SJD1501
Assignment 5
(COMPLETE
ANSWERS)
Semester 1 2024
(643092) - DUE
5 May 2024
, Let’s consider the cases of Hillary Gardee and Bokgabo Poo, which were
discussed in Unit 5. These tragic events involve numerous alleged crimes. At
the forefront is gender-based violence, which is discussed throughout our
units. Please provide your own opinion on the following: 1. Who are the
criminal justice system role-players in the trial and post-trial phases? Please
describe their roles and what parts they play in these two cases. (300 words,
10 marks)
In the trials and post-trial phases of cases like those of Hillary Gardee and Bokgabo Poo, the
criminal justice system involves various role-players, each with distinct responsibilities aimed at
ensuring justice is served. Let's examine the roles they play in these two cases:
1. Judges: Judges preside over the trials, ensuring that proceedings are conducted fairly and
according to the law. They make rulings on admissibility of evidence, instruct the jury,
and ultimately deliver the verdict. In the post-trial phase, judges may also oversee
sentencing and appeals.
2. Prosecutors: Prosecutors represent the state and are responsible for presenting the case
against the accused. They gather evidence, question witnesses, and make arguments to
convince the jury of the defendant's guilt. In cases involving gender-based violence like
those of Gardee and Poo, prosecutors play a crucial role in advocating for the victims and
seeking justice on their behalf.
3. Defense Attorneys: Defense attorneys represent the accused and ensure their rights are
protected throughout the legal process. They challenge the prosecution's evidence, cross-
examine witnesses, and make arguments in favor of their client's innocence. In cases of
gender-based violence, defense attorneys may attempt to challenge the credibility of the
victim's testimony or argue for mitigating circumstances.
4. Jury: The jury, composed of impartial members of the community, listens to the
evidence presented by both sides and deliberates to reach a verdict. In cases involving
gender-based violence, jurors must carefully consider the evidence and testimony to
determine the guilt or innocence of the accused.
5. Law Enforcement: Law enforcement officers investigate the crimes, gather evidence,
and arrest suspects. Their role is crucial in building the case for prosecution and ensuring
that perpetrators are brought to justice.
6. Victim Advocates: Victim advocates provide support and assistance to the victims
throughout the legal process. They help victims understand their rights, navigate the court
system, and access resources such as counseling and shelter.
In cases like those of Gardee and Poo, where gender-based violence is alleged, each of these
role-players must fulfill their responsibilities diligently to ensure that justice is served and that
victims are provided with the support they need to heal and move forward.
2. Who are the primary and secondary victims in these two cases? Please
explain your answer. (300 words, 10 marks)
Assignment 5
(COMPLETE
ANSWERS)
Semester 1 2024
(643092) - DUE
5 May 2024
, Let’s consider the cases of Hillary Gardee and Bokgabo Poo, which were
discussed in Unit 5. These tragic events involve numerous alleged crimes. At
the forefront is gender-based violence, which is discussed throughout our
units. Please provide your own opinion on the following: 1. Who are the
criminal justice system role-players in the trial and post-trial phases? Please
describe their roles and what parts they play in these two cases. (300 words,
10 marks)
In the trials and post-trial phases of cases like those of Hillary Gardee and Bokgabo Poo, the
criminal justice system involves various role-players, each with distinct responsibilities aimed at
ensuring justice is served. Let's examine the roles they play in these two cases:
1. Judges: Judges preside over the trials, ensuring that proceedings are conducted fairly and
according to the law. They make rulings on admissibility of evidence, instruct the jury,
and ultimately deliver the verdict. In the post-trial phase, judges may also oversee
sentencing and appeals.
2. Prosecutors: Prosecutors represent the state and are responsible for presenting the case
against the accused. They gather evidence, question witnesses, and make arguments to
convince the jury of the defendant's guilt. In cases involving gender-based violence like
those of Gardee and Poo, prosecutors play a crucial role in advocating for the victims and
seeking justice on their behalf.
3. Defense Attorneys: Defense attorneys represent the accused and ensure their rights are
protected throughout the legal process. They challenge the prosecution's evidence, cross-
examine witnesses, and make arguments in favor of their client's innocence. In cases of
gender-based violence, defense attorneys may attempt to challenge the credibility of the
victim's testimony or argue for mitigating circumstances.
4. Jury: The jury, composed of impartial members of the community, listens to the
evidence presented by both sides and deliberates to reach a verdict. In cases involving
gender-based violence, jurors must carefully consider the evidence and testimony to
determine the guilt or innocence of the accused.
5. Law Enforcement: Law enforcement officers investigate the crimes, gather evidence,
and arrest suspects. Their role is crucial in building the case for prosecution and ensuring
that perpetrators are brought to justice.
6. Victim Advocates: Victim advocates provide support and assistance to the victims
throughout the legal process. They help victims understand their rights, navigate the court
system, and access resources such as counseling and shelter.
In cases like those of Gardee and Poo, where gender-based violence is alleged, each of these
role-players must fulfill their responsibilities diligently to ensure that justice is served and that
victims are provided with the support they need to heal and move forward.
2. Who are the primary and secondary victims in these two cases? Please
explain your answer. (300 words, 10 marks)
