Summary
Summary Principles of Taxation (2021/2022)
- Course
- Institution
Complete summary of all 4 parts of the course Principles of Taxation. Taught by Professor L. De Broe in 2021/2022. (BBA KU Leuven)
[Show more]
Seller
Followalexanderbollen
Reviews received
Content preview
Principles of TaxationPart 1: The fundamental principles of taxation
1. What is a tax?
2. What are the fundamental questions of taxation?
3. What are the essential elements of taxation?
1. What is a tax?
Mandatory payment in cash or in kind to a public authority
- Tax No contractual obligation
- Payments on a contractual basis are not taxes
- Gifts, donations, or voluntary payments to public authority are not taxes
- Financial sanctions are not taxes ( Fines)
- Taxes are determined by law ( Legal basis is required)
A tax is a payment without consideration or compensation
- No quid pro quo You get nothing in return ( No individual compensation to taxpayer)
- Unilateral contribution to the budget of a public authority
- This governmental budget is used to finance any public purpose
- Taxpayer has no control over the use of this budget ( Public authority has control)
- Control over spending of public authority is exercised by parliament
- This parliament is elected by citizens/taxpayers ( Indirect control)
What is a tax? ( Summarized)
- Mandatory contribution ( In cash or in kind)
- In accordance with rule of law ( Legal basis is required)
- Imposed by public authority ( Paid by taxpayers/citizens)
- Without any personal compensation ( Individual taxpayers get nothing in return)
- Used by public authority for public spending
Mandatory contribution
- Taxpayers/citizens have no choice and must comply
- Can be imposed by force by the public authority (Fines, seizing of private property, …)
- Only way to legitimately avoid payment of tax Tax avoidance
- Tax avoidance Placing yourself outside the legal scope of application of a certain tax
- Tax laws are not internationally harmonized ( E.g., No individual taxation in UAE)
- More international organizations can engage in more complex tax planning
In accordance with rule of law
- “No taxation without representation” Legislation is required for application of taxes
- Taxation needs a legitimate legal basis Principle of legality
- Legal scope of application is determined individually ( Constitutional organization)
- Any governmental body of any country can levy taxes
- All essential elements of must be laid down in the tax codes
- Tax statutes (or tax codes) What is taxed + who pays + tax rate (+ set of rules)
- National parliaments vote, amend, etc. tax statutes or (tax codes)
- E.g., Magna Charta (1215), UK Bill of Rights (1689), …
, Imposed by the public authority on its subjects
- Taxable subjects are individuals and legal persons
- Only taxpayers/civilians vote ( Legal persons don’t vote)
- Governments exercise authority in 2 ways Over persons + over territory
For purpose of public spending (in the public interest)
- In principle taxes can’t be reserved for only certain expenses
- Government is free to determine for which public purposes tax money is used
- The spending of governments is subject to parliamentary control ( Not directly)
- Dissuasive taxes Taxes are created + motivated by specific goals ( Climate, health, …)
- E.g., environmental taxes are mostly introduced to reduce emission gasses ( CO2)
- Direct link between tax rate and governmental spending is very rare in practice
Mandatory payment with no personal compensation
- Tax Unilateral payment for all subjects of a governmental authority
- No quid pro quo Government doesn’t owe taxpayer anything in return for payment
- Government has authority on all citizens and persons on its territory
What about social security contributions?
- Not taxes ( Legal perspective)
- Social security contributions are also mandatory payments imposed by law
- Paying SSC entitles contributor to specific social benefits ( Unlike taxes)
- Social protection against unemployment, illness, accidents, retirement, childcare, …
- Subjects Cut from the wages of the working population
- No direct proportional link between size of contributions and individual benefits
- Based on principle of solidarity and insurance ( You pay now & receive benefits later)
What about toll charges and fees?
