Class notes
College notes Public International Law
- Course
- Institution
Notes from the course Public International Law 2022 - until lecture 20. Including overview of case law. 191 pages.
[Show more]
Seller
Follow
MasterKULstudent
Reviews received
Content preview
Public International LawTable of Contents
EXAM......................................................................................................................................................1
Chapter 1 – History & Nature of International Law................................................................................1
A. A brief history of International Law................................................................................................1
1. Origin..........................................................................................................................................1
2. Intellectual currents in international law....................................................................................1
i. Pre-1500..................................................................................................................................1
ii. 1500-1648...............................................................................................................................1
3. Modern international law (1648-1815)......................................................................................2
4. Hugo Grotius...............................................................................................................................2
i. Distinction between just naturale and jus gentium.................................................................2
ii. Characteristics of the jus gentium...........................................................................................3
5. Dominance of positivism............................................................................................................3
6. The Concert of Europe (1815-1914)............................................................................................3
7. Colonialism and Empire..............................................................................................................3
8. United Nations............................................................................................................................4
i. World War I and the League....................................................................................................4
ii. World War II and the United Nations......................................................................................4
B. The scope and content of international law...................................................................................5
1. Defining international law today................................................................................................5
2. Basic principles of the international legal system.......................................................................5
3. Core concepts of international law.............................................................................................5
4. Is international law a system?....................................................................................................5
5. Contemporary debates in international legal scholarship..........................................................6
C. A definition of international law.....................................................................................................6
D. The function of international law...................................................................................................6
Chapter 2 – Sources of IL & Peremptory norms.....................................................................................6
A. On sources and validity of legal rules.............................................................................................6
1. Sources, States, and Consent......................................................................................................6
2. Distinguishing formal and material sources of international law................................................7
B. Article 38 of the Statute of the International Court of Justice........................................................7
1. Lex Arbitri or an authoritative general statement?.....................................................................7
i
, 2. Article 38.....................................................................................................................................7
C. Treaties...........................................................................................................................................8
1. Definition....................................................................................................................................8
2. Only binding on parties...............................................................................................................8
3. Characteristics............................................................................................................................8
D. Customary international law..........................................................................................................9
1. Understanding the concept of ‘custom’.....................................................................................9
2. The requirement for a ‘general practice’: State practice..........................................................10
i. Case law.................................................................................................................................10
ii. Evidence of State practice.....................................................................................................10
3. Evidence of ‘acceptance as law’: Opinio juris...........................................................................11
i. Definition...............................................................................................................................11
ii. Identifying.............................................................................................................................11
4. Limitations: the relativity of custom.........................................................................................12
i. Conduct as opinion juris.........................................................................................................12
ii. Three exceptions to binding customary law.........................................................................12
Persistent and subsequent objection....................................................................................12
Particular (“regional”) custom..............................................................................................13
E. General principles of law..............................................................................................................13
1. Definition..................................................................................................................................13
2. Finding general principles.........................................................................................................15
F. Subsidiary Sources: judicial decisions (non-formal sources).........................................................15
G. Other Sources of law or obligation...............................................................................................16
H. Soft law........................................................................................................................................17
1. Concept.....................................................................................................................................17
2. Effects of soft law......................................................................................................................17
3. Examples...................................................................................................................................17
I. Provisional conclusion on sources.................................................................................................17
Chapter 3 – Hierarchy of norms............................................................................................................17
A. Peremptory Norms in International Law......................................................................................17
B. The emergence of jus cogens in international law.......................................................................18
C. Hierarchy of norms and sources...................................................................................................18
D. Jus cogens in international law.....................................................................................................18
1. Definition..................................................................................................................................18
2. Origin of concept of jus cogens.................................................................................................19
3. Implications of jus cogens.........................................................................................................19
ii
, 4. Jus cogens as ‘super-custom’?..................................................................................................20
E. Obligations erga omnes................................................................................................................20
1. Concept.....................................................................................................................................20
2. Obligations erga omnes at the ICJ.............................................................................................20
3. Jus cogens and erga omnes compared.....................................................................................21
