Samenvatting van alle colleges, werkgroepen en teksten geordend per week van het blok essential contemporary challenges.
Inhoud:
> WK1 Studying philosophy: Arendt, Crisis in education
> WK2 Mental Health: Hacking, the looping effect + Laing, the divided self
> WK3 Climate Crisis: Cath...
WK1: STUDYING PHILOSOPHY pg 3-6
Text 1 Arendt; Crisis in education (core)
LT02 Studying philosophy
WK2: MENTAL HEALTH pg 7-11
Text 2.1 Hacking; The looping effect of human kinds (core)
Text 2.2 Laing; In the divided self (mandatory)
LT03 Intro Mental Health
LT04 How to stay sane
WK3: CLIMATE CRISIS pg 12-18
Text 3.1 Catherine; Climate crisis: Facing extinction (core)
Text 3.2 Bottici; The environment is us (mandatory)
Text 3.3 Stengers; The intrusion of Gaia (mandatory)
LT05 Intro Climate crisis thinking
LT06 Climate change,
WK4: CONTESTING POLITICS pg 19-28
Text 4.1 Mouffe; For a left populism (core)
Text 4.2 Kaltwasser; Populism around the world (mandatory)
LT07 Democratic contestation
LT08 Populism
Examen Q5 pg 29-3
Examen info + overige vragen
,LT1 (Introduction) → (skip)
Course Introduction (canvas)
ECC course aims to promote philosophical reflection on contemporary challenges (education, mental
health, climate, politics).
Discussion of philosophical approach, descriptive/normative statements and role of philosophy.
Title Essential Contemporary Challenges
Predicament in title because ‘essential’ and ‘contemporary’ do not go together. Essential has
philosophical concept (necessary/forever true) whereas contemporary is temporal/contigent
(belonging to the present)
Challenges not problems
Philosophy is about challenges and how to think about these, not coming up with solutions.
● Instrumental thinking: reducing everything in life to a configuration of problems and solutions
● Accepting challenges is not problem solving but embracing the complexity of a problem.
● Requires stirring thinking: no analysis/criticism/irony but mindfulness and relativism in a
deeper sense of the world.
All essential contemporary challenges are actually existential challenges. → philosophical
methodology = attitude.
ECC: 4 themes
1. Studying philosophy
- What is a ‘challenge’? ‘Essential contemporary challenges’, why we get up in the
morning, the ‘twenty-first century’
- How is education instrumentalized and how should we interpret education? What is
education ‘about’?
2. Mental health
- What is it to be mentally (un)healthy? What is the importance of an existential
perspective? How should we think about normality?
3. Climate crisis
- How does ecology impact our thinking and acting? How should we conceive of
nature/culture? What is to be done?
4. Contesting politics
- How should we conceive of politics today? What is populism and where does it
come from?
, WK1 Studying Philosophy - Crisis in education
Text 1 - (core) Arendt, The crisis in Education
Literatuur: Arendt, H. (1961). The Crisis in Education, in: Between past and future: six exercises in
political thought. New York: Penguin Books, 173-196.
(Samenvatting: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cAENdNnSrzc )
Part I (pg 1-8)
> Crisis in education in modern world, characterised by decline of school system and disappearance
of common sense.
● Crisis as opportunity to explore the essence of the matter, back to the questions without
prejudices. (only becomes disaster when using prejudices → avoids reality so no reflection
possible)
● Though clear problem, still impossible to completely isolate the essential element from
circumstances
> Focus on crisis in education in America
● Novus Ordo Seclorum = a new order of the World (immigration!) (founding new world against
the old to get rid of poverty and oppression)
○ Continuous immigration influences politics, difficulty melting together most diverse
ethnic groups through education and americanization of children/parents.
○ These immigrants are guarantee to the country that it represents the new order (not
just needing immigrants to populate the land).
● Enthusiasm pathos of the new (thus also the newborn) which caused education (influenced
by Rousseauism) to become instrument of politics and political activity seen as form of
education
○ According to education logical to start a new world with newborns but according to
politics, the adult should have superiority (instead of equals). → education NOT part
of politics which deals with those already educated.
