Een volledige samenvatting van het vak History of Education uit het schakeljaar/schakelprogramma van pedagogische wetenschappen met
zowel ALLE lessen/Powerpoints, als de uitleg van de prof
1 BIJHORENDE TEKSTEN BIJ THEMA’S .......................................................................................................... 5
1.1 GENERAL INTRO + FROM HISTORICISM TO HISTORICIZING ...................................................................................... 5
1.2 HUMANISM ................................................................................................................................................. 5
1.3 ENLIGHTENMENT .......................................................................................................................................... 5
1.4 SPECIAL EDUCATION ...................................................................................................................................... 5
1.5 REFORM PEDAGOGY ...................................................................................................................................... 5
1.6 COLONIAL EDUCATION ................................................................................................................................... 5
1.7 20TH CENTURY ............................................................................................................................................ 5
1.8 SILENCE AT SCHOOL ....................................................................................................................................... 5
2 GENERAL INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................................... 6
2.1 EDUCATIONALIZATION: TWO EXAMPLES............................................................................................................. 6
2.1.1 example 1: the educationalization of traffic education................................................................... 6
2.1.2 example 2: the educationalization of punishments ......................................................................... 7
2.1.3 what is educationalization?............................................................................................................. 8
2.2 THE TOTALLY PEDAGOGISED SOCIETY (BERNSTEIN)............................................................................................... 8
2.3 EDUCATIONALIZATON & EDUCATIONAL HISTORIOGRAPHY ..................................................................................... 9
2.4 EXTRA LITERATURE, VIDEOS AND WEBSITES (HC 1) ............................................................................................. 10
2.4.1 what is history for? ........................................................................................................................ 10
2.4.2 what’s the difference between history and the past? ................................................................... 10
2.4.3 The medicalization of current educational research ..................................................................... 10
2.4.4 history vs historiography ............................................................................................................... 11
2.5 TEXT POPKEWITZ (RETHINKING THE HISTORY OF EDUCATION) ............................................................................... 11
3 FROM HISTORICISM TO HISTORICIZING .................................................................................................. 12
3.1.1 presentism ..................................................................................................................................... 13
3.1.2 What brought about this historiographical evolution? (from historicism to historicizing) ........... 13
3.2 NEW CULTURAL HISTORY OF EDUCATION (NCHO) .............................................................................................. 14
3.2.1 characteristics of NCHE ................................................................................................................. 14
3.2.2 historical/educational ................................................................................................................... 14
3.3 THE THREE DUTIES OF THE HISTORIAN OF EDUCATION ......................................................................................... 14
4 HUMANISM & THE DISCOVERY OF CHILHOOD ........................................................................................ 15
4.1 WHEN AND WHERE DOES HISTORY OF EDUCATION START? .................................................................................. 15
4.2 HUMANISM ............................................................................................................................................... 15
4.2.1 rise of different denominations = societal context ........................................................................ 15
4.2.2 desiderius erasmus on education .................................................................................................. 15
4.2.2.1 main characteristics of humanism ............................................................................................................. 15
4.2.3 michel the montaigne on education .............................................................................................. 16
4.2.4 Education in the low countries during Middle Ages and Humanism ............................................. 16
4.2.5 Juan Luis Vives and the reconfiguration of poverty relief .............................................................. 16
4.3 EXTRA LITERATURE, VIDEOS AND WEBSITES (HC 2) ............................................................................................. 17
4.3.1 philosophy (michel de montaigne) ................................................................................................ 17
4.3.2 social construction of childhood .................................................................................................... 17
5 THE ENLIGHTENMENT: A BREAKING POINT IN THE HISTORY OF EDUCATION? ........................................ 18
1
, 5.1 PURPOSE OF THIS CLASS ............................................................................................................................... 18
