoden van gedragswetenschappelijk onderzoek: kwantitatieve onderzoeksdesigns en kwalitatieve methoden.
[Show more]
Seller
Follow
AstridD
Reviews received
Content preview
Methoden van gedragswetenschappelijk onderzoek: verdiepingMethoden van gedragswetenschappelijk onderzoek:
verdieping
1 Validiteit ........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 4
1.1 Typologie en bedreigingen.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 4
1.2 Classificatie en bedreigingen van validiteit..................................................................................................................................................................................................... 4
2 Designs.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................6
2.1 Quasi-experimenten zonder controlegroep ....................................................................................................................................................................................................6
Causale inferentie bij quasi-experimenten ......................................................................................................................................................................................... 7
Soorten designs .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 7
Matching, blocking en stratificatie ........................................................................................................................................................................................................8
Controlegroepen .........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................8
Werken met contrasten bij designs zonder controlegroep............................................................................................................................................................9
Case-control design...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................9
2.2 Quasi-experimenten met contolegroep en voormeting ...............................................................................................................................................................................9
Soorten designs ........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 10
Taxonomie van quasi-experimenten......................................................................................................................................................................................................11
Is er één ideaal quasi-experimenteel design? ...................................................................................................................................................................................11
2.3 Gerandomiseerde experimenten .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................12
Toevallige toewijzing = randomisering ................................................................................................................................................................................................12
Waarom en hoe werkt randomisering? ...............................................................................................................................................................................................12
Wat wordt er gerandomiseerd? ............................................................................................................................................................................................................12
Soms randomisering niet haalbaar of wenselijk ............................................................................................................................................................................. 13
3 Kwalitatieve onderzoeksbenaderingen ..................................................................................................................................................................................................................14
3.1 Narratieve benadering ........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 15
Definitie ....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 15
Oorsprong................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 15
Kenmerken .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 15
Types ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 15
Procedures ................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 16
Voordelen en uitdagingen ....................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 16
3.2 Fenomenologie ........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................17
Definitie ........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................17
Oorsprong....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................17
Kenmerken ...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................17
Types ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 17
Procedures ..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................17
Voordelen en uitdagingen ....................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 18
Astrid De Brabandere
1
, Methoden van gedragswetenschappelijk onderzoek: verdieping
3.3 Grounded theory ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 19
Definitie ....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 19
Oorsprong................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 19
Kenmerken .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 19
Types ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 19
Procedures ................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 20
Voordelen en uitdagingen ...................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 20
3.4 Etnografie.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................21
Definitie ........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................21
Oorsprong....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................21
Kenmerken ...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................21
Types .............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................21
Procedures ................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 22
Voordelen en uitdagingen ...................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 22
3.5 Case study ....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 23
Definitie ...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 23
Oorsprong.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 23
Kenmerken ................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 23
Types ........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 23
Procedures ................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 24
Voordelen en uitdagingen ...................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 24
3.6 5 verschillende benaderingen vergeleken.............................................................................................................................................................................................. 25
4 Ethische overwegingen in kwalitatief onderzoek .............................................................................................................................................................................................. 25
4.1 Relationele ethiek................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 25
4.2 Ethische commissies .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 26
4.3 Meer dan ‘toegang onderhandelen’ en ‘building rapport’......................................................................................................................................................................... 26
4.4 Informed consent / geïnformeerde toestemming ......................................................................................................................................................................................27
4.5 Onderzoeks-grenzen ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27
4.6 Transparantie in doelen, verwachingen, processen en rollen .................................................................................................................................................................27
4.7 Vertrouwelijkheid en anonimiteit .....................................................................................................................................................................................................................27
4.8 Ethische dimensies van de onderzoeker als instrument.......................................................................................................................................................................... 28
4.9 Verzet je tegen de binaire tegenstelling expert-lerende ......................................................................................................................................................................... 28
4.10 Ethical collaboration ..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 28
4.11 Evenwicht tussen flexibiliteit en nauwgezetheid van het design ............................................................................................................................................................ 28
5 Validiteit: kwaliteitsvol kwalitatief onderzoek .................................................................................................................................................................................................... 29
5.1 Het debat over ‘kwaliteit’ in kwalitatief onderzoek .................................................................................................................................................................................... 29
5.2 Kwaliteit/Validiteit: algemene opmerkingen ................................................................................................................................................................................................ 29
5.3 Criteria voor kwaliteit .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 29
Astrid De Brabandere
2
, Methoden van gedragswetenschappelijk onderzoek: verdieping
5.4 Types validiteit ...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 29
5.5 Strategieën ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 29
Triangulatie................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 29
Validering door participanten (aka “member checks”)................................................................................................................................................................ 29
Strategisch sequentiëren van methodes.......................................................................................................................................................................................... 30
Thick description...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 30
Dialogic engagement............................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 30
Multiple coding.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 30
Gestructureerde reflexiviteit ............................................................................................................................................................................................................... 30
(Mixed methods)....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 30
5.6 Rigoureusheid en validiteit in kwalitatief onderzoek ........................................................................................................................................................................... 30
6 4 filosofische visies op wetenschap ...................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 31
7 Mixed methods ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 33
7.1 Visies op de relatie tussen kwantitatieve en kwalitatieve methoden ................................................................................................................................................... 36
7.2 Keuzes van methode wordt bepaald ............................................................................................................................................................................................................... 36
Astrid De Brabandere
3
, Methoden van gedragswetenschappelijk onderzoek: verdieping
1 Validiteit
Voorbeeld: Slimme Hans = paard waarvan werd beweerd dat het kon rekenen
Kunstjes: eenvoudige optelsommen (bv. 5+3= en dan stampte hij 8 keer op de grond)
Nagaan waarop deze theorie werd gebaseerd, fraude?