4. Legal effects of jus cogens........................................................................................................22
F. Categories of peremptory norms..................................................................................................22
G. Closing thoughts on peremptory norms.......................................................................................23
Special Topic: War – Russia against Ukraine.........................................................................................23
Chapter 4 – International and National Law.........................................................................................28
A. Overview......................................................................................................................................28
B. Interactions between legal orders................................................................................................28
1. Dualism.....................................................................................................................................28
2. Monism.....................................................................................................................................28
C. The relation between international and national law in practice.................................................29
1. Domestic law within international law.....................................................................................29
2. Municipal law must comply with valid international obligations..............................................29
3. Municipal law in international courts.......................................................................................30
4. Municipal law in international law............................................................................................30
5. International law within municipal law.....................................................................................30
i. Incorporation of customary international law into municipal law.........................................31
ii. Treaty implementation in municipal law...............................................................................31
6. Legislative implementation of a treaty.....................................................................................31
D. Practical issues faced by domestic courts in relation to international law...................................32
1. Separation of powers................................................................................................................32
2. Doctrines of judicial restraint....................................................................................................33
3. Acts of State..............................................................................................................................33
E. Conclusion: accommodating plural orders...................................................................................33
Chapter 5 – States................................................................................................................................33
A. Introduction: the nature of the State...........................................................................................34
1. Concept.....................................................................................................................................34
2. Capacity under international law..............................................................................................34
3. Personality – participants in the International Legal System....................................................34
i. States.....................................................................................................................................34
ii. Other participants.................................................................................................................34
B. The criteria for statehood.............................................................................................................35
iii
, 1. Defining....................................................................................................................................35
2. Criteria for statehood...............................................................................................................35
i. Permanent population...........................................................................................................36
ii. Defined territory...................................................................................................................36
iii. Effective government...........................................................................................................36
iv. Capacity to enter into legal relations...................................................................................37
3. Potential factors not in Montevideo?.......................................................................................38
4. Continuity and change in statehood.........................................................................................39
5. State succession........................................................................................................................39
C. Recognition of States and governments.......................................................................................40
1. Recognition...............................................................................................................................40
2. Declaratory theory of recognition.............................................................................................40
3. Constitutive theory of recognition............................................................................................40
4. Collective recognition...............................................................................................................41
5. Duty of non-recognition............................................................................................................41
6. Recognition of governments.....................................................................................................42
i. Concept..................................................................................................................................42
ii. De jure and de facto recognition...........................................................................................42
iii. Effects of recognition in domestic law.................................................................................43
D. Continuity and extinction of statehood: the emergence of new states.......................................43
1. 1990-2011 trend in non-recognition.........................................................................................43
2. Domestic criteria for determining recognition of a government..............................................43
3. Effects of non-recognition in domestic law...............................................................................44
4. A renaissance of de jure recognition.........................................................................................44
i. Libya, 2011.............................................................................................................................44
ii. Syria, 2011............................................................................................................................45
iii. Venezuela, 2019...................................................................................................................45
iv. Afghanistan, 2021................................................................................................................45
E. Conclusion: statehood and international personality...................................................................46
Chapter 6 – The Law of the Treaties.....................................................................................................46
What is a treaty?..............................................................................................................................46
A. The Creation of Treaties...............................................................................................................46
1. Concept.....................................................................................................................................46
2. Becoming party to a treaty.......................................................................................................46
3. Who may represent a State?....................................................................................................47
4. How does a State consent to be bound?..................................................................................47
iv
, B. Entry in Force of Treaties..............................................................................................................48
C. The Nature of Treaty Obligations – general principles.................................................................48
D. Treaty Interpretation....................................................................................................................48
1. Theory.......................................................................................................................................48
2. In practice.................................................................................................................................49
E. Reservations.................................................................................................................................50
1. Reservations.............................................................................................................................50