5.2 ENLIGHTENMENT: DEFINITION ....................................................................................................................... 18
5.3 WHAT IS ENLIGHTENMENT? .......................................................................................................................... 18
5.4 RADICALLY NEW OR RELATIVELY OLD? → ON THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN THE ENLIGHTENMENT AND HUMANISM ......... 19
5.5 REASON OR PERCEPTION → HOW TO ACQUIRE TRUTH AND KNOWLEDGE ............................................................... 20
5.5.1 strands of the enlightenment ........................................................................................................ 20
5.6 A THEORY OF MIND → JOHN LOCKE AND THE TABULA RASA................................................................................. 20
5.6.1 John Locke (1632-1704) ................................................................................................................. 20
5.6.2 Some thoughts concerning education (1693) – John locke ........................................................... 20
5.7 HISTORY OF EDUCATION FOR THE DISABLED → THE EMERGENCE AND DEVELOPMENT OF EDUCATIONAL INSITUTES FOR THE
DISABLED .............................................................................................................................................................. 21
5.7.1 idiots in cages ................................................................................................................................ 21
5.7.2 the first initiatives .......................................................................................................................... 21
5.7.3 educating the mentally disabled ................................................................................................... 21
5.8 THE MODERNISATION OF EDUCATION: EDUCATION IN THE ‘AGE OF REASON’/ENLIGHTENMENT .................................. 21
5.8.1 the politics of education ................................................................................................................ 21
5.8.2 ‘modern education’ ....................................................................................................................... 22
5.8.3 sustainable reforms? ..................................................................................................................... 22
5.9 IMPACT OF THE ENLIGHTENMENT → THE INFLUENCE OF THE ENLIGHTENMENT ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE
EDUCATIONAL SYSTEM IN THE 19TH AND 20TH CENTURY ............................................................................................... 22
5.9.1 the ‘enlightened’ school? .............................................................................................................. 22
5.9.2 de-mythologizing the enlightenment ............................................................................................ 23
5.9.3 the emergence of an educational paradox.................................................................................... 23
6 JEAN-JACQUES ROUSSEAU, EDUCATION AND THE CONSTRUCTION OF HUMAN DIFFERENCES ............... 24
6.1 ENLIGHTENMENT AND PEDAGOGICAL OPTIMISM ............................................................................................... 24
6.2 JEAN-JACQUES ROUSSEAU: MAN OF NATURE & CULTURAL PESSIMISM (<-> THE ENLIGHTENMENT).............................. 25
6.2.1 civilization as ‘unavoidable’........................................................................................................... 26
6.2.2 negative education ........................................................................................................................ 26
6.3 JEAN-JACQUES ROUSSEAU AND HAPPINESS CF. TEXT OF TAL GILEAD IN THE READER ................................................. 27
6.3.1 a brief history of happiness ........................................................................................................... 27
6.3.2 history as criticism ......................................................................................................................... 27
7 SPECIAL EDUCATION ............................................................................................................................... 28
7.1 JEAN-MARC ITARD AND THE WILD BOY OF AVEYRON ........................................................................................... 28
7.2 EDOUARD SÉGUIN, PHRENOLOGY AND EDUCABILITY ........................................................................................... 29
7.3 ENLIGHTENMENT, COLONIALISM & HUMAN DIFFERENCES ................................................................................... 29
7.4 RETRACING THE EMERGENCE OF SPECIAL EDUCATION AROUND 1800 .................................................................... 29
7.4.1 structure of the argument (how it shifted throughout time) ........................................................ 30
7.4.2 preliminary remark ........................................................................................................................ 30
7.4.3 humanitarian & historical materialist accounts ............................................................................ 30
7.4.3.1 father of the “deaf-mute” ......................................................................................................................... 30
7.4.3.2 father of the “blind” .................................................................................................................................. 30
7.4.4 humanitarian account ................................................................................................................... 31
7.4.5 historical material interpretation .................................................................................................. 31
7.4.6 two counter-arguments................................................................................................................. 31
7.5 TAKING A DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVE: PROBLEMATIZATION ..................................................................................... 32
7.5.1 what’s in a name? ......................................................................................................................... 32
