Essay
The Merchants Tale and An ideal Husband comparison
- Course
- Institution
A Level English Lit OCR - The Merchants Tale By Chaucer and An ideal Husband by Wilde Comparison Essay plans
[Show more]
Seller
Follow
annabellag24
Content preview
Use/misuse of Powerneg aspects of power (Robert)
● W presents Robs desire for power as clouding his judgement and corrupting his
moral compass in AIH
● In committing a fraudulent act in his youth in order to acquire ‘exactly what I
wanted, power over others’ Rob effectively ensures the inevitability of his ruin once
his unsavoury act is revealed
● Through presenting Rob as having to fights against the threat of ‘public scandal’ +
the potential breakdown of his marriage in response to him having ‘bought success
at a .. price’ W highlights impacts of an overt desire for power on happiness. In
exploring powers ability to corrupt through plays that were presented to the upper
echelons of a nineteenth century society that celebrates status + power. W
encourages the consideration of what Sos Eltis calls, ‘the corrosive effects of
wealth + power’ in Vic society
mays’ power =neg effects
● Can clearly be seen that in obtains sexual agency, may deeply humiliates and
emasculates J, who by the end of the tale is reduced to childish figure w/his ‘a
roring and a cry’
● This undoubtedly reads as destructive , particularly to a med reader , to whom the
concept of cuckoldry would have been linked w/both the destruction of a husbands
masculinity + his marriage , arguably far more than a modern reader, as divorce
was impossible in the Middle Ages + so the shame of infidelity was almost
inescapable
● BUT modern critics may interpret m’s newfound sexual autonomy as empowering,
and a retaliation to her status as a ‘desirable commodity’, as observed by Aers
● Contrast b/w her being as ‘still e as stoon’ on her wedding night + ‘brighte +
sheene’ + b4 she has sex w/D creates the sense that in pursuing her sexual
desires, may has Gaines power + happiness
Greed/ambition/desire
J sees consequences of his greed
● his fate is foreshadowed in very structure of the tale- introduced as ‘ sixty year a
wyfless man’ having a ‘great corage… to be a wedded man’ - link b he w
euphemistic ‘corage’ and his old age sets up tale as fabliau, which med reader
would’ve implied his desire for wife shall lead to j’s downfall
● j and appetite for sex portrayed in repulsive light/self destructive = c draws upon
adj ‘tendre,’ ‘corage ‘ + ‘pittee’- following a lexical field of sexuality = accentuates
overwhelming focus on lust/carnality - suggest marital intentions revolve around
securing LT sexual satisfaction rather than being united in ‘hooly bonde”
● his repeated focus on sex=creates sense of moral depravity + supports coopers
observation that J ‘ has opted for moral blindness from the start’
● sancity of marriage become perverted by sexual greeed , on wedding night tells
may that ‘ a man can do no sin w/his wyf’ - to society as religious as med one j’s
sexual excess violates of moderation so crucial to biblical teachings
● j’s loss of sights seen as physical punish ends as he ‘ amiddle his lust and
prosperitee is women blind’ - but it’s after he regains his sight that he blindly
accords mays exude for adultey and so ‘chooses to live in a self imposed
blindess’- emerson
, ● C arguing by end of novel, no longer matter whether can see -it is
● his power of perception has been destroyed by greed
Persuasion/manipulation
yes male writers can write about women- May’s infedelity
● Present women as cunning/manipulative and empowering =Mays infidelity
● when M receives D love letter she uses her sexual power to her adv, having sex
w/j so he will sleep enabling her to ‘secrely’ read the note
● The med church often encouraged women to procreate in order to escape Eve’s
sin, and marriage was widely considered a means of regulating sexual activity
● Hence, she exploits her one true form of power, her sexual power, + is able to
utilise the social conception of women as overtly sexual to her adv = Davidson ‘it is
the sprightly May who will hold the sexual potency of the union’
● Similarly as she ‘in warm wex hath e printed the clicket’, reminding the reader of J’s
earlier comment, ‘men may warm wex w/hands plye’= impression M now showing
plot of tale = manages to gain autonomy in face of perverse husband
● m’s transition from ‘stoon’ to ‘sheene’ could be read my modern fem critics as C
depicting an assertion of female sexual empowerment
Happiness
Intro
happiness not possible w/out delusion (both)
● At end of TMT = j chooses what Brown Jr referred to as ‘self-imposed blindness,’,
as he blindly accepts May’s exude for her adultery
● Chaucer’s description of ‘this J, who is glad but he?’, creates impression j has
reached some sort of happiness by end of poem. = but had to either
consciously/unconsciously disregard the truth in the process
● Considering the impossibility of divorce during middle ages , reader can see why J
eager to return to marriage w/may as of whole incident never transpired , as only
other option would be public humiliation
● While divorce legal during vic era, would be incred socially damaging to women,
who would rarely be able to pursue 2nd marriage
● Easy to see why LC being prepared to make similar exchange of truth for
happiness in AIH
● After hearing Robs misdeeds begs “lie to me! Lie to me! tell me it’s not true!’
● This paradoxical demand shows how, Iike j, LC rather remain happy + ignorant
than face spouses actions
● Writers able to present the reader w/ question of which is more important to
Pursue= happiness of truth
Love/desire
love = destructive (M+J)
● j and appetite for sex portrayed in repulsive light/self destructive = c draws upon
adj ‘tendre,’ ‘corage ‘ + ‘pittee’- following a lexical field of sexuality = accentuates
overwhelming focus on lust/carnality - suggest marital intentions revolve around
securing LT sexual satisfaction rather than being united in ‘hooly bonds’
The benefits of buying summaries with Stuvia:
Guaranteed quality through customer reviews
Stuvia customers have reviewed more than 700,000 summaries. This how you know that you are buying the best documents.
Quick and easy check-out
You can quickly pay through credit card or Stuvia-credit for the summaries. There is no membership needed.
Focus on what matters
Your fellow students write the study notes themselves, which is why the documents are always reliable and up-to-date. This ensures you quickly get to the core!
Frequently asked questions
What do I get when I buy this document?
You get a PDF, available immediately after your purchase. The purchased document is accessible anytime, anywhere and indefinitely through your profile.
Satisfaction guarantee: how does it work?
Our satisfaction guarantee ensures that you always find a study document that suits you well. You fill out a form, and our customer service team takes care of the rest.
Who am I buying these notes from?
Stuvia is a marketplace, so you are not buying this document from us, but from seller annabellag24. Stuvia facilitates payment to the seller.
Will I be stuck with a subscription?
No, you only buy these notes for $13.82. You're not tied to anything after your purchase.
Can Stuvia be trusted?
4.6 stars on Google & Trustpilot (+1000 reviews)
73918 documents were sold in the last 30 days
Founded in 2010, the go-to place to buy study notes for 14 years now