Discussion 1: Hooks
General information about Hooks and the chapters:
Bell Hooks, born in 1952, is a prominent feminist educator and socio-cultural critic known for her influential work on
feminism, education, and critical pedagogy. She has taught at institutions like Berea College in Kentucky, where she
holds the position of Distinguished Professor in Residence. Her work encompasses a wide range of topics, including
feminism, men and patriarchy, sexuality and love, cultural criticism, media and film studies, as well as children's
literature.
hooks is best known for her theories and pedagogical approaches that transcend boundaries of race, gender, class,
and educational levels. Her teaching trilogy, consisting of "Teaching to Transgress: Education as the Practice of
Freedom" (1994), "Teaching Community: A Pedagogy of Hope" (2003), and "Teaching Critical Thinking: Practical
Wisdom" (2010), encapsulates her ideas of anti-racist, anti-colonial, multi-cultural, and critical and feminist
pedagogies. She emphasizes community, pedagogy of hope, self-reflection, critique of power, and critical thinking as
essential qualities for transformative learning experiences. Her pedagogical approach is particularly relevant to social
work and supervision.
Early in her life, hooks was inspired by her experiences at an all-black school in the American South. Her black
women teachers nurtured intellectual growth and encouraged students to become scholars and critical thinkers.
These experiences taught her that education could be a revolutionary act, particularly for marginalized communities.
Despite her positive early experiences, hooks faced the constraints of her race, gender, and class, especially when
she transitioned to predominantly white colleges and graduate schools. She encountered a system that reinforced
domination, obedient compliance, and lacked contextualization of knowledge within the framework of black student
lives. This fueled her desire to become a teacher who could challenge these norms and empower students.
Hooks' academic journey led her to gain a BA in English Literature at Stanford, an MA at the University of Wisconsin,
and a PhD at UCLA. She eventually secured a teaching position at Yale, though her academic achievements did not
eliminate the racist, elitist culture pervasive in education at the time. In her teaching career, hooks had the
opportunity to explore pedagogical paradigms, especially in feminist classrooms, where pedagogical practices were
open to interrogation. She drew inspiration from educators like Paulo Freire, Sojourner Truth, Martin Luther King Jr.,
and Thich Nhat Hanh. hooks's initial attempts to create a transformative learning community faced resistance from
students who were not accustomed to pedagogical innovation.
However, things changed when hooks shifted from a formal teacher role to engaging students as intellectuals. She
began to document her experiences, leading to her first book, "Teaching to Transgress: Education as the Practice of
Freedom." In this book, she outlined her efforts to transform the traditional classroom into an exciting and liberatory
space for learning. She emphasized the importance of authentic education in enabling students to become "whole"
human beings.
Hooks continued her exploration of alternative learning cultures in her book "Teaching Community: A Pedagogy of
Hope." She called on teachers to teach democratically, approach teaching as an art form, and create spaces for
invention and mutual engagement. She encouraged teachers and students to confront feelings of difference and
trauma, emphasizing the importance of genuine respect and care in the classroom.
In her third book, "Teaching Critical Thinking: Practical Wisdom," hooks expanded on her previous works, offering a
deeper exploration of her experiences and pedagogical practices. She used testimonials and transcripts of
conversations with students and colleagues to present her ideas in a candid and accessible manner. Hooks aimed to
make the classroom a place of intense learning and engagement.
Throughout her work, hooks advocates for the integration of feminist and anti-racist theories with practical
application, and she prioritizes accessibility and inclusivity in her writing and pedagogy. Her approach challenges
traditional academic discourse and emphasizes the importance of teaching as a means of empowerment, liberation,
and community building, both in and outside the classroom.
1
,The text: Bell Hooks trilogy – pedagogy for social work supervision
Summary of the chapters
1. “Introduction” P501
The introduction provides an overview of bell hooks, an influential feminist educator and socio-cultural critic. She has
contributed to various academic fields and authored numerous scholarly articles, books, and children's literature. The
chapter focuses on her key concepts and pedagogical approach, particularly her teaching trilogy, which includes
"Teaching to Transgress," "Teaching Community," and "Teaching Critical Thinking." These works encapsulate her ideas
of anti-racist, anti-colonial, multicultural, and critical feminist pedagogies. Her work emphasizes community,
pedagogy of hope, self-reflection, critique of power, and critical thinking as essential for transformative learning.
These ideas are relevant to social work, especially in teaching critical thinking and fostering transformational
learning, and can be applied in social work supervision to embed a critical worldview in current and future
practitioners.
2. “Early life” P501
The text provides insights into bell hooks' early life and educational experiences. Growing up in the American South,
she attended an all-black school where her black women teachers emphasized nurturing intellect and individual
voices. Hooks saw education as a means to resist racist colonialism, and her early school years were marked by a
revolutionary pedagogy that encouraged intellectual exploration. However, as she pursued higher education, she
encountered the constraints of her race, gender, and class. She attended predominantly white colleges and graduate
schools where the educational experience was marred by teachers reinforcing white supremacist and patriarchal
values. Hooks observed the dehumanizing aspects of education that crushed spirits rather than empowering
students. She found that knowledge was often presented without a critical lens, and non-conformity was viewed
negatively, particularly for black students. The curricula did not relate to the lives of marginalized and oppressed
individuals, and education seemed more focused on reinforcing domination. These biases and discrimination created
additional stress in her adult learning experiences.
