Met deze samenvatting kan je het boek op de plank laten liggen.
In deze samenvatting: Hoorcolleges, werkgroepen, leesvragen, samenvattingen van alle gelezen artikelen en hoofdstukken van de Policy Paradox – Stone. Slechts 1 artikel mist; Howlett et al. Chapter 5.
Daarnaast zijn ook de artike...
Samenvattingen Beleid, Rationaliteit en
Macht + Training ‘Conflicthantering &
onderhandelen’
Jasmijn Pelders - studiejaar 2021
In deze samenvatti ng: Hoorcolleges, werkgroepen, leesvragen, samenvatti ngen
van alle gelezen arti kelen en hoofdstukken van de Policy Paradox – Stone.
Slechts 1 arti kel mist; Howlett et al. Chapter 5 .
Daarnaast zijn ook de arti kelen behoren bij de training ‘confl icthantering &
onderhandelen’ samengevat en toegevoegd.
Voor het overzicht is er een inhoudsopgave toegevoegd en zijn de pagina’s voorzien van een
paginanummer. Op deze manier is het makkelijk zoeken in deze uitgebreide samenvatting.
1
,Inhoudsopgave
C&O Training: Huguenin (2010)...........................................................................................................................7
§4.3 Conflictgedrag..............................................................................................................................................7
§4.3.1 Logische niveaus.......................................................................................................................................7
§4.3.2 Conflictstijlen............................................................................................................................................7
§ 4.3.3 Conflictstijl en omgeving........................................................................................................................10
§ 4.3.4 Belemmeringen en aangrijpingspunten bij de ontwikkelen van stijlkeuze.............................................11
C&O Training: Paul Cairney blogpost "What is policy?"...............................................................................15
Mastenbroek (1996), Onderhandelingsrelaties, in: conflicthantering en organisatieontwikkeling...............17
§6.1 Inleiding......................................................................................................................................................17
§6.2 Onderhandelen...........................................................................................................................................17
§6.3 Onderhandelen: vier activiteiten................................................................................................................18
§6.4 Fase bij onderhandelen..............................................................................................................................22
§6.5 Effectief onderhandelen, conclusies...........................................................................................................23
Fisher, Ury, Patton (1994) ‘Richt je op belangen, niet op posities’..................................................................24
§1 Niet onderhandelen over posities..................................................................................................................24
§2 argumenteren over posities levert onverstandige overeenkomsten op..........................................................24
§3 Argumenteren over posities is niet efficiënt..................................................................................................24
§4 Argumenteren over posities brengt relaties in gevaar..................................................................................24
§5 Als er veel partijen zijn, is positioneel onderhandelen nog veel erger..........................................................24
§6 Aardig zijn is geen antwoord.........................................................................................................................24
§7 Er is een andere mogelijkheid.......................................................................................................................25
Carney Chapter 4 Bounded rationality and the Psychology of Policymaking................................................27
Introduction: The profound importance of bounded rationality........................................................................27
Comprehensive and bounded rationality............................................................................................................27
Bounded Rationality Is More Important Than Ever...........................................................................................28
Incrementalism...................................................................................................................................................28
Is Incrementalism ‘Universal’ and Inevitable?..................................................................................................29
The Narative policy framework..........................................................................................................................29
Carney Chapter 9 : Punctuated Equilibrium Theory (PET)............................................................................30
Introduction: The profound importance of policymaker attention.....................................................................30
Why ‘Punctuated equilibrium’ theory (PET)?...................................................................................................30
PET’s orginal focus: Agendas and instability....................................................................................................30
Policy subsystems, monopolies, and subsystems................................................................................................31
Issue networks and subsystems...........................................................................................................................31
Agenda setting and attention..............................................................................................................................31
Problem definition..............................................................................................................................................32
2
,Howlett et al. Chapter 5........................................................................................................................................33
Hoorcollege 15-02-2021.........................................................................................................................................34
Hoofdlijnen: Beleidskeuzes en -instrumenten....................................................................................................34
Reflectie op hoofdlijnen......................................................................................................................................36
Actualiteit – met Jeroen Hannekamp.................................................................................................................36
Michels (2018): Burgerparticipatie in het beleid, bewonersinitiatieven en de rol van de gemeenteraad.....42
Inleiding..............................................................................................................................................................42
Burgerparticipatie in historisch perspectief.......................................................................................................42
Interactief beleid en bewonersinitiatieven..........................................................................................................43
De gemeenteraad onder druk.............................................................................................................................44
Burgerbegroting, burgertop en burgerraad.......................................................................................................44
Kanttekeningen bij burgerparticipatie...............................................................................................................45
Pülzl & Treib: Implementing Public Policy........................................................................................................46
1. Introduction....................................................................................................................................................46
2. Top-down, bottom-up, and hybrid theories of implementation......................................................................46
§2.1 Top-down theorieën...............................................................................................................................46
2.2 Bottom-up theorieën................................................................................................................................47
2.3 vergelijkende discussie............................................................................................................................47
2.4 Hybride theorieën....................................................................................................................................48
3 New developments in implementation analysis...............................................................................................48
3.1 Implementatie in een internationale context: nieuws uit de Europese Integratiestudies.........................48
3.2 De interpretatieve benadering van beleidsuitvoering..............................................................................49
4 Thirty years of implementation research: what have we learned?.................................................................49
5 Conclusions and further outlook.....................................................................................................................50
