Summary
Samenvatting - Comparative Law
- Course
- Institution
Comprehensive and Detailed Summary for Comparative Law - First Master (taught by Cosmin Cercel)
[Show more]
Seller
Followhjdv2822
Content preview
Comparative Law UGent 2024-2025INHOUDSOPGAVE
Introduction ................................................................................................................................. 4
The concept of comparative law ....................................................................................................... 4
The research object ....................................................................................................................... 4
research method.............................................................................................................................. 9
components.................................................................................................................................. 9
Comparative Law v. Legal History Methodological similarities ....................................................... 10
SOCIOLOGY, ANTHROPOLOGY, LEGAL THEORY .......................................................................... 11
Origins and development ............................................................................................................. 12
Antiquity (pre 500): only a few traces of ‘comparative law’ .................................................................12
1st half of the Middle Ages (500-1000): little to be found ....................................................................13
2nd half of the Middle Ages (1000-1500): important, but different concept from present .....................14
General overview ......................................................................................................................... 14
Rediscovery and Influence ........................................................................................................... 14
Legal perspective ........................................................................................................................ 15
THE ‘NEW AGE’ (1500-1800) ............................................................................................................16
general overview ......................................................................................................................... 16
legal evolution ............................................................................................................................. 18
sporadic legal comparison ........................................................................................................... 19
19th Century: CL ‘taking roots’ – a systematic approach....................................................................19
legislative comparison ................................................................................................................. 20
scientific comparison .................................................................................................................. 21
From 1900 onwards: a ‘blossoming’ comparative law in a contemporary sense .................................22
Birth of modern comparative law.................................................................................................. 22
The Interwar era .......................................................................................................................... 23
Second Half of the 20th Century to Today ..................................................................................... 23
Applications ................................................................................................................................ 24
Comparative law in conflict resolution .............................................................................................24
Comparative law & international law ............................................................................................ 24
Comparative law & international private law ................................................................................. 26
Comparative Law and the Application of Foreign Law .................................................................... 28
COMPARATIVE LAW IN LAWMAKING ................................................................................................29
Comparative Law and Lawmaking ................................................................................................ 29
Comparative Law in Case Law ..................................................................................................... 30
Reception and Legal Transplants ................................................................................................. 33
Harmonization and Unification..................................................................................................... 35
Comparative Law in Legal Scholarship (Research Method) ................................................................45
Denscombe - The Logic of Research Proposals ............................................................................. 45
Research Design ......................................................................................................................... 46
Originality of the Research ........................................................................................................... 46
Normative Legal Studies and Comparative Law ............................................................................ 47
1
,Comparative Law UGent 2024-2025
Role of Comparative Law: ............................................................................................................ 47
Positive Legal Research ............................................................................................................... 47
Positive Legal Doctrine and Comparative Law ............................................................................... 49
Comparative Law as a Data Collection Method ............................................................................. 49
Didactic Value of Comparative Law .............................................................................................. 49
Conclusion on Comparative Law.................................................................................................. 50
Microcomparison ........................................................................................................................ 50
COMPARABILITY OF LEGAL SYSTEMS ..............................................................................................51
Choice of Systems to Compare .................................................................................................... 51
Comparability and Basis for Comparison...................................................................................... 51
APPROACH: DOGMATIC VERSUS FUNCTIONAL COMPARISON.........................................................52
Dogmatic Legal Comparison ........................................................................................................ 52
Functional Legal Comparison ...................................................................................................... 53
The Presumption of Similarity....................................................................................................... 53
Functional vs. Dogmatic Comparison: Pros and Cons ................................................................... 53
KNOWLEDGE OF FOREIGN (LEGAL) SYSTEMS ..................................................................................54
Law versus Doctrine .................................................................................................................... 54
Law and/as Language ......................................................................................................................57
LAW AND LANGUAGE .................................................................................................................. 57
Sources of Law ...............................................................................................................................59
FORMAL SOURCES OF LAW ......................................................................................................... 59
LEGISLATION .............................................................................................................................. 60
CASE LAW ................................................................................................................................... 60
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN THE JUDGE AND THE LAW ............................................................. 61
THE ACTUAL COMPARISON.............................................................................................................64
Macrocomparison ....................................................................................................................... 65
Definition of Macro-Comparative Law ..............................................................................................65
Utility of Macro-Comparative Law ....................................................................................................66
Methodological Fundamental Issue .................................................................................................67
The Concept of a Legal System..................................................................................................... 67
Fundamental Issue of Taxonomies ............................................................................................... 68
Criteria for Taxonomy/Typology ........................................................................................................69
External Factors .......................................................................................................................... 69