3. Academic endeavours P502
The text discusses bell hooks' academic journey during the 1960s and 1970s, a period marked by calls for radical
change and the rise of equality and democratic education. Despite the climate of change, hooks found that the old
hierarchies of class, gender, and race remained entrenched, particularly for black students who faced the challenge
of reconciling their aspirations with the reality of systemic inequalities. She aspired to become a teacher to help
students become self-directed learners, but she encountered ongoing abuses of power within the education system.
Despite the stress, boredom, and apathy she experienced, hooks used these emotions as inspiration to advocate for a
different approach to learning. Against considerable odds, she achieved a BA in English Literature at Stanford in 1973,
an MA at the University of Wisconsin in 1976, and a PhD at UCLA in 1983. These academic accomplishments did not
eliminate the prevailing racist and elitist culture of education, nor did they diminish her passion for learning and
teaching, which she continues to pursue.
4. “Teaching career” P503
The text discusses bell hooks' teaching career, focusing on her experiences in feminist classrooms during the 1980s
and 1990s. In these spaces, she began to explore pedagogical paradigms aimed at critiquing the politics of
domination within academic culture. She was influenced by figures such as Paulo Freire, Sojourner Truth, Martin
Luther King Jr., and Thich Nhat Hanh, whose ideas helped shape her approach to critical pedagogies. hooks faced
resistance from students who were initially hesitant to embrace new pedagogical practices that transgressed
conventional boundaries. However, she persisted in her efforts to create a transformative learning community. hooks
believed that authentic education should help students become "whole" human beings and enable self-discovery
and self-actualization.
2
, 5. Critical thinking P505
This text discusses bell hooks' approach to critical thinking and pedagogy. It highlights her unique contributions to
teaching critical thinking and employing an engaged pedagogy, emphasizing their direct applicability to her life and
challenges in and outside the classroom. Hooks' concept of critical thinking involves discovering the fundamental
aspects of a subject and using that knowledge to determine what truly matters. It requires active engagement, open-
mindedness, and a commitment to understanding core truths rather than surface-level information. Central to her
approach are conversations, stories, personal narratives, and reflections that create a classroom where every voice is
heard. Hooks believes in the power of stories as a means of connecting individuals to a diverse world. She
emphasizes the importance of critically reviewing assumptions, content, and shared experiences through various
theoretical and experiential lenses to build and maintain an authentic learning community.
6. Current context of higher education P507
This text addresses the current context of higher education and the challenges posed by oppressive hegemonic
curricula and practices in many institutions. The author discusses how culture and politics are closely intertwined,
and many higher education institutions still rely on pre-determined curricula and traditional teaching methods, such
as lectures, textbooks, and exams. Several scholars, including bell hooks, Henry Giroux, Stephen D. Brookfield, and
Raewyn Connell, advocate for challenging the existing power structures within higher education.
7. Critically informed social work P508
The text explores the concept of critically informed social work, emphasizing its role in addressing social issues
related to marginalized and stigmatized groups. Social work often deals with marginalized populations, including the
poor, unemployed, homeless, migrants, and others who face social stigma and oppression. This oppression is seen as
a consequence of the "politics of imperialist, white-supremacist, capitalist patriarchy," where certain privileged
groups benefit from social, political, cultural, and economic power. The critical agenda of social work is to empower
and liberate individuals from oppression, promote justice and human rights, and challenge systems and processes
contributing to their oppression.
8. Critical social work supervision: applying an engaged pedagogy P508
This text discusses the application of critical social work supervision using an engaged pedagogy. It highlights that
supervision is an opportunity for both supervisors and supervisees (practitioners or students) to enrich their practice,
integrate theory with practice, and address conflicts encountered in their work. Drawing on bell hooks' critical
pedagogy, critical supervision supports the development of critical practitioners in social work. This pedagogy aims to
create practitioners who can analyze the broader contexts and dynamics of their practice, understanding the nature
of oppression and how to challenge dominant hegemonic structures. The text emphasizes that developing a critical
educational practice and a critical lens is an ongoing, lifelong commitment. While achieving social, political, or
educational change may be challenging, understanding power dynamics and the potential for change can imbue
practitioners with a sense of purpose and future possibilities. Critical supervision can occur in various settings,
including individual, group, peer, and community-based supervision, but it requires appropriate tools and skills to be
effective.
9. Critical (engaged) pedagogy for use in supervision sessions: how? P509
This text explores the application of critical (engaged) pedagogy in supervision sessions, particularly in the context of
social work. Critical pedagogy for supervision involves practices such as critical questioning, analysis, reflection,
reading, deconstruction, and having critical conversations before, during, and after practice. It encourages reflecting
on the power dynamics and interpretations within the supervisor-supervisee relationship and scrutinizing the
content, structure, tasks, and assessments used in supervision sessions. The text also discusses the importance of
democratizing the supervision process and valuing diverse experiences and interpretations. It suggests various tools
and techniques, such as critical reflection, analysis of critical incidents, and narrative approaches, to develop a critical
pedagogy.
3
