Table of Contents
College 1: 30 september 2022.................................................................................................................4
Ia. General Information .................................................................................................................................... 4
Ib. Concept of Human Rights Law ..................................................................................................................... 5
1. TERMINOLOGY .................................................................................................................................................................. 5
2. LEGAL SOURCES ................................................................................................................................................................ 6
3. HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE................................................................................................................................................. 8
4. NO HIERARCHY.................................................................................................................................................................. 9
College 2: 3 oktober 2022 ..................................................................................................................... 10
II. Universal protection (United Nations)......................................................................................................... 10
1. Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR 1948) .................................................................................................. 10
2. Treaties............................................................................................................................................................................ 10
3. Universal Mechanisms.................................................................................................................................................... 11
4. Illustrations ..................................................................................................................................................................... 13
III. The council of Europe ................................................................................................................................ 14
1. Two Europes.................................................................................................................................................................... 14
College 3: 7 oktober 2022 ..................................................................................................................... 16
2. Council of Europe ............................................................................................................................................................ 16
College 4: 10 oktober 2022 ................................................................................................................... 19
IV. European Union ........................................................................................................................................ 23
1. CHARTER OF FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS OF THE EU ............................................................................................................... 23
2. EU ENFORCEMENT MECHANISMS ....................................................................................................................................... 23
College 5: 14 oktober 2022 ................................................................................................................... 24
European Union ............................................................................................................................................. 24
2. EU ENFORCEMENT MECHANISMS ....................................................................................................................................... 24
V. Jurisdiction and Extra-territoriality ............................................................................................................. 25
1. Sources.................................................................................................................................................................................. 25
2. Art. 1 ECHR: jurisdiction ....................................................................................................................................................... 25
3. Art. 1 ECHR: attribution: participation in UN-operations ................................................................................................... 28
4. Art. 2(1) CESCR: ‘Internal obligations’ ................................................................................................................................. 29
CASES AND QUESTIONS.................................................................................................................................. 30
College 6: 21 oktober 2022 (2 colleges achter elkaar)............................................................................ 31
VI. Effects of Human Rights Treaties in Belgium .............................................................................................. 31
1. Relationship between legal orders: effect of treaties in Belgium ...................................................................................... 31
2. Human Rights Protection in Belgium................................................................................................................................... 33
3. Execution of ECtHR judgements in Belgium: hoe voer je een beslissing van EHRM uit? .................................................. 33
4. Effective remedy .................................................................................................................................................................. 34
VII. Typology of Human Rights Obligations...................................................................................................... 34
1. Human Rights Treaties: interpreting open norms .............................................................................................................. 34
- Interpretation techniques .............................................................................................................................................. 34
2. Typology of the State’s Obligations: verschillende soorten staatsverplichtingen ............................................................ 36
2. A Negative Obligations (obligation to respect) ................................................................................................................... 36
2. B Positive Obligations (obligation to protect and fulfill) .................................................................................................... 37
2.C Nature of the Stat’s Obligations (cont’d) .......................................................................................................................... 39
CASES AND QUESTIONS.................................................................................................................................. 40
1
,College 7: 24 oktober 2022 ................................................................................................................... 41
3. Derogable rights in Times of emergency ....................................................................................................................... 41
Cases and questions ................................................................................................................................................................. 42
VIII. Right to life ............................................................................................................................................. 43
1. Absolute right ....................................................................................................................................................................... 43
2. Scope..................................................................................................................................................................................... 43