Hoorcollege week 8: Lokale besluitvorming en -uitvoering..............................................................................54
Deel A – Hoofdlijnen..........................................................................................................................................54
Implementatie: Top-down vs bottom-up.............................................................................................................54
Pulzl & Treib......................................................................................................................................................54
De lokale implementatiestijl...............................................................................................................................54
Sterke druk op participatie.................................................................................................................................55
Motieven burgerparticipatie...............................................................................................................................55
Issues burgerparticipatie....................................................................................................................................56
Beleidsplan.........................................................................................................................................................57
Deel B – Kennisclips (Besluitvorming in gemeenten & Gemeenten in de gedecentraliseerde eenheidsstaat). .57
Besluitvorming in gemeenten.............................................................................................................................57
3
, Gemeenten in de gedecentraliseerde eenheidsstaat...........................................................................................57
Van Bommel et al. (2015) Interpretive policy analysis in the Netherlands......................................................59
5.1 Introduction..................................................................................................................................................59
5.2 An interpretive approach to policy research................................................................................................59
5.3 Developing interpretive policy analysis in the Netherlands: an genealogy (= stamboomonderzoek).........59
5.4 main theoreticial-analytic focuses of Dutch interpretive policy research...................................................59
5.5 Understanding interpretive policy analysis in the Netherlands...................................................................61
Policy Paradox (Stone, 2012) Introduction: Why This Book?..........................................................................62
The Rationality Project.......................................................................................................................................62
Policy Paradox (Stone, 2012) Chapter 1: The Market and the Polis................................................................64
Community..........................................................................................................................................................64
Altruïsme.............................................................................................................................................................64
Public Interest....................................................................................................................................................64
Common problems..............................................................................................................................................65
Influence.............................................................................................................................................................65
Cooperation........................................................................................................................................................65
Loyalty................................................................................................................................................................66
Groups................................................................................................................................................................66
Information.........................................................................................................................................................66
Passion...............................................................................................................................................................66
Power..................................................................................................................................................................66
Hoorcollege 01-03-2021.........................................................................................................................................68
Hoofdlijnen.........................................................................................................................................................68
Reflectie op hoofdlijnen......................................................................................................................................69
Policy Paradox (Stone, 2012) Chapter 2: Equity................................................................................................74
The dimensions of equality.................................................................................................................................74
1 Membership................................................................................................................................................74
2 Merit...........................................................................................................................................................74
3 Rank............................................................................................................................................................75
4 Group-Based Distribution...........................................................................................................................75
5 Need............................................................................................................................................................76
6 Value...........................................................................................................................................................76
7, 8, and 9 Competition, Lotteries, and Elections..........................................................................................76
Choosing a distributive method..........................................................................................................................76
Inequality............................................................................................................................................................77
Inequality and community.............................................................................................................................77
Inequality and democracy..............................................................................................................................77
4
,Policy Paradox (Stone, 2012) Chapter 3: Efficiency..........................................................................................78
What is efficiency?..............................................................................................................................................78
Markets and Efficiency.......................................................................................................................................78
Making Markets in the Polis...............................................................................................................................79
1 Rationality...................................................................................................................................................79
Full Information.............................................................................................................................................79
Voluntarism...................................................................................................................................................79
Externalities...................................................................................................................................................79
Public goods...................................................................................................................................................79
Competition...................................................................................................................................................80
Whose efficiency?...............................................................................................................................................80
The equality-efficiency trade-off.........................................................................................................................80
Policy Paradox (Stone, 2012) Chapter 4: Welfare..............................................................................................81
Dimensions of need.............................................................................................................................................81
1 Material Needs vs. Symbolic Needs...........................................................................................................81
