Summary
Summary Resume of the readings week 1
- Course
- Institution
- Book
70 pages of Plato's "Republic" and Alan Ryan's "On Politics..." resumed in 9 pages
[Show more]
Connected book
Book Title:
Author(s):
- Edition:
- ISBN:
- Edition:
Seller
Followevanavince
Available practice questions
25 flashcards about the readings and lectures of week 1
Flashcards
25 Flashcards
$3.75
0 sales
Flashcards
25 Flashcards
$3.75
0 sales
Some examples from this set of practice questions
1.
According to Plato, who should rule ?
Answer: The Experts (Epistemocracy), ruling is a skill that requires knowledge.
2.
[A bit of History] What do you know about Plato ?
Answer: Lived in 428-347 BCA in Athens Well known philosopher, taught by Socrates Founded the Academy (lasted 300 years) Tried to teach Dionysius I (tyrant of Syracuse) how to be a philosopher king
3.
[A bit of History] What do you know about Athens ?
Answer: City state Popular democracy (limited to free male citizens) Regular meetings : ekklésia Urgent matters handled by a council of 500 citizens chosen by lot : boulé
4.
Plato\'s 2 criticisms of popular democracy
Answer: Leads to disorder/anarchy and reign of false
5.
3 dangers of demagogues
Answer: - The people is susceptible to flattery and demagogues - They can persuade the masses that their erats (fake political craft) is real - Undermines the habits of thought and reasonable expectations
6.
What is a demagogue ?
Answer: A Sophist, a populist, or someone who uses rhetoric to overturn preexisting opinions.
7.
4 theoretical problems of Epistemocracy
Answer: - On which grounds is someone thought qualified to lead ? - Who gets to monitor the admission of the experts ? - Are the ruling experts going to be accepted by the people ? - Will they rule fairly ?
8.
[A bit of History] What do you know about Aristotle ?
Answer: Lived in 384-322 BCA Was student and critic of Plato Mentored Alexander the Great Founded the Lyceum
9.
According to Aristotle, what is the fairest way to select rulers ?
Answer: Lottery
10.
Why would lottery be the fairest selection of political rulers ?
Answer: In a democracy, nobody is better than anybody else, therefore everybody should have equal rights to participate in politics. Lottery gives equal chances to everyone.
Content preview
Plato, Republic 488e-489d, « Ship of state »[Dialogue, Socrates and Adeimantus]
The cities will find a release from their troubles when the philosophers
(who are considered useless) become their rulers :
Analogy : A shipowner, who knows how to sail, is always surrounded by the sailors who are
begging him to give them the tiller ; sometimes, they even drug him or make him drink to take control
of the ship. When someone is good at finding ways to persuade the shipowner to let them sail, they
give him their respect by calling him a real seaman/captain.
What they do not understand is that one who truly fits to take command must be familiar with
seasons of the year, the stars, the winds, etc. How to steer is seen as the art of being a ship’s captain and
not as something that can be learned, a skill that could be taught. Therefore, in this situation, a person
actually equipped to be captain would be mocked and called an useless stargazer.
It describes the attitude of cities towards true philosophers, who are not treated with respect.
The uselessness, however, is not in the philosophers, but on the people who is not using them (for their
knowledge). A captain would not ask his sailors to come under his command or a wise man would
never go to a rich person’s door. As no matter if someone is rich or poor, when they are ill, they need to
seek a doctor ; the people who wants to be ruled has to go seeking a person who knows how to.
Philosophers are described as villains by their opponents, that makes philosophy (the good)
useless. Therefore, it is inevitable to those who go into philosophy will turn out as villains too
(philosophy is not to be blamed).
Alan Ryan, On politics pp. 31-38,
« The Paradoxical Plato » and « Plato’s Life »
The history of political thinking began with Plato, even though his political thought is anti-
political. Lots of thinkers thought a certain degree of social harmony would make disappear political
conflicts and politics. Utopian thinkers hope to maintain social order and meet the needs of the
population without economic or political competition.
Plato did not take seriously the inescapability of politics. An other writer, more than two
millennia later, Karl Marx did the same. He thought the abolition of capitalism would abolish economic
conflict and with it the need for government and politics. His refusal to prescribe for an unknowable
future was admirable; but his unwillingness to say more about how a society might operate, beyond
saying that the first step was to establish the dictatorship of the proletariat, turned out to be disastrous.