2. Objections.................................................................................................................................50
3. Effect of a valid reservation......................................................................................................51
4. Limitations on reservations.......................................................................................................52
5. Reservations to human rights treaties......................................................................................53
F. Invalid Treaties..............................................................................................................................54
1. General.....................................................................................................................................54
2. Grounds....................................................................................................................................54
G. Termination of Treaties................................................................................................................55
Chapter 7 – Jurisdiction........................................................................................................................56
A. Defining Jurisdiction in International Law....................................................................................56
1. Concept.....................................................................................................................................56
2. Forms of jurisdiction.................................................................................................................56
B. The exercise of Jursidiction...........................................................................................................57
1. Case of the SS Lotus (1927, PCIJ)..............................................................................................57
C. Prescriptive Jurisdiction................................................................................................................58
1. Territorial and Nationality Principles........................................................................................58
i. Territorial principle................................................................................................................58
ii. Nationality principle..............................................................................................................59
2. Contested principles: passive personality, the protective principle, the universal principle....60
i. The protective principle.........................................................................................................60
ii. Passive personality principle.................................................................................................61
iii. The universality principle.....................................................................................................61
3. Treaty-based extensions of jurisdiction....................................................................................63
i. Concept..................................................................................................................................63
ii. Case study: Guantánamo Bay...............................................................................................64
iii. Problems with traditional approaches.................................................................................64
D. Enforcement Jurisdiction..............................................................................................................65
Chapter 8 – Immunities........................................................................................................................65
A. State Immunity: Elements of a plea..............................................................................................65
v
, 1. Defining the Foreign State........................................................................................................65
2. Exceptions to Adjudication Jurisdiction....................................................................................66
i. Methods for avoidance..........................................................................................................66
ii. Acts of State..........................................................................................................................66
iii. Non-justiciability: substantive..............................................................................................67
3. Absolute State immunity: origins..............................................................................................67
i. Origin.....................................................................................................................................67
ii. Early judicial decisions..........................................................................................................67
iii. Applicability of immunities to State acts..............................................................................68
iv. Practice on restrictive immunity..........................................................................................68
B. Immunity of Certain Categories of Officials..................................................................................69
i. Key ICJ cases on State immunity & State officials’ immunity.................................................69
ii. UN Convention on jurisdictional Immunities, 2005...............................................................69
C. State Immunity in international Courts........................................................................................70
1. Principle....................................................................................................................................70
2. Possible exceptions to immunity..............................................................................................71
D. Immunity of State officials............................................................................................................72
1. General.....................................................................................................................................72
2. Heads of State immunity..........................................................................................................72
3. Head of government/Minister of Foreign affairs......................................................................72
4. Other State officials..................................................................................................................73
E. Scope of Immunities for Serious Crimes.......................................................................................73
1. Immunity ratione personae......................................................................................................73
2. Immunity ratione materiae.......................................................................................................74
F. Diplomatic and Consular Immunities............................................................................................76
1. Concept.....................................................................................................................................76
B. Diplomatic immunity................................................................................................................76
C. Consular immunity....................................................................................................................77
D. Special missions immunity.......................................................................................................77
Chapter 9. State responsibility.............................................................................................................78
A. Classification and characterization...............................................................................................78
1. Defining State responsibility.....................................................................................................78
2. General principles of State responsibility.................................................................................78
i. The ILC Articles on State Responsibility.................................................................................78
ii. Exclusions under State responsibility....................................................................................78
iii. Articles of State responsibility..............................................................................................79
vi
, iv. State responsibility and municipal law.................................................................................79
B. Breach of an international obligation of a State...........................................................................80
1. Conditions for a breach.............................................................................................................80
i. Overview................................................................................................................................80
ii. Time......................................................................................................................................81
iii. Intend, fault and damage excluded as a general rule...........................................................81
C. Attribution of conduct to a State..................................................................................................81
1. Organs of a State......................................................................................................................82
2. Other entities............................................................................................................................83