2 Intrinsic vs Instrumental Needs..................................................................................................................81
3 Volatility vs Security..................................................................................................................................81
4 Quantity vs Quality.....................................................................................................................................82
5 Individual Needs vs Relational Needs........................................................................................................82
6 Absolute vs Relative Needs........................................................................................................................82
Making Needs in the Polis..................................................................................................................................82
Moral Hazard and the Welfare-Efficiency Trade-off.........................................................................................83
Policy Paradox (Stone, 2012) Chapter 5: Liberty..............................................................................................84
Making Liberty in the Polis: five Paradoxes......................................................................................................85
1 Negative and Positive Liberty....................................................................................................................85
2 Positive Obligations....................................................................................................................................85
3 Paternalism.................................................................................................................................................85
4 Freedom of Speech.....................................................................................................................................86
5 Multiculturalism.........................................................................................................................................86
The Liberty-Equality Trade-off...........................................................................................................................86
The Liberty-Welfare Trade-Off...........................................................................................................................86
Policy Paradox (Stone, 2012) Chapter 5: Security.............................................................................................87
Three concept of Securtiy...................................................................................................................................87
Psychological Security and its Complications...................................................................................................87
Making Security in the Polis...............................................................................................................................88
Science and Politics Vie for Authority................................................................................................................88
Double Edged Swords........................................................................................................................................89
The Security-Democracy Trade-off....................................................................................................................89
Hoorcollege 08-03-2021 (week 5)..........................................................................................................................90
Doelen van beleid (hoofdlijnen).........................................................................................................................90
Hoorcollege 5B Collegereflectie – The Point of Politics...................................................................................91
, Stories of Change: Decline and Rising..............................................................................................................99
Stories of Power: helplessness and Control.....................................................................................................100
Synecdoche.......................................................................................................................................................100
Metaphors.........................................................................................................................................................100
Ambiguity..........................................................................................................................................................101
Policy Paradox (Stone, 2012) Chapter 8: Numbers..........................................................................................102
Numbers and Metaphors..................................................................................................................................102
Numbers and Norms and Symbols....................................................................................................................102
The hidden Stories in Numbers.........................................................................................................................102
Making numbers in the Polis............................................................................................................................103
Policy Paradox (Stone, 2012) Chapter 9: Causes.............................................................................................105
Causal Stories as Problem definition...............................................................................................................105
Making Causes in the Polis..............................................................................................................................106
Using Causes in the Polis.................................................................................................................................107
Policy Paradox (Stone, 2012) Chapter 10: Interests........................................................................................108
Making Interests in the Polis............................................................................................................................108
Mobilizing Interests..........................................................................................................................................108
Rational Choice Theory: Pluralism Turned on its Head..................................................................................108
Collective Action in the Polis...........................................................................................................................109
How Issues and Interests Define Each Other...................................................................................................109
Good Interests versus Bad................................................................................................................................109
Policy Paradox (Stone, 2012) Chapter 11: Decisions.......................................................................................111
Rational Decision Making................................................................................................................................111
Making Decisions in de Polis...........................................................................................................................111
Defining goals..............................................................................................................................................111
Selecting Alternatives..................................................................................................................................111
Controlling the Policial Meanings of Alternatives......................................................................................112
Evaluating Policy alternatives with Cost-Benefit Analysis.........................................................................112
Hoorcollege 15-03-2021 (week 6) – Problemen in beleid.................................................................................114
HC 6b The Stuff of Politics...............................................................................................................................116
Voordelen van het kopen van samenvattingen bij Stuvia op een rij:
Verzekerd van kwaliteit door reviews
Stuvia-klanten hebben meer dan 700.000 samenvattingen beoordeeld. Zo weet je zeker dat je de beste documenten koopt!
Snel en makkelijk kopen
Je betaalt supersnel en eenmalig met iDeal, creditcard of Stuvia-tegoed voor de samenvatting. Zonder lidmaatschap.
Focus op de essentie
Samenvattingen worden geschreven voor en door anderen. Daarom zijn de samenvattingen altijd betrouwbaar en actueel. Zo kom je snel tot de kern!
Veelgestelde vragen
Wat krijg ik als ik dit document koop?
Je krijgt een PDF, die direct beschikbaar is na je aankoop. Het gekochte document is altijd, overal en oneindig toegankelijk via je profiel.
Tevredenheidsgarantie: hoe werkt dat?
Onze tevredenheidsgarantie zorgt ervoor dat je altijd een studiedocument vindt dat goed bij je past. Je vult een formulier in en onze klantenservice regelt de rest.
Van wie koop ik deze samenvatting?
Stuvia is een marktplaats, je koop dit document dus niet van ons, maar van verkoper jasmijnpelders. Stuvia faciliteert de betaling aan de verkoper.
Zit ik meteen vast aan een abonnement?
Nee, je koopt alleen deze samenvatting voor €15,49. Je zit daarna nergens aan vast.
