STRAFRECHT EN MENSENRECHTEN
Tilburg University 2023-2014
,Inhoudsopgave
WEEK 1: INTRODUCTIE & RECHT OP EEN EERLIJK PROCES...............................................................................5
Hoorcollege..........................................................................................................................................................5
Europeanisering van het straf(proces)recht....................................................................................................6
Nederlandse straf(proces) en het EVRM.........................................................................................................7
Pijnpunten in Nederland..................................................................................................................................8
Artikel 17 Grondwet.........................................................................................................................................9
Artikel 6 EVRM: introductie...........................................................................................................................10
Het toepassingsbereik van artikel 6 EVRM....................................................................................................11
Recht op rechtsbijstand.................................................................................................................................13
Salduz t. Turkije..............................................................................................................................................14
De discussie in Nederland..............................................................................................................................15
De ontwikkelingen na Salduz.........................................................................................................................17
Besluit Inrichting en orde politieverhoor.......................................................................................................19
Meer recente rechtspraak.............................................................................................................................20
Van de Kolk t. Nederland (EHRM 28 mei 2019).............................................................................................20
De gevolgen van een schending....................................................................................................................21
Atristain Gorosabel t. Spanje (EHRM 18 januari 2022)..................................................................................22
Aanwezigheidsrecht.......................................................................................................................................22
M. Lochs, ‘Geen coulance maar recht: de actieve raadsman bij het politieverhoor’, Boom Strafblad 2021, alf.
4..........................................................................................................................................................................23
EHRM 28 mei 2019, 23192/15 (Van de Kolk t. Nederland)................................................................................28
EHRM 18 januari 2022, 15508/15, EHRC-2022-0039 (Atristain Gorosabel t. Spanje).......................................29
EHRM 14 februari 2017, 30749/12 (Hokkeling t. Nederland)...........................................................................30
EHRM 8 juni 2021, nr. 61591/16 (Dijkhuizen t. Nederland)..............................................................................30
EHRM 27 juli 2021, nr. 72631/17 (X t. Nederland)............................................................................................31
Hoorcollege........................................................................................................................................................32
De verhouding tot andere mensenrechten (art. 3 EVRM).............................................................................36
De verhouding tot andere mensenrechten (art. 2 EVRM).............................................................................37
Excessief politiegeweld..................................................................................................................................38
Levenslange gevangenisstraf.........................................................................................................................38
Detentieomstandigheden..............................................................................................................................40
, Uitlevering en uitzetten: non-refoulement....................................................................................................41
Gäfgen t. Duitsland (2010).................................................................................................................................42
Vinter e.a. t. het Verenigd Koninkrijk (2013)......................................................................................................42
Bouyid t. België (2015).......................................................................................................................................43
Murray t. Nederland (2016)...............................................................................................................................43
D. t Letland (2024)..............................................................................................................................................43
Hoge Raad van 23 juni 2020, ECLI:NL:HR:2020:1092 (incl. conclusie)...............................................................44
WEEK 3: PRIVACY EN STRAFRECHT I.............................................................................................................. 45
Hoorcollege........................................................................................................................................................45
Het mensenrechtelijk kader...........................................................................................................................45
Artikel 8 EVRM...............................................................................................................................................46
De beperkingssystematiek van artikel 8 lid 2 EVRM......................................................................................47
Het Nederlandse strafvorderlijke kader........................................................................................................48
Artikel 8 lid 2 EVRM: bij wet voorzien...........................................................................................................49
Datagedreven opsporing...............................................................................................................................53
Het Wetboek van Strafvordering en de Wet Politiegegevens.......................................................................55
EHRM Big Brother Watch...............................................................................................................................55
Jurisprudentie.....................................................................................................................................................57
HR 4 april 2017, ECLI:NL:HR:2017:584 (Smartphone)...................................................................................57
EHRM 25 mei 2021, ECLI:CE:ECHR:2021:0525… (Big Brother Watch e.a. t. VK)...........................................58
WEEK 4: PRIVACY EN STRAFRECHT II............................................................................................................. 64
Hoorcollege........................................................................................................................................................64
Digital right Ierland........................................................................................................................................64
Tele2 Sverige/Watson....................................................................................................................................65
Ministerio Fiscal.............................................................................................................................................66
Prokuratuur (HvJ 2 maart 2021)....................................................................................................................67
Abortus..........................................................................................................................................................69
EHRM A, B en C/Ierland.................................................................................................................................70
Hoorcollege........................................................................................................................................................72
Artikel 5 EVRM (het recht op vrijheid)...........................................................................................................74
De voorlopige hechtenis................................................................................................................................74
Motiveringseisen van de VH..........................................................................................................................76
, De kritiek........................................................................................................................................................77
Detentie, vervangende hechtenis en gijzeling...............................................................................................78
De voorwaardelijke invrijheidsstelling...........................................................................................................80
Tbs, ISD en de zorgmachtiging.......................................................................................................................82
Hoorcollege........................................................................................................................................................85
Criterium voor de toepasbaarheid................................................................................................................86
De ratio..........................................................................................................................................................89
Een nationaal NT-beginsel?............................................................................................................................91
Hoorcollege......................................................................................................................................................105
Het mensenrecht.........................................................................................................................................106
De onschuldpresumptie in Nederland.........................................................................................................107
De twee beginselen.....................................................................................................................................109
Het bewijsbeginsel in het Nederlandse strafrecht......................................................................................114
Bejegening in het Nederlandse strafrecht...................................................................................................115
WEEK 9: RECHT OP EEN EERLIJK PROCES IN DE RECHTSPRAKTIJK.................................................................118
Inleiding.......................................................................................................................................................118
Getuigen......................................................................................................................................................120
De redelijke termijn.....................................................................................................................................122
Aanwezigheidsrecht.....................................................................................................................................123
Procesafspraken...........................................................................................................................................124
Verschoningsrecht.......................................................................................................................................125
The benefits of buying summaries with Stuvia:
Guaranteed quality through customer reviews
Stuvia customers have reviewed more than 700,000 summaries. This how you know that you are buying the best documents.
Quick and easy check-out
You can quickly pay through credit card or Stuvia-credit for the summaries. There is no membership needed.
Focus on what matters
Your fellow students write the study notes themselves, which is why the documents are always reliable and up-to-date. This ensures you quickly get to the core!
Frequently asked questions
What do I get when I buy this document?
You get a PDF, available immediately after your purchase. The purchased document is accessible anytime, anywhere and indefinitely through your profile.
Satisfaction guarantee: how does it work?
Our satisfaction guarantee ensures that you always find a study document that suits you well. You fill out a form, and our customer service team takes care of the rest.
Who am I buying these notes from?
Stuvia is a marketplace, so you are not buying this document from us, but from seller meekevanterwisga. Stuvia facilitates payment to the seller.
Will I be stuck with a subscription?
No, you only buy these notes for $17.66. You're not tied to anything after your purchase.