7.5.2 what causes it? .............................................................................................................................. 32
7.5.3 the necessity of reproblematization .............................................................................................. 32
2
, 7.5.4 three important ideas.................................................................................................................... 33
7.5.5 a different set of questions: ........................................................................................................... 33
7.5.6 emotions ........................................................................................................................................ 33
7.5.6.1 sollitude ..................................................................................................................................................... 33
7.5.6.2 happiness ................................................................................................................................................... 33
7.5.7 a heated 19th century discussion .................................................................................................. 34
7.5.8 what does these texts tell us? ....................................................................................................... 34
7.6 FROM SATISFACTION TO COMPLIANCE ............................................................................................................. 35
7.7 CONCLUSIONS ............................................................................................................................................ 35
8.1 IN THE VIEWPOINT OF PESTALOZZI: WHY SHOULD WE CARE ABOUT THE PAST IF IT’S GONE? ....................................... 35
8.2 PESTALOZZI’S ‘MODERNITY’ .......................................................................................................................... 36
8.2.1 (1) the economic upswing in the crisis of classical republicanism ................................................. 36
8.2.2 (2) education as strengthening the soul ........................................................................................ 38
8.2.3 (3) the invention of modern education as solution to the problem ............................................... 39
8.2.4 (4) the rising the nation-states after 1815 as educational projects .............................................. 40
8.2.5 (5) pestalozzi’s ‘actuality’ or ‘topicality’ ........................................................................................ 41
9 REFORM PEDAGOGY, NEW EDUCATIONAL MOVEMENT & GRAMMAR OF SCHOOLING .......................... 43
9.1 MARIA MONTESSORI ................................................................................................................................... 43
9.1.1 main characteristics of progressive education .............................................................................. 44
9.1.2 necessity of school reform ............................................................................................................. 44
9.1.3 metaphor of the school desk ......................................................................................................... 44
9.1.4 rewards and punishments ............................................................................................................. 45
9.1.5 she shifts the emphasis from government to self-government ..................................................... 45
9.1.6 vrijheid, macht & casa dei bambini ............................................................................................... 45
9.1.7 context: emancipation of women .................................................................................................. 46
9.1.8 beschavingsoffensief ..................................................................................................................... 46
9.1.9 grammar of schooling ................................................................................................................... 46
9.1.10 progressive education is not a monolothic whole! ........................................................................ 46
9.2 CONCLUSIONS ............................................................................................................................................ 47
9.3 PRELIMINARY REMARK ................................................................................................................................. 48
10 EMANCIPATION OR CIVILIZATION? HISTORY OF EDUCATION IN BELGIAN-CONGO (1908-1960).......... 48
10.1 CONTEMPORARY DISCUSSIONS ...................................................................................................................... 48
10.2 (1) SOME HISTORICAL CONTEXT ..................................................................................................................... 49
10.2.1 the memory of congo .................................................................................................................... 50
10.3 (2) EDUCATION DURING CONGO-FREESTATE .................................................................................................... 50
10.3.1 close cooperation between the state and the church ................................................................... 50
10.3.2 ambitions of the catholic mission?! ............................................................................................... 50
10.3.3 tangible heritage & local cultures ................................................................................................. 51
10.3.4 main eambitions of education in congo-freestate ........................................................................ 51
10.4 (3) EDUCATION DURING BELGIAN COLONIZATION .............................................................................................. 51
10.4.1 the curriculum ............................................................................................................................... 52
10.4.2 ‘the congo’ in belgian manuals ..................................................................................................... 52
