This document provides a detailed summary of the course Economics of Cities GEO2-3804 at Utrecht University of the academic year . The document contains three sections. First, the book Modern Urban and Regional Economics by Philip McCann is summarised (Chapter 2-6 and 8-10. Second the articles disc...
2.1 Introduction
- Most industrial activities tend to be clustered together in space -> why?
- Certain activities take place in certain clusters -> some are more dispersed (more
transportation), others more concentrated.
-> Generally one largest city cluster with almost all types of activities -> larger number of
smaller clusters.
-> Urban hierarchy.
- This chapter: why cluster activities together in space?
2.2 Industrial clustering: returns to scale and geography
- Constant returns to scale: Clustering will create demand for land and labour -> land rents
and wages go up -> profitability of firms will be reduced, so no incentive for firms to cluster.
- External economies of scale: Clustering still leads to higher land rents and higher wages,
could be offset by increase in efficiency for each firm.
-> Clustering increases profitability -> other firms will join too: cumulative process of local
growth.
-> Are limits though as it is not continuously cumulative: not all activities are at one
location.
2.3 Agglomeration economies
-> Location-specific economies of scale.
- Sources of agglomeration economies (Marshall):
- Knowledge spillovers: Tacit information (incomplete knowledge shared on a non-market
basis) flows easily in clusters through informal contacts.
-> All firms able to get a clear picture of market environment -> more competitive in the
market.
-> Information advantage for firms within the cluster over outsiders.
- Non-traded local inputs: If many firms in the same industry group together, they form a
large demand for specialized inputs to be provided.
- Local skilled labour pool: Easier for the firm to find new labour when market demand
conditions improve + little costs to retraining activities (they are skilled).
-> Duranton and Puga: Processes of learning, sharing and matching: together the three
sources allow firms to experience economies of scale external to a single firm, internal to the
group of firms together.
-> Agglomeration economies for firms clustered within the same industry.
- Types of agglomeration economies (Hoover):
- Internal returns to scale: Economies of scale due to size of one firm: large factory requires
a lot of capital and a large labour force at the location.
-> Production factors clustered together within one firm -> internal economies of scale are
,location specific.
-> Firm-specific economies of agglomeration.
- Economies of localization: Advantages due to a group of firms within the same industrial
sector located at the same place (Marshall’s sources of agglomeration).
-> Industry-specific economies of agglomeration.
- Economies of urbanization: Advantages of firms of different sectors clustering together:
activities not related to dominant sector providing services for firms and employees of that
sector (education, health care, leisure, legal).
-> City-specific economies of agglomeration.
2.4 Clusters, firm types, and the nature of transactions
- Hard to empirically distinguish between different types and sources of agglomeration.
- Three different typologies of spatial industrial clusters:
- Pure agglomeration: Firms are atomistic (perfect competition) -> intense local competition
(no loyalty between firms).
-> Everyone is able to enter the cluster: benefit is local presence, cost local real-estate
rents -> the last one also an indicator of the cluster’s performance.
-> Marshall model, also localization and urbanization economies.
- Industrial complex: Long-term and stable relations between firms in the cluster.
-> Input-output linkages, high entry and exit costs -> proximity is required to reduce inter-
firm transport costs.
-> Internal returns to scale.
- Social network: Common culture of mutual trust -> no opportunistic behaviour.
-> Spatial proximity fosters trust relations: local business environment of confidence, risk-
taking and cooperation.
-> These types differ quite a lot -> each cluster will have a dominant typology and helps
determining the characteristics and behaviour of any particular cluster.
-> Does not show why firms wish to cluster in space due to potential unintended knowledge
outflows (privately developed ideas or techniques through R&D) -> is controlled for by
contracts (industrial complex) and shared values (social network), but not in a pure
agglomeration -> discourages investments in R&D.
-> Decision of clustering issue of comparing knowledge advantages and disadvantages.
-> Clusters are related to innovation and economic growth, ways to observe these relations
empirically remain very unclear.
2.5 People clustering: creativity and urban consumption
- Other advantages of urban clustering:
- Creative class (Florida): Culture of tolerance will lead to an environment of creativity
(fostering innovation in multiple areas) and commercial dynamism.
-> Creative personalities will move to tolerant places -> increasing innovation in these
places.
- Consumer city: Modern city a place of work and leisure.
-> High-income consumers benefit of high-quality creative services and amenities provided
by creative people.
,-> Clustering not only about firms, also related to interactions of people.
2.6 Limited information, uncertainty, and the evolution of clusters
- In environments of uncertainty and limited information the process of agglomerations
needs to be reconsidered: three themes:
- Bounded rationality: Firms due to limited information, limited in their ability to be
rational.
-> Firms location decision bounded by limited information on locations -> unable to
choose profit maximizing location -> needs to focus on other objectives.
- Conflicting goals: Firms can choose to optimize short run profits, sales, minimize costs.
-> All best in different location -> due to limited behaviour, firms focus on different
objectives and might miss the best possible location.