- User fees and toll charges Payments for specific goods/services provided by government
- E.g., toll for driving on certain roads, tunnels, bridges, …
- Not taxes Clear and specific compensation for payment ( Quid pro quo)
- Price is unilaterally fixed by the public authority ( Public has no say)
- You can avoid them by not making use of the specific goods or services
2. Fundamental questions of taxation
Why do we tax and how do we tax?
- Why? The benefit principle
- Why? Principle of sovereignty
- How? Ability to pay + equality principle
- How? Principle of legality
- How? Efficiency
The benefit principle (Why?)
- Justifies taxation based on taxpayer’s usage of government goods/services
- Governmental goods/services provide a benefit to taxpayers Taxes are required
- Those who use and derive more benefits therefore must pay more taxes
, This goes against element of tax as mandatory payment without personal compensation
- Argument against the benefit principle
- Citizen is entitled to governmental services because he is citizen of that government
- Not because he pays taxes Presumed benefit of being a citizen
- Tax Unilateral payment without personal compensation
- E.g., general administration, police protection, national education, healthcare, …
The principle of sovereignty (Why?)
- Sovereignty Right of a state to regulate its (tax) affairs in the most suitable way
- Through use of governmental institutions Parliament, executive power, and judiciary
- Allows states to impose + enforce rules on/against persons connected to state territory
- Limited to state territory and people connected to state territory ( Nationals + residents)
- Relationship of subordination between government and taxpayers ( Justifies taxation)
- Only valid if legality principle is respected ( No taxation without representation)
Ability to pay principle + equality principle (How?)
- Ability to pay principle Tax rate must be in order with economic capacity of taxpayer
- Taxes must be equally distributed in function of income, wealth, and consumption
- Goes together with equality principle (= non-discrimination principle)
- Horizontal equity Persons in comparable economic situations pay the same tax
- Vertical equity Persons in different economic situations should not pay the same tax
- Implementing vertical equity Law of diminishing marginal utility
- Loss of utility of increasing income Progressive tax ( Higher income, higher tax)
- In practice Only personal income taxes are progressive
- Income taxes on companies are rarely progressive on the other hand ( One flat rate)
- Consumption taxes, in particular VAT, are also not the same for all goods
- Essential goods (food, non-alcoholic drinks, medicine, …) Low VAT
- Non-essential or luxury goods Higher VAT
The principle of legality (How?)
- Taxation is only possible in case of valid legal basis
- All essential elements of a tax must be determined by statutes
- Statutes (of a tax) are approved/declined by the parliament ( Majority voting)
- Impossible to provide all necessary details in the statutes of a tax ( Too complex)
- Supplementary to tax statutes Executive decrees, regulations, and rulings
- In case of disagreements Judicial power makes final decisions
The benefits of buying summaries with Stuvia:
Guaranteed quality through customer reviews
Stuvia customers have reviewed more than 700,000 summaries. This how you know that you are buying the best documents.
Quick and easy check-out
You can quickly pay through credit card or Stuvia-credit for the summaries. There is no membership needed.
Focus on what matters
Your fellow students write the study notes themselves, which is why the documents are always reliable and up-to-date. This ensures you quickly get to the core!
Frequently asked questions
What do I get when I buy this document?
You get a PDF, available immediately after your purchase. The purchased document is accessible anytime, anywhere and indefinitely through your profile.
Satisfaction guarantee: how does it work?
Our satisfaction guarantee ensures that you always find a study document that suits you well. You fill out a form, and our customer service team takes care of the rest.
Who am I buying these notes from?
Stuvia is a marketplace, so you are not buying this document from us, but from seller alexanderbollen. Stuvia facilitates payment to the seller.
Will I be stuck with a subscription?
No, you only buy these notes for $5.98. You're not tied to anything after your purchase.
Can Stuvia be trusted?
4.6 stars on Google & Trustpilot (+1000 reviews)
78252 documents were sold in the last 30 days
Founded in 2010, the go-to place to buy study notes for 14 years now