Tort Law - A Summary of the New Textbook for Global Law (2024)
72 views 4 purchases
Course
Tort Law (620290B6)
Institution
Tilburg University (UVT)
Book
Tort Law
These notes are a summary of the new textbook for the Global Law course by Professor Tjong Tjin Tai. They include summaries of the main concepts, processes and laws from all chapters (excluding Chapter 16 - Tort law around the world - which you will likely not need for the exam).
The notes are ...
Tort law - the law of non-contractual liability
o The tortfeasor must compensate the person who suffered damages as a result of
wrongful conduct (usually in the form of damages)
o Rules of tort law build on the intuition that the tortfeasor has committed a
wrongful act
o Injury on its own does not create liability
o The interests of individuals to act freely must be balanced against the interests of
others not to be harmed
o Primary aim of tort law is reparation – restitutio in integro – restoring the victim to
the previous state of affairs. Corrective justice, as opposed to distributive justice.
Other potential aims: satisfaction; recognition of wrongdoing
Elements of liability in most tort cases
o Fault
Wrongful conduct (act or omission) by a tortfeasor
Sub-elements in German and Dutch law:
1. Wrongfulness (unlawfulness) of the act (objective fault) – the act
should not have occurred
2. Accountability or culpability (subjective fault) – the act is the
‘fault’ of the person; they are culpable, accountable
o Exceptions, such as involuntary reactions out of fright, are
applicable
o Subjective culpability is often in question due to lack of
capacity to make a mature judgement (age)
o Some kinds of torts require intention in addition to
negligence. (e.g. battery in English law)
o Malice – used in common law for some torts – aimed at
causing harm to the victim (difference between malice and
intention is like between murder and manslaughter)
There are forms of liability that do not require fault (e.g., liability for
lawful acts, such as tearing down a house to prepare for a military defence,
eminent domain, expropriation)
o Harm
Injury to an interest, such as harm to material interests (damage to a car,
injury to a person)
, Defined in reference to interests
German BGB states which interests are protected for certain grounds of
liability
o Causal connection between fault and harm
Harm is caused by the fault; the injury is a result of the wrongful conduct
Causality involves two different, cumulative conditions:
1. Factual causation, for establishing a causal connection
o Condition sine qua non (c.s.q.n.) or ‘but for’ test in English
law
2. Legal causation, for limiting the extent of liability
o Compensation is not awarded for losses that are too far
removed from the act
o Precise criterion varies: remoteness (England); direct and
immediate consequence (France); adequacy (Germany);
proximate cause (USA)
o Remedies
Award of damages (sum of money paid by the defendant to the claimant)
Court order (such as an injunction) – requires the defendant to perform an
action or to refrain from certain conduct
Declaration of rights – the court declares that someone is liable without
awarding damages or other remedies (may serve as a basis for further
negotiations or provide moral satisfaction)
Others are usually variations of the above. I.e., an injunction could be the
requirement to rectify a public statement
Systems of tort law in France, Germany and
England
France – fault liability
, Art 1240 Cc – “Any human act that causes damage to another obliges the person by
whose fault it occurred to repair it”
Art 1241 Cc – “Everyone is liable for the damage they have caused not only by
intentional acts, but also by negligent conduct or by imprudence”
o ‘Fault, cause and damage’ not explained
o No explicit requirement for subjective fault
Categories of fault are not expressly stated in the articles
o Explicitly written duties
Written rules proscribing certain behavior (statutes, other rules)
Protection of subjective rights (others’ rights)
o Unwritten rules
Unwritten non-contractual duties – determined by courts; similar to
English tort of negligence
Abuse of right – intentional actions intended to harm another person
o
Incompetence of the tortfeasor is not an excuse, tortfeasor is presumed accountable for
his actions. Mentally disabled adults are not exempt (art. 414-3 Cc). Art. 1240 is
applied directly to children using an objective standard as well.
Causality is not defined, but case law established a need for c.s.q.n. connection and
legal causality (damage must be immediate and direct – art 1231-4 Cc, derived from
contract law)
Multiple tortfeasors are jointly and severally liable, i.e., liable for the whole obligation
and held to contribute for their fair share (arts 1313 and 1317 Cc)
Classification of kinds of fault in France
o
Causality in French law – required by Art. 1240 Cc, but only established in case law:
o C.s.q.n.-connection is required; legal causality as well – damage must be
‘immediate and direct’ (Art. 1231-4 Cc) to be compensated. Derived from
contract law, extends to torts.
Multiple tortfeasors
The benefits of buying summaries with Stuvia:
Guaranteed quality through customer reviews
Stuvia customers have reviewed more than 700,000 summaries. This how you know that you are buying the best documents.
Quick and easy check-out
You can quickly pay through credit card or Stuvia-credit for the summaries. There is no membership needed.
Focus on what matters
Your fellow students write the study notes themselves, which is why the documents are always reliable and up-to-date. This ensures you quickly get to the core!
Frequently asked questions
What do I get when I buy this document?
You get a PDF, available immediately after your purchase. The purchased document is accessible anytime, anywhere and indefinitely through your profile.
Satisfaction guarantee: how does it work?
Our satisfaction guarantee ensures that you always find a study document that suits you well. You fill out a form, and our customer service team takes care of the rest.
Who am I buying these notes from?
Stuvia is a marketplace, so you are not buying this document from us, but from seller GlobalLawyer. Stuvia facilitates payment to the seller.
Will I be stuck with a subscription?
No, you only buy these notes for $22.37. You're not tied to anything after your purchase.