Level of Development .................................................................................................................. 69
Genealogical Approach ............................................................................................................... 70
Typological Approach .................................................................................................................. 71
COMMON LAW VS. CIVIL LAW (Ideal-Typical) ...................................................................................73
Romanization .............................................................................................................................. 73
Substantive Law .......................................................................................................................... 73
Rules .......................................................................................................................................... 74
Rule-Making ................................................................................................................................ 74
Summa Divisio ............................................................................................................................ 74
MIXED SYSTEMS, HYBRID SYSTEMS, AND LEGAL PLURALISM ...........................................................75
2
,Comparative Law UGent 2024-2025
Unique Mixed Systems ................................................................................................................ 76
Law as Culture and Decoloniality ................................................................................................. 77
Study Materials ...............................................................................................................................77
Law as Culture: Intellectual Origins ..................................................................................................78
Philosophical Roots..................................................................................................................... 78
Phenomenology .......................................................................................................................... 78
Psychoanalysis ........................................................................................................................... 78
2.4 Critical Theory ....................................................................................................................... 78
Comparing Law as Culture ..............................................................................................................79
A Critique of Objectivity in Law .........................................................................................................79
Remnants of Colonialism ................................................................................................................79
Hybridity and Peripheral Identity .................................................................................................. 79
The Case of Egypt’s Civil Code ..................................................................................................... 79
Cultural Expressions and Law ..........................................................................................................79
Grounding Law in Cultural Philosophy ..............................................................................................80
Law and Decoloniality .....................................................................................................................80
Decolonial Critiques .................................................................................................................... 80
Key Themes................................................................................................................................. 80
Concluding Insights.........................................................................................................................80
Comparative Law and Interdisciplinarity ...................................................................................... 81
Thinking as a Lawyer ........................................................................................................................81
Legal Alienation ........................................................................................................................... 81
Bourdieu’s Sociology of the Legal Field ......................................................................................... 81
Law and Ideology ............................................................................................................................82
The Ideological Function of Codes................................................................................................ 82
Freedom and Constraint in Adjudication....................................................................................... 82
Comparative Law and Cultural Studies .............................................................................................82
Defining Culture (CESCR GC 21) .................................................................................................. 82
Law as Cultural Expression .......................................................................................................... 82
Legal Rigor and Authenticity .............................................................................................................82
Material Authenticity ................................................................................................................... 83
Heritage Conservation in Law....................................................................................................... 83
Comparative Law and Politics ..........................................................................................................83
Law as Political ........................................................................................................................... 83
The Influence of Politics ............................................................................................................... 83
Instrumentalization of Comparative Law ..........................................................................................83
Colonial Applications .................................................................................................................. 83
Criminology’s Role in Law ................................................................................................................84
Criminology and Interdisciplinarity ............................................................................................... 84
Historical Development ............................................................................................................... 84
Criminology’s Contribution to Law ............................................................................................... 84
3
, Comparative Law UGent 2024-2025
8. Concluding Insights .....................................................................................................................84
COMPARATIVE LAW
INTRODUCTION
THE CONCEPT OF COMPARATIVE LAW
Comparative Law - What is it not?
• It is not a branch of law or a part of the law (objective law).
• It is not a claim or authority (subjective law).
• It is not a way to resolve conflicts (functional law).
What is it then?
• It is an activity in which someone engages with the law, namely, a research method and a way to
study the law.
o Zweigert and Kötz were considered the standard reference, but no new work has yet
replaced it.
• It is a comparison of laws, where comparison is the method and the law is the object (“an
intellectual activity with law as its object and comparison as its process”).
Note: Some terms are misleading.
• "Comparative law" = comparable law.
• "Droit comparé" = compared law
THE RESEARCH OBJECT
WHAT IS LAW?
The Object of Comparison = Law - Importance of the Question
• One must know what law is, because otherwise, one cannot compare it, and it will yield no
results.
• Law = "a set of rules for ordering society" (a vague description).
o This is not a true definition of law, as it does not explain what rules are or what ordering
means. It does not teach how to distinguish behavioral rules from legal rules.
4
The benefits of buying summaries with Stuvia:
Guaranteed quality through customer reviews
Stuvia customers have reviewed more than 700,000 summaries. This how you know that you are buying the best documents.
Quick and easy check-out
You can quickly pay through credit card or Stuvia-credit for the summaries. There is no membership needed.
Focus on what matters
Your fellow students write the study notes themselves, which is why the documents are always reliable and up-to-date. This ensures you quickly get to the core!
Frequently asked questions
What do I get when I buy this document?
You get a PDF, available immediately after your purchase. The purchased document is accessible anytime, anywhere and indefinitely through your profile.
Satisfaction guarantee: how does it work?
Our satisfaction guarantee ensures that you always find a study document that suits you well. You fill out a form, and our customer service team takes care of the rest.
Who am I buying these notes from?
Stuvia is a marketplace, so you are not buying this document from us, but from seller hjdv2822. Stuvia facilitates payment to the seller.
Will I be stuck with a subscription?
No, you only buy these notes for $16.20. You're not tied to anything after your purchase.
Can Stuvia be trusted?
4.6 stars on Google & Trustpilot (+1000 reviews)
56326 documents were sold in the last 30 days
Founded in 2010, the go-to place to buy study notes for 14 years now