- Relocation costs: Due to high relocation costs, firms will not move due to small changes in
factor prices or market revenues.
-> Relocation is a last resort strategy if other competitive weapons did not work.
-> Behavioural theory explains why observed spatial patterns do not reflect optimum
location behaviour, but behavioural theory does not indicate why a firm chooses a particular
location.
-> Necessary to reconsider agglomeration theories: no.
- Alchian (evolutionary approach):
- Adoptive environment: All firms are identical, no information advantages or a priori
knowledge of whether their strategy is successful.
-> In the end the firms best suited to the needs of the economy will survive.
- Adaptive environment: Large firms able to analyse the market and acquire information,
small firms are not, but they copy behaviour of larger firms.
-> Large firms overcome uncertainty by analysis, small firms by imitation.
-> Small firms (most cases spin-offs) will locate near large firms -> explains why localized
clusters in related technological fields arise.
-> Moving close to large firms good strategy for risk averse firms: market share is not
lower than equivalent firm + well defended against price movements.
2.7 Conclusions
- Generation, acquisition and transfer of knowledge key component of industrial clustering.
- Spatial economy characterized by geographical concentration and dispersion, the balance
produces a system of cities: an urban hierarchy.
Chapter 3: The spatial distribution of activities
3.1 Introduction to industrial dispersal
- Not all activities are located together, some with large land use for instance are dispersed.
-> Industrial dispersal creates a spatial pattern or system of cities: urban hierarchy.
3.2 Firm dispersion: price discrimination, market areas, and distance costs
- In absence of agglomeration mechanisms, different firms with different output for different
, markets will tend to be dispersed.
- Firms might use monopoly power over local consumers (less transport costs) to charge
them more than distant consumers: price discrimination.
-> Increases spatial market of the firm + increases the tendency towards firm dispersion.
- Market area: Reilly: Ability of market to attract customers directly related to size of market
and indirectly to distance to the market.
-> Large market increases attractiveness of market, distance increases costs of overcoming
that distance.
-> Greater urbanization economies associated with larger cities, implies larger hinterland;
more local market areas are dominated by purchases of lower variety of goods.
- High-value products tend to have a high value-weight ratio, meaning that transport costs
will remain small portion of the price; low-value products tend to have low value-weight
ratio, meaning transport costs quickly become a significant portion of price.
-> High-value products tend to be in larger urban centres.
-> The higher the value-weight ratio, the greater average distance of shipment.
- Problems: Method is useless for the weightless service economy, some high-value
products also produced outside major centres + major centres also production location for
low-value products.
-> This paragraph contrasts with chapter 2: countervailing forces of agglomeration and
dispersal create a spatial pattern of cities and regions.
3.3 Urban hierarchies and classical central place theory
- Observations: Nations dominated by one or two primal cities, followed by smaller cities, as
city size falls, the number of those cities increases.
-> Spatial distribution of urban centres follow a hierarchical pyramidal pattern.
- Christaller approach to central places: (inductive)
- There is a hierarchy of different goods, market areas and urban centres.
- Higher order goods, need larger spatial market areas.
- Outcome: Spatial pattern with hexagonal market areas, which ensures that all locations
are supplied with all goods from a minimum amount of supply points.
- Lösch approach to central places: (deductive)
- Variety of firms, producing a variety of goods.
- Aim to find ideal economic landscape with the most efficient spatial allocation of activity
(arises naturally in a competitive economy).
- Quantity demanded decreases with distance at some point price + transport costs is so
high, that quantity demanded is zero.
-> Market area of firm is a circle.
- Competition: all land is occupied by identical firms: spatial economy will follow a pattern
of hexagons, firms locate at centre of their hexagon.
-> Ensures that the average price + transport costs is minimized as there is a maximum
number of competing suppliers in the economy (the opposite of Christaller).
- High-value goods price inelastic -> larger market area as demand does fall relatively slowly
as distance (transport costs) increase, low-value goods have smaller market areas.
-> Firms producing price inelastic goods located at fewer points (larger hexagonal areas),
The benefits of buying summaries with Stuvia:
Guaranteed quality through customer reviews
Stuvia customers have reviewed more than 700,000 summaries. This how you know that you are buying the best documents.
Quick and easy check-out
You can quickly pay through credit card or Stuvia-credit for the summaries. There is no membership needed.
Focus on what matters
Your fellow students write the study notes themselves, which is why the documents are always reliable and up-to-date. This ensures you quickly get to the core!
Frequently asked questions
What do I get when I buy this document?
You get a PDF, available immediately after your purchase. The purchased document is accessible anytime, anywhere and indefinitely through your profile.
Satisfaction guarantee: how does it work?
Our satisfaction guarantee ensures that you always find a study document that suits you well. You fill out a form, and our customer service team takes care of the rest.
Who am I buying these notes from?
Stuvia is a marketplace, so you are not buying this document from us, but from seller stuviauu. Stuvia facilitates payment to the seller.
Will I be stuck with a subscription?
No, you only buy these notes for $5.90. You're not tied to anything after your purchase.
