Summary literature Analysis of Governmental Policy (AM_470571)
61 views 0 purchase
Course
Analysis of Governmental Policy (AM_470571)
Institution
Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam (VU)
Book
Making Health Policy
This is a summary of all the mandatory literature for the course Analysis of Governmental Policy that is necessary to make the exam and for the assignment.
Everything needed for AGP exam Goodnotes - book + knowledge clips + lectures + Q&A's - 8.3 gehaald
Samenvatting Making Health Policy - Policy, Management and Organization (AM_470819)
Summary knowledge clips Analysis of Governmental Policy (AM_470571)
All for this textbook (9)
Written for
Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam (VU)
Master MPA
Analysis of Governmental Policy (AM_470571)
All documents for this subject (2)
Seller
Follow
yaralangeveld
Reviews received
Content preview
Making health policy - Buse, Mays & Walt (2012)
Chapter 1: The health policy framework
Epistemic community = policy community that is marked by shared political values and a shared
understanding of a problem and its causes.
Policy = decisions taken by policy makers for a given policy area at a certain level (national/local).
→ private policy: policies within companies within the boundaries of public, governmental law.
→ public policy: government policy to accomplish a purpose or goal or resolve a problem.
Policy problem = (1) gap between the ideal world and current reality, (2) unclear reason for this
difference, (3) there should be more than one possible solution to the problem.
Means = (instruments) series of intended activities with certain consequences → types: judicial
(legislation), economic (subsidies/taxes), communication (persuasion), modern (self-regulation).
Health policy = actions that affect institutions, organisations, services and funding arrangements
of health care systems → involves public and private policies.
Health policy triangle ( figure right) = looking at the content of policy,
processes of policy making and how power is used in a health policy context.
(a) actors: individuals, organisations, groups, states → inside
government; members of parliament, ministers → outside
government; groups that don’t seek political power, BUT influence
policy making (FEX. NGOs and private companies).
→ macro level: political (government/municipality that steers the whole society) -> meso level:
institutional (groups of people/private companies) -> micro level: societal (individuals).
→ extent to which actors can influence policy depends on their power = mixture of individual
wealth, personality and level of or access to knowledge and authority.
(b) context: systemic factors that may have an effect on health policy → types of factors:
(i) situational: temporary conditions or focusing events → FEX. droughts and wars.
(ii) structural: unchanging elements of society → FEX. the type of economy and
employment base, demographic features and technological advances.
(iii) cultural: religion, tradition and social values → FEX. formal hierarchies, difficult
access to health services or a disease stigma.
(iv) international/exogenous: interdependence between states, influencing
sovereignty and international cooperation → FEX. help of WHO in fighting polio.
(c) process: stages of policy making; problem identification, policy formulation, policy
implementation, policy evaluation, feedback and policy termination.
(d) content: what is the issue and why is something not working? → conducting FEX. data
analysis, actor chart, labeling, causal analysis.
Chapter 10: Doing policy analysis
Crowdsourcing = raise suggestions from the public via social media to decide a course of action.
2 types of policy analysis:
1. Retrospective analysis: learning from the past → analysis of existing policy.
2. Prospective analysis: advicing the present → analysis for new policy, change and reform.
Influences of policy outcomes on: problems, agenda-setting, political windows of opportunity and
positions, interests and power of interested parties.
→ legislators are influenced by: direct contacts (FEX. lobbyists and business coalitions), ideologies
and beliefs, consumers and the media.
Stakeholder analysis = steps:
, (a) identifying policy actors: relevant actors that are likely to be affected by a policy.
(b) assessing their political resources: access to tangible (finance) and intangible (expertise)
resources increases a stakeholders’ influence in the policy process.
(c) assessing their position, interests and commitment: supportive, neutral or opposed.
→ there is a relation between power and position → actors might shift to higher and lower power
positions → especially the neutral power group.
→ downside: it only provides data on actors and reveals little about the context and process of
policy making, which plays an important role in policy change.
→ for a greater number of actors, more useful to do a social network analysis = mapping,
measuring and analysing the social relationships between people, groups and organisations.
Alternative strategy for policy change: determine the position of relevant actors, the power of
political resources, the number of players involved, and the perception of stakeholders of the
problem and solution.
Types of data for a policy analysis:
- Policy documents: that explain/predict policy change → evidence on contextual
variables, actors, content and process.
- People: through semi-structured interviews → limitation; doesn’t concern what people
actually think or do, but what they say and how they say it (subjective info).
- Social media: valuable info about stakeholders' positions, interests and commitments.
Data analysis: policy analysis triangle → review all components → analysis for policy may raise
ethical issues: FEX. can a group participate in a policy process to create a more powerful
coalition? or can you withhold info from the public for tactical purposes?
Chapter 4: Agenda setting
Agenda setting models:
- Rational model = choose what is important → BUT this may differ per group.
- Hall model = 3 features; legitimacy (have to), feasibility (can we), support (will we).
- Kingdon’s stream model = policy window = agenda setting opportunities → policies are
only taken into account by governments when 3 streams run together:
1. problem stream: perceptions of public problems that require government action.
2. policy stream: ongoing analysis of problems, proposed solutions and debates.
3. politics stream: events, like changes of government and campaigns done by
interest groups.
- Hogwood & Gunn approach = issue search, anticipate before problems turn into crisis.
- Shiffman & Smith’s model = policy making influenced by; actor power (strength of actors),
ideas (how they portray), characteristics (featuring problems) and context (environment
actors) → internal frame = policy stream, external frame = politics stream.
Agenda setting in “politics-as-usual” circumstances: response to routine, day-to-day problems.
→ requirements for an issue: (a) legitimacy (right/obligation to intervene), (b) feasibility
(potential for implementing the policy), (c) support (public support for the government).
Agenda setting in crisis circumstances: easier to get radical policies considered.
Non-policy making: FEX. radical market reforms of health care systems rarely changed the
monopoly control and cannot initiate treatment and prescribe drugs for patients.
Agenda setters: government (national and international) and the mass media (propaganda).
Factors shaping political priority: policy community cohesion - leadership - civil society
mobilisation - internal frame (community agreement) - external frame (public portrayals of an
issue) - severity - effective interventions - policy windows - global governance structure.
The benefits of buying summaries with Stuvia:
Guaranteed quality through customer reviews
Stuvia customers have reviewed more than 700,000 summaries. This how you know that you are buying the best documents.
Quick and easy check-out
You can quickly pay through credit card or Stuvia-credit for the summaries. There is no membership needed.
Focus on what matters
Your fellow students write the study notes themselves, which is why the documents are always reliable and up-to-date. This ensures you quickly get to the core!
Frequently asked questions
What do I get when I buy this document?
You get a PDF, available immediately after your purchase. The purchased document is accessible anytime, anywhere and indefinitely through your profile.
Satisfaction guarantee: how does it work?
Our satisfaction guarantee ensures that you always find a study document that suits you well. You fill out a form, and our customer service team takes care of the rest.
Who am I buying these notes from?
Stuvia is a marketplace, so you are not buying this document from us, but from seller yaralangeveld. Stuvia facilitates payment to the seller.
Will I be stuck with a subscription?
No, you only buy these notes for $3.53. You're not tied to anything after your purchase.