Oscar was psycholoog die experimenten opzette en conclusie maakte
Onderzocht paard alleen, zonder publiek en baasje
Nog altijd veel juiste resultaten
Concludeerde: gebruik maken van onbewuste aanwijzingen (gelaatsuitdrukking, lichaamstaal)
Mensen geneigd met kleine knik om hoofd op te tillen bij juist antwoord
Truckjes aanleren met juist getal onthouden
Stelde validiteit van uitspraak in vraag, ‘dit specifiek paard’
Alternatieve verklaringen uitsluiten
1.1 Typologie en bedreigingen
Validiteit (geldigheid) → de mate waarin een uitspraak / inferentie de waarheid benadert
- Het gaat over “een mate waarin”; de waarheid wordt slechts “benaderd”
- Het gaat over uitspraken / inferenties; niet over proefopzetten of methoden
- Geen enkele methode is superieur; het gaat over afwegen van verschillende types van validiteit gekoppeld aan de context en de doelstellingen
van het onderzoek
- Er bestaan geen sterke en zwakke designs
In deze theorie is validiteit gekoppeld aan Waarheid
- Correspondentie met de observeerbare werkelijkheid vb. “Het regent”
- Coherentie verzameling van uitspraken, dit al waarheid beschouwd, fysiologische kenmerken, passend binnen geheel van resultaten (van eerdere
onderzoeken) vb. “Het roken van cannabis veroorzaakt kanker”
- Nuttigheid, Uitspraak is waar als het nuttig en kan naar gewerkt worden, het werkt vb. “Elektronen bestaan”
- Sociale constructie, Invloed van sociale en psychologische factoren op de consensusvorming
Campbell (1957)
Interne validiteit Externe validiteit
“did in fact the experimental stimulus make some significant difference in “to what populations, settings, treatment variables, and measurement
this specific instance?“ variables can this effect be generalized?”
Antwoord geven op de vraag of er een significante verandering is Theorie van validiteit uitbreiden met andere zaken, zoals populaties,
→ onder controle door randomisering (invloed van Fisher in de jaren contexten, variabelen…
’50) → niet onder controle door randomisering
Intern versus extern ≠ laboratorium versus veld
1.2 Classificatie en bedreigingen van validiteit
Algemene bedreigingen
= de specifieke redenen waarom we gedeeltelijk of volledig verkeerd kunnen zijn als we een inferentie maken
= veel voorkomende alternatieve verklaringen
- Bedreigingen van de statistische conclusie validiteit en de interne validiteit:
- Bedreigingen van de constructvaliditeit en de externe validiteit
→ Proberen om rekening te houden met de bedreigingen (“rule them out”) door middel van design controls (niet zozeer statistical adjustments = post
hoc) = proberen onder controle krijgen
→ Indien niet mogelijk, dan drie vragen:
(1) Op welke manier is de bedreiging toepasselijk in dit geval?
(2) Is er evidentie dat de bedreiging plausibel is (en niet enkel mogelijk)?
(3) Werkt de bedreiging in dezelfde richting als het geoberverveerde effect zodat het een gedeeltelijke of volledige verklaring van het geobserveerde
effect kan bieden?
→ De bedreiging “meten”
Astrid De Brabandere
4
The benefits of buying summaries with Stuvia:
Guaranteed quality through customer reviews
Stuvia customers have reviewed more than 700,000 summaries. This how you know that you are buying the best documents.
Quick and easy check-out
You can quickly pay through credit card or Stuvia-credit for the summaries. There is no membership needed.
Focus on what matters
Your fellow students write the study notes themselves, which is why the documents are always reliable and up-to-date. This ensures you quickly get to the core!
Frequently asked questions
What do I get when I buy this document?
You get a PDF, available immediately after your purchase. The purchased document is accessible anytime, anywhere and indefinitely through your profile.
Satisfaction guarantee: how does it work?
Our satisfaction guarantee ensures that you always find a study document that suits you well. You fill out a form, and our customer service team takes care of the rest.
Who am I buying these notes from?
Stuvia is a marketplace, so you are not buying this document from us, but from seller AstridD. Stuvia facilitates payment to the seller.
Will I be stuck with a subscription?
No, you only buy these notes for $5.89. You're not tied to anything after your purchase.
Can Stuvia be trusted?
4.6 stars on Google & Trustpilot (+1000 reviews)
53022 documents were sold in the last 30 days
Founded in 2010, the go-to place to buy study notes for 14 years now