i. Private individuals..................................................................................................................83
ii. Revolutionaries and insurgents.............................................................................................84
iii. Complicity for acts of others................................................................................................85
Principle................................................................................................................................85
Shared responsibility?...........................................................................................................87
D. Defenses to State responsibility...................................................................................................88
1. Circumstances precluding wrongfulness...................................................................................88
E. Invoking responsibility of a State..................................................................................................89
F. Reparations and other remedies..................................................................................................90
1. Consequences of a breach........................................................................................................90
i. Cessation................................................................................................................................90
ii. Reparation............................................................................................................................90
G. Aggravated State responsibility....................................................................................................91
Chapter 10. Diplomatic protection.......................................................................................................92
A. Bases of diplomatic protection.....................................................................................................92
B. Legal interest as a pre-requisite to admissibility..........................................................................92
1. Principle....................................................................................................................................92
2. Actio popularis versus erga omnes: standing in the public interest?........................................93
3. Modalities for establishing legal interest..................................................................................93
4. Discretion of a State to espouse a claim...................................................................................93
5. From discretion to duty of protection?.....................................................................................93
C. Rules on nationality......................................................................................................................94
1. Individuals.................................................................................................................................94
2. International law and granting nationality................................................................................95
3. Further conditions for nationality.............................................................................................96
4. Nationality of corporations.......................................................................................................97
5. Diplomatic protection for shareholders....................................................................................97
vii
, D. Rule on exhaustion of local remedies...........................................................................................98
1. Principle....................................................................................................................................98
2. Exceptions (art. 15 ADP)...........................................................................................................98
3. Exhaustion of remedies in mixed claims...................................................................................99
4. Nature of rule...........................................................................................................................99
E. Rules on the treatment of aliens..................................................................................................99
Chapter 11. Dispute settlement............................................................................................................99
A. International disputes................................................................................................................100
1. History....................................................................................................................................100
2. What is a dispute?..................................................................................................................100
B. Diplomatic Methods of Dispute Settlement (art. 33)..................................................................100
1. Negotiation.............................................................................................................................100
2. Mediation...............................................................................................................................101
3. Inquiry.....................................................................................................................................101
4. Conciliation.............................................................................................................................102
C. Legal Methods of Dispute Settlement........................................................................................102
1. Arbitration..............................................................................................................................102
i. Concept................................................................................................................................102
ii. Alabama arbitration............................................................................................................102
iii. Post Alabama.....................................................................................................................103
iv. Permanent Court of Arbitration.........................................................................................103
2. Adjudication............................................................................................................................104
D. The International Court of Justice..............................................................................................104
1. Concept...................................................................................................................................104
i. The Court.............................................................................................................................104
ii. Role of judges......................................................................................................................104
2. Contentious function..............................................................................................................105
i. Concept................................................................................................................................105
ii. Special agreements.............................................................................................................106
iii. Compromissory clauses......................................................................................................106
iv. Optional Clause..................................................................................................................107
v. Preliminary objections: jurisdiction and admissibility.........................................................107
vi. Incidental proceedings.......................................................................................................108
3. Advisory function....................................................................................................................109
i. Concept................................................................................................................................110
ii. Can ICJ decline?...................................................................................................................110
viii
The benefits of buying summaries with Stuvia:
Guaranteed quality through customer reviews
Stuvia customers have reviewed more than 700,000 summaries. This how you know that you are buying the best documents.
Quick and easy check-out
You can quickly pay through credit card or Stuvia-credit for the summaries. There is no membership needed.
Focus on what matters
Your fellow students write the study notes themselves, which is why the documents are always reliable and up-to-date. This ensures you quickly get to the core!
Frequently asked questions
What do I get when I buy this document?
You get a PDF, available immediately after your purchase. The purchased document is accessible anytime, anywhere and indefinitely through your profile.
Satisfaction guarantee: how does it work?
Our satisfaction guarantee ensures that you always find a study document that suits you well. You fill out a form, and our customer service team takes care of the rest.
Who am I buying these notes from?
Stuvia is a marketplace, so you are not buying this document from us, but from seller MasterKULstudent. Stuvia facilitates payment to the seller.
Will I be stuck with a subscription?
No, you only buy these notes for $31.37. You're not tied to anything after your purchase.
Can Stuvia be trusted?
4.6 stars on Google & Trustpilot (+1000 reviews)
67096 documents were sold in the last 30 days
Founded in 2010, the go-to place to buy study notes for 14 years now