Many commentators have thought of Republic as a treatise on education, but its political
message is the need to enlighten us so that we may become fit to live in kallipolis, the ideal city.
Plato’s subject is the ignorance of politicians. The thought that nothing will go well until kings
are philosophers or philosophers are kings, he believed that knowledge was the root of salvation and
ignorance the root of perdition. We may wonder why Plato was convinced that lack of knowledge was
the major issue rather than greed, anger, or the other dangerous emotions to which we are prey.
Socrates held some of the doctrines attributed to him by Plato: that nobody does evil willingly,
wickedness is error and that it is better to suffer wrong than to do it. The ideas that modern readers find
least plausible are those with the clearest origin in Socrates’s known doctrines, particularly the equation
of virtue with knowledge and the doctrine that no one does evil willingly. It is possible that he, like
Plato, thought that democracy is the second-worst of all forms of government, one step better than
tyranny.
, Plato came from an upper-class Athenian family, and his relatives were members of the
murderous oligarchy that briefly replaced the Athenian democracy at the end of the Peloponnesian War.
He took no part in politics and welcomed the restoration of democracy as the restoration of the rule of
law, but was disillusioned by the judicial murder of Socrates.
The trial and execution of Socrates in 399 (B.C.E.) was a key moment in European thought;
more immediately, it was a crisis in the lives of his students and disciples. Many of his followers went
into voluntary exile, Plato among them; he returned to Athens several years later, and founded the
Academy in 387.
There were competing schools, and others sprang up later, but there was an earlier tradition of
individual teachers of rhetoric and philosophy giving instruction to ambitious young men who hoped to
make a name in politics. They were the Sophists, who receive hostile treatment throughout Plato’s
Dialogues. The Sophists took their clients’ desire for worldly success as the starting point, and taught
them what they needed for success in the law-courts and in debate in the assembly.
Plato’s practical interventions in politics were limited, and they nearly cost him his life. During
his exile, he was befriended by Dionysius I, the tyrant of Syracuse, who then became irritated with him,
and may have decided to sell him into slavery. Some years later, he was cajoled into an other attempt to
turn a tyrant into a philosopher-king, and again escaped with some difficulty.
Alan Ryan, On politics pp. 97-99,
« Aristotle’s Classification of Constitutions »
Aristocracy is in principle the best form of government: the best men rule because they possess
judgment, courage, justice, and moderation. Yet experience shows that aristocracies have a regrettable
habit of becoming oligarchies in which class pride rules.
To see how Aristotle resolved the
difficulties as he understood them, we
must turn to what he is best remembered
for, the sexpartite distinction between
forms of government according to the
numbers who participate in them, on the
one hand, and their goodness or
corruption, on the other :
Aristotle believed that poverty should disqualify men from active citizenship. The “narrow
democracy” or “expanded aristocracy” of the well-balanced politeia is the remedy. A narrow
democracy would not permit the lowest social class to hold offices; conversely, an expanded
aristocracy would be a system in which the requirements were not onerous, as oligarchical parties want
to institute. A too restrictive or broad constitution arouse resentment: the middle ground is the answer.
Aristotle connects the excellence of citizens with the excellence of the constitutional form. A
virtuous man is more likely to be corrupted by absolute power than to become wiser and more virtuous;
The benefits of buying summaries with Stuvia:
Guaranteed quality through customer reviews
Stuvia customers have reviewed more than 700,000 summaries. This how you know that you are buying the best documents.
Quick and easy check-out
You can quickly pay through credit card or Stuvia-credit for the summaries. There is no membership needed.
Focus on what matters
Your fellow students write the study notes themselves, which is why the documents are always reliable and up-to-date. This ensures you quickly get to the core!
Frequently asked questions
What do I get when I buy this document?
You get a PDF, available immediately after your purchase. The purchased document is accessible anytime, anywhere and indefinitely through your profile.
Satisfaction guarantee: how does it work?
Our satisfaction guarantee ensures that you always find a study document that suits you well. You fill out a form, and our customer service team takes care of the rest.
Who am I buying these notes from?
Stuvia is a marketplace, so you are not buying this document from us, but from seller evanavince. Stuvia facilitates payment to the seller.
Will I be stuck with a subscription?
No, you only buy these notes for $0.00. You're not tied to anything after your purchase.
Can Stuvia be trusted?
4.6 stars on Google & Trustpilot (+1000 reviews)
67474 documents were sold in the last 30 days
Founded in 2010, the go-to place to buy study notes for 14 years now