10.5 EXERCISE: DE BOE’S MOVOE LEPROSY......................................................................................................... 53
10.6 CONCLUSION ............................................................................................................................................. 53
11 AUTHORITARIAN AND ANTI-AUTHORITARIAN PEDAGOGY (IN THE 20TH CENTURY) ........................... 54
3
, 11.1 A CALL FOR MOREE AUTHORITY...................................................................................................................... 54
11.2 EDUCATION: A CONTINUUM OF FREEDOM AND AUTHORITY ................................................................................. 54
11.3 TWO EXTREME POSITIONS ON THE CONTINUUM OF AUTHORITY ............................................................................ 55
11.3.1 fascist regimes and authoritarian education ................................................................................ 55
11.3.1.1 he who has the youth, has the future … ............................................................................................... 55
11.3.1.2 fascist curricula ..................................................................................................................................... 56
11.3.1.3 the banality of evil/authority ................................................................................................................ 56
11.3.2 anti-authoritarian pedagogy ......................................................................................................... 56
11.3.2.1 summerhill ............................................................................................................................................ 57
11.3.3 montessori & communism/socialist thinking ................................................................................ 57
11.4 CONCLUSIONS ............................................................................................................................................ 57
12 MOVIE: BOUNDLESSLY DIFFERENT ...................................................................................................... 58
13 LISTENING TO SOUNDS AND SILENCES IN THE HISTORY OF EDUCATION ............................................. 58
13.1 THE SCHOOL BELL & THE SILENCE CHAIR .......................................................................................................... 58
13.2 CLASS STRUCTURE ....................................................................................................................................... 58
13.3 SOUND STUDIES AND SOUND HISTORIES .......................................................................................................... 59
13.3.1 origin of sound studies: soundscape.............................................................................................. 59
13.3.2 sound studies ................................................................................................................................. 59
13.3.2.1 an example: the sound ear .................................................................................................................... 60
13.3.3 sound histories .............................................................................................................................. 60
13.4 SOUNDS, SILENCES & THE HISTORIOGRAPHY OF EDUCATION ................................................................................ 60
13.4.1 sounds, silences & the new cultural history of education.............................................................. 60
13.4.2 landahl’s “sound of authority” ...................................................................................................... 61
13.5 SOME HISTORIAL EXAMPLES OF SILENCE’S EDUCATIONAL VALUE ........................................................................... 61
13.5.1 1) the rise of silent classrooms ...................................................................................................... 61
13.5.2 2) maria montessori (1905) ........................................................................................................... 62
13.5.3 3) how quiet helps at school (1953) .............................................................................................. 63
13.5.3.1 (neo-)liberal power and silence............................................................................................................. 63
13.5.4 4) a.s. neill (1960) .......................................................................................................................... 64
13.5.4.1 noise @ summerhill .............................................................................................................................. 64
13.6 CONCLUSIONS: THE EDUCATIONALIZATION OF SILENCE?! .................................................................................... 64
13.7 THINGS YOU DEFINITELY SHOULD REMEMBER! .................................................................................................. 64
4
The benefits of buying summaries with Stuvia:
Guaranteed quality through customer reviews
Stuvia customers have reviewed more than 700,000 summaries. This how you know that you are buying the best documents.
Quick and easy check-out
You can quickly pay through credit card or Stuvia-credit for the summaries. There is no membership needed.
Focus on what matters
Your fellow students write the study notes themselves, which is why the documents are always reliable and up-to-date. This ensures you quickly get to the core!
Frequently asked questions
What do I get when I buy this document?
You get a PDF, available immediately after your purchase. The purchased document is accessible anytime, anywhere and indefinitely through your profile.
Satisfaction guarantee: how does it work?
Our satisfaction guarantee ensures that you always find a study document that suits you well. You fill out a form, and our customer service team takes care of the rest.
Who am I buying these notes from?
Stuvia is a marketplace, so you are not buying this document from us, but from seller ankemathijs. Stuvia facilitates payment to the seller.
Will I be stuck with a subscription?
No, you only buy these notes for $16.71. You're not tied to anything after your purchase.