○ ‘It is in the nature of human condition that each new generation grows into an old
world; to prepare a new generation for a new world would mean taking away their
chance at the new (anything proposed by adults is older than the newcomers) → not
the case in america
○ In America: education has political role of americanizing children and parents which
creates illusion of building new world. Standards lag behind:
■ Not simply because young and not yet caught up with standards of old world
■ Crisis in education shows the failure of progressive education + problems
handling demands of mass society.
■ Concept of equality aggravated crisis → high school continuation of primary
school (democratic instead of meritocratic)
, Part II (pg 9-13)
> Measures that brought on the crisis are based on 3 assumptions:
1. Existence of child's world → autonomous society formed among children and governed by
them
○ Adult lost contact with child: authority that tells individual child what (not) to do lays
within the child group itself
○ Child worse of: authority of group stronger than that of individual person→ no
rebellion → hopeless minority
■ Through emancipation from authority of adults, child is not freed but
subjected to more terrific authority of majority
2. Teaching → pedagogy (approach to teaching) developed into a science of teaching in general
and emancipated from the actual material to be taught.
○ A teacher is trained in teaching (can teach anything), not in mastery of particular
subject → just a little ahead in knowledge → non-authoritarian teacher
3. Modern theory of learning → ‘one can know and understand only what one has done himself’
○ learning is substituted by doing
○ No importance attached to the teacher's mastering of the subject, no passing on of
‘dead knowledge’ but instead demonstrating how it is produced.
■ Limited in learning when substituted doing for learning and playing for
working (obliterates distinction between play and work)
■ It removes the habit (gradually more work, less playing) that prepares the
child for the adult world, in favor of the autonomy of the world of childhood
Part III
> Reflection on the role of education in civilization: what was learned from the crisis for the essence of
education?
● Education is elementary for human society, a crisis in education reflects a more general
crisis/instability in modern society.
○ Society continually renews itself through the birth of human beings → new to the
world + in a state of becoming.
○ Responsibilities of education: for the life/development of the child + continuance of
the world → preserving + protecting the new/child and the old/world
● Modern education → prejudice private/public life
○ destroys necessary conditions for vital development and growth despite aim to
emancipate child and free them from adult world -derived standards
○ Modern society discards the distinction private/public→ makes it harder for children
(who require security of concealment to mature undisturbed).
■ School is interposing institution that enables transition from private domain of
home to public world
■ Educators as representatives of a world for which they must assume
responsibility.
■ Teachers should know the world and instruct the students and authority rests
on his assumption of responsibility for this world..
○ Adults can discard authority by refusing to assume responsibility for the world in
which they brought child
● Conservatism in education →to preserve newness of child and introducing it to old world
○ Conservatism (conservation) is essential in education→ protecting new/child against
old/world (and other way around). To preserve the new, one has to preserve the old.
○ Conservatism is only good for education (relation adult/child) and not in politics
(adults should be equal)
The benefits of buying summaries with Stuvia:
Guaranteed quality through customer reviews
Stuvia customers have reviewed more than 700,000 summaries. This how you know that you are buying the best documents.
Quick and easy check-out
You can quickly pay through credit card or Stuvia-credit for the summaries. There is no membership needed.
Focus on what matters
Your fellow students write the study notes themselves, which is why the documents are always reliable and up-to-date. This ensures you quickly get to the core!
Frequently asked questions
What do I get when I buy this document?
You get a PDF, available immediately after your purchase. The purchased document is accessible anytime, anywhere and indefinitely through your profile.
Satisfaction guarantee: how does it work?
Our satisfaction guarantee ensures that you always find a study document that suits you well. You fill out a form, and our customer service team takes care of the rest.
Who am I buying these notes from?
Stuvia is a marketplace, so you are not buying this document from us, but from seller KaleyRozemarijn. Stuvia facilitates payment to the seller.
Will I be stuck with a subscription?
No, you only buy these notes for $7.49. You're not tied to anything after your purchase.