3. Obligations............................................................................................................................................................................ 44
B. Positive obligations......................................................................................................................................................... 45
a. Osman test!!!!! ............................................................................................................................................................... 45
b. Obligations ...................................................................................................................................................................... 45
4. Positive obligations and right to life.................................................................................................................................... 46
4.1 Against authority ................................................................................................................................................................ 46
4.2 Against third parties: against other individuals ................................................................................................................ 46
4. 3 Against yourself ................................................................................................................................................................. 46
o Lambert v. France ........................................................................................................................................................... 47
College 8: 28 oktober 2022 ................................................................................................................... 48
4.4. Minimal living conditions.................................................................................................................................................. 48
4.5 Procedural obligations ....................................................................................................................................................... 48
CASES AND QUESTIONS.................................................................................................................................. 51
College 9: 4 november 2022 ................................................................................................................. 53
IX. Prohibition of torture of inhuman of degrading treatment ......................................................................... 53
1. Absolute right ....................................................................................................................................................................... 53
2. Applicability .......................................................................................................................................................................... 54
3. Classification (merits) ........................................................................................................................................................... 55
4. Obligations............................................................................................................................................................................ 56
5. Attribution – burden of proof (toeschrijving – bewijslast)................................................................................................. 56
College 10: 7 november 2022 ............................................................................................................... 60
CASES AND QUESTIONS.................................................................................................................................. 62
XA. Right to a fair trial = applicability .............................................................................................................. 63
College 11: 14 november 2022.............................................................................................................. 66
XB. Right to a fair trial = guarantees ............................................................................................................... 66
§1. General guarantees with ‘implied limitations’ (= Algemene waarborgen met impliciete beperkingen) ....................... 66
1. Right to a court (including right of acces) (= recht op een rechter: inclusief recht op toegang) ...................................... 67
2. Organisation and composition ............................................................................................................................................ 67
3. Conduct of the proceedings (= verloop van de procedure) ................................................................................................ 68
§2. Criminal proceedings: right to be presumed innocent (recht van vermoeden van onschuld) ....................................... 70
1. Right to participate in the hearing ...................................................................................................................................... 71
2. Law of evidence/right to remain silent ............................................................................................................................... 72
College 12: 18 november 2022.............................................................................................................. 73
3. Right of acces to a lawyer .................................................................................................................................................... 73
CASES AND QUESTIONS.................................................................................................................................. 76
College 13: 21 november 2022.............................................................................................................. 79
XII. Right to Respect for Private and Family Life .............................................................................................. 79
A. Right to respect for private life (recht op eerbieding van het privé leven) .................................................... 79
• I. Toepassingsgbied......................................................................................................................................................... 79
• II. Negatieve verplichting ............................................................................................................................................... 80
College 14: 25 november 2022.............................................................................................................. 87
B. Right to Respect Family Life ........................................................................................................................ 89
• Negatieve verplichtingen ............................................................................................................................................... 89
• Positieve verplichtingen ................................................................................................................................................. 90
2
, CASES AND QUESTIONS (p.410) ...................................................................................................................... 91
College 15: 28 november 2022.............................................................................................................. 95
XIII. Freedom of Assembly and Association (vrijheid van vergadering en vereniging) ....................................... 95
1. Bronnen ................................................................................................................................................................................ 95
2. Vrijheid van vergadering en vereniging .............................................................................................................................. 95
3. Vakbondsvrijheid ............................................................................................................................................................ 98
