100% satisfaction guarantee Immediately available after payment Both online and in PDF No strings attached
logo-home
Previously searched by you
Previously searched by you
logo
Moral Theory Essay - For any world in which a small number of people lead high quality lives, is there always a better world in which a large number lead low quality lives? £7.99
Add to cart
Quickly navigate to
Preview
  2.  
  3. Durham University (DUT)
  4.  
  5. Durham University
  6.  
  7. Moral Theory

Essay

Moral Theory Essay - For any world in which a small number of people lead high quality lives, is there always a better world in which a large number lead low quality lives?
 0 purchase

Essay about the Repugnant Conclusion, receiving a 1st

Preview 2 out of 8  pages

Document information

  • January 10, 2021
  • 8
  • 2018/2019
  • Essay
  • Unknown
  • A

Subjects

Written for

All documents for this subject (1)

Seller

avatar-seller
ppegraduate

Content preview

For any world in which a small number of
people lead high quality lives, is there always
a better world in which a large number lead
low quality lives?
Parfit’s Repugnant Conclusion raises a population ethics problem, which states that a world in
which a large number lead low quality lives is better than a world in which a small number of
people lead high quality lives. In this essay, I will attempt to challenge this Repugnant Conclusion.
First, I will outline the Repugnant Conclusion. Next, I will attempt to argue against the Repugnant
Conclusion by adopting Average Utilitarianism. Then, after finding criticisms with Average
Utilitarianism, I will endeavor to amend it by including a threshold to determine which worlds are
desirable and worth living, in order to prevent us from reaching a Z-like world. I shall then consider
potential criticisms of using a threshold before dismissing these.


Here, I will outline the Repugnant Conclusion, before putting forward potential arguments to solve
it. The Repugnant Conclusion can be outlined as the following:


“For any possible population of at least ten billion people, all with a very high quality of life, there
must be some much larger imaginable population whose existence, if other things are equal, would
be better, even though its members have lives that are barely worth living.” (Parfit 1984:388).


This can be explained via diagrams, such as the figure 1:



Fig 1




A B C Z

, It is worth noting here that the Repugnant Conclusion uses total utilitarianism, which is defined as
the greatest quantity of whatever makes life worth living. In figure 1, world A depicts a small
population, such as one million, that has a very high level of utility. World B has a larger population
and a lower level of utility than A. According to total utilitarianism (which I will refer to as TU),
world B is better than world A, as world B has a greater amount of total utility than world A. The
same conclusions can be made when comparing world B to C, for the same reasons. This will
continue for worlds D, E F, and so on. Eventually, we get to world Z. World Z has a large population,
let us say of 100 million, and the level of utility is just above the threshold of a life worth living. The
total utility of world Z is greater than that of world A, and so according to TU, world Z is better than
world A. Our intuition, however, states otherwise. World A should be better than world Z, because
the lives lived in world A are of higher quality than in world Z, due to the higher level of utility. This
leads us to the Repugnant Conclusion (Parfit 1984:384-389).


I will now attempt to solve the Repugnant Conclusion, by discussing utility. First, I shall consider
Average Utilitarianism as a potential solution. Average Utilitarianism (AU) takes the total utility and
divides it by the population, to find the average utility of each person (Sikora 1975:409). If we apply
this to the diagram above, it is clear that the average utility of world A is higher than that of world
Z. Therefore, if we replace TU with AU, we can initially claim that the Repugnant Conclusion is false.
However, I will now put forward a counterargument to using AU.


Sikora provides an example that criticizes AU. In a given world, the destruction of the world is going
to happen. According to Sikora, AU would be concerned with the suffering of people who exist at
the time the world was destroyed and lost their lives; yet it may not be concerned about the loss of
future generations. If future generations would have been happier that the people already existing,
then AU would be concerned about future generations. If future generations had been less happy
than existing people, then AU would not be concerned about future generations, as they would be
seen as only pulling down the average level of utility (Sikora 1975:410). The diagrams below can
illustrate this.

The benefits of buying summaries with Stuvia:

Guaranteed quality through customer reviews

Guaranteed quality through customer reviews

Stuvia customers have reviewed more than 700,000 summaries. This how you know that you are buying the best documents.

Quick and easy check-out

Quick and easy check-out

You can quickly pay through credit card for the summaries. There is no membership needed.

Focus on what matters

Focus on what matters

Your fellow students write the study notes themselves, which is why the documents are always reliable and up-to-date. This ensures you quickly get to the core!

Frequently asked questions

What do I get when I buy this document?

You get a PDF, available immediately after your purchase. The purchased document is accessible anytime, anywhere and indefinitely through your profile.

Satisfaction guarantee: how does it work?

Our satisfaction guarantee ensures that you always find a study document that suits you well. You fill out a form, and our customer service team takes care of the rest.

Who am I buying these notes from?

Stuvia is a marketplace, so you are not buying this document from us, but from seller ppegraduate. Stuvia facilitates payment to the seller.

Will I be stuck with a subscription?

No, you only buy these notes for £7.99. You're not tied to anything after your purchase.

Can Stuvia be trusted?

4.6 stars on Google & Trustpilot (+1000 reviews)

64302 documents were sold in the last 30 days

Founded in 2010, the go-to place to buy revision notes and other study material for 15 years now

Start selling

Recently viewed by you

Exam (elaborations) ·

(0)

Essentials of Psychiatric Mental Health Nursing 8th Edition Concepts of Care in Evidence- Based Practice 8th Edition Morgan Townsend Test Bank, complete all chapters

Exam (elaborations) ·

(2)

COMPLETE TEST BANK FOR The Legal and Regulatory Environment of Business 19th Edition by Marisa Anne Pagnattaro (Author) latest update Question And Answers (Answer key)

Package deal ·

(0)

HESI Pharmacology Exams Version 1/2/3/4/5, HESI Pharmacology Exam Reviews,HESI Pharmacology Practice Exams|STUDY BUNDLE Questions and Verified Answers | 2023 / 2024 Updates

Exam (elaborations) ·

(1)

AQA GCSE GERMAN 8668/RH Paper 3 Reading Higher Tier Version: 1.0 Final *jun238668RH01* IB/M/Jun23/E12 8668/RH QUESTION PAPER & MARKING SCHEME/ [MERGED] Marl( scheme June 2023

Exam (elaborations) ·

(3)

Test Bank For Tietz Fundamentals of Clinical Chemistry and Molecular Diagnostics, 8th Edition by Nader Rifai, All 49 Chapters Covered and Verified, ISBN: 9780323530446

Exam (elaborations) ·

(0)

CHIMA NEC - Legal Aspects of HIM / Privacy, Confidentiality, Access and Release of PHI / Ethical Aspects of HIM and Professional Practice Questions With Complete Solutions

Exam (elaborations) ·

(1)

Test Bank-Pharmacotherapeutics for Advanced Practice-A Practical Approach 5th Edition Arcangelo, Peterson,Wilbur & Kang(2022), All Chapters 1-56 ISBN-13 978-1975160593

Package deal ·

(0)

Exam 1, Exam 2 & Exam 3: BIOS251 / BIOS 251 Anatomy & Physiology I with Lab (Latest 2024 / 2025 Updates STUDY BUNDLE WITH COMPLETE SOLUTIONS) | 100% Correct | Grade A - Chamberlain

Package deal ·

(0)

NBCOT Certification Occupational Therapist Registered OTR and Occupational Therapy Assistant COTA :-2024-2025 - EXAM PREPARATIONs COMPILATION BUNDLE 100% GUARANTEED SUCCESS
£7.99
  • (0)
Add to cart
Added