4. Recht op staking: beschermd door artikel 11 EVRM? ................................................................................................... 99
CASES AND QUESTIONS (p.436) .................................................................................................................... 101
College 16: 2 December 2022 ............................................................................................................. 102
XIV. Economic, Social and Cultural Rights ...................................................................................................... 103
1. Wettelijke bronnen ............................................................................................................................................................ 103
2. Klassieke (gedateerde?) aanpak ........................................................................................................................................ 105
3. Alternatieve geïntegreerde benadering ............................................................................................................................ 106
4. ESCR (Europees verdrag voor sociale en culturele rechten): typologie van de verplichtingn ........................................ 108
College 17: 5 December 2022 ............................................................................................................. 111
CASES AND QUESTIONS................................................................................................................................ 115
XV. Right to protection of health .................................................................................................................. 117
1. Definitie .............................................................................................................................................................................. 117
2. Bronnen .............................................................................................................................................................................. 117
3. Toepassingsgebied ............................................................................................................................................................. 117
4. Verplichtingen .................................................................................................................................................................... 119
College 18: 9 December 2022 ............................................................................................................. 120
CASES AND QUESTIONS (zie forum) ............................................................................................................. 124
College 19: 12 December 2022............................................................................................................ 126
XVI. Right to education ................................................................................................................................ 126
1. Bronnen ............................................................................................................................................................................. 126
2. Toepassingsgebied ............................................................................................................................................................. 126
3. Dimensies ........................................................................................................................................................................... 127
4. Kernverplichtingen: §57 General Comment...................................................................................................................... 128
5. Vrijheid van onderwijs.................................................................................................................................................. 128
5.A. Vrijheid van onderwijs: respect voor religieuze en filosofische overtuigen van de ouders ........................................ 129
5.B. Vrijheid van onderwijs: religieuze en filosofische overtuigen van de ouders .............................................................. 129
6.A Recht op onderwijs – Positieve verplichting: beschikbaarheid en toegankelijkheid onderwijs .................................. 130
6.B Recht – Positieve verplichting: gratis (primair) onderwijs ............................................................................................. 131
CASES AND QUESTIONS................................................................................................................................ 132
College 20: 16 December 2022............................................................................................................ 133
XVII. Equality and non-discrimination ........................................................................................................... 134
0. Poll: voorkeur: formele gelijkheid of situationele gelijkheid? ......................................................................................... 134
1. Bronnen ............................................................................................................................................................................. 134
2. Wettelijke betekenis .......................................................................................................................................................... 135
3. Typologie ............................................................................................................................................................................ 136
4. Beschermde gronden ......................................................................................................................................................... 140
College 21: 19 December 2022............................................................................................................ 142
5. Toegevoegde waarden Europees-handvest ...................................................................................................................... 145
CASES AND QUESTIONS................................................................................................................................ 146
3
, College 1: 30 september 2022
Ia. General Information
Week of 4/11 and 7/11 : extra preparation
- Prohibition of torture and fair trial (scope)
- On Friday he will give the information to know what you have to read
o Next week: universal system and council of europe
- Also possibility to earn bonus points by participating in forum
Course material
- ACCO: Human rights treaties
- ACCO: Human rights: selected judgments and documents 2022-23
- PPTs
Extra
- Bring your selected judgements and human right treaties
- Be prepared: read your assignment = goede voorbereiding voor het examen
- Active participation
Exam
- Two questions: oral with written preparation (1h preps and 15m exam)
o One inside question: ‘explain’
o Second one is a a case
▪ Cross-references are allowed
4
Voordelen van het kopen van samenvattingen bij Stuvia op een rij:
√ Verzekerd van kwaliteit door reviews
Stuvia-klanten hebben meer dan 700.000 samenvattingen beoordeeld. Zo weet je zeker dat je de beste documenten koopt!
Snel en makkelijk kopen
Je betaalt supersnel en eenmalig met iDeal, Bancontact of creditcard voor de samenvatting. Zonder lidmaatschap.
Focus op de essentie
Samenvattingen worden geschreven voor en door anderen. Daarom zijn de samenvattingen altijd betrouwbaar en actueel. Zo kom je snel tot de kern!
Veelgestelde vragen
Wat krijg ik als ik dit document koop?
Je krijgt een PDF, die direct beschikbaar is na je aankoop. Het gekochte document is altijd, overal en oneindig toegankelijk via je profiel.
Tevredenheidsgarantie: hoe werkt dat?
Onze tevredenheidsgarantie zorgt ervoor dat je altijd een studiedocument vindt dat goed bij je past. Je vult een formulier in en onze klantenservice regelt de rest.
Van wie koop ik deze samenvatting?
Stuvia is een marktplaats, je koop dit document dus niet van ons, maar van verkoper margothorowitz. Stuvia faciliteert de betaling aan de verkoper.
Zit ik meteen vast aan een abonnement?
Nee, je koopt alleen deze samenvatting voor €8,99. Je zit daarna nergens aan vast.
