Class notes
POLI 345 Midterm Exam Notes
- Course
- Poli 345
- Institution
- McGill University (Mcgillu)
International organizations class on the UN and other intl orgs. McGill class, notes up until the midterm exam.
[Show more]
Seller
Follow
Content preview
International Organization- 3 or more member states
- Legal definition is 3 or more
- Created by a formal treaty
o Outlines the objectives of the IO’s, voting system, how is it funded, how all of these
things work
- Regular, plenary meetings
o Discuss different ideas and vote on different issues
o At least once or twice a year as a minimum
- Permanent secretariat
o Means a physical building where meetings take place, where the staff of the IO work,
independent civil servants
o Headquarters in New York, then offices all over the world
o Secretary General is the head of the secretariat
- Examples
o UN
o WTO
o WHO
o Association of South-East Asian Nations
- Not the only definition, this is just the legal definition used in international law
- Sometimes we might discuss organizations that don’t fit this definition, but are still relevant
o G8 or G20 don’t fit the definition, no formal treaty, no permanent staff, but might still
study them as international organizations
Membership of IGOs
- Anywhere between three and all states of the world
- 3 or more states
- IOs more regionally focused states within a geographical area (Shanghai Cooperation
Organization – 8 members, EU – 20 members, ASEAN...)
- IOs with universal membership, all states of the world (UN – 193, WTO, 194, WHO – 164), to
gather all states of the world
Founding Treaty
- Sets objective of the organization
o Objectives can be diverse
▪ Political
▪ Economic
▪ Military
o Some objectives can be very specific (Interpol)
o Some objectives are broader (UN)
▪ Mix of different objectives
- Creates the main organs of the IO
o Details the mechanics, how they work, how do states get membership, voting rules,
access
, - Establishes functions and powers of the organs
o UN: UNSC versus UNGA
Plenary Meetings
- Plenary organ
- UNGA (usually each fall)
- Permanent secretariat: physical building, permanent staff
International Organizations as Political Systems
- Political system:
o Input (different forces and elements blended together)
▪ Demands and resources
• IOs have resources, experts, communities and countries can make
demands
• IOs take everything into account, converted into an output into a
decision or activity
▪ Member states often make a lot of demands on IOs, negotiate and write the
treaties, supply the resources, common for them to make demands, try to make
IOs as responsive as possible to these objectives
▪ Interest groups may also try to influence IOs, climate change activists, steer IOs
to create stronger climate change treaties
▪ Experts and scientists, huge role in activities of IOs, climate change experts,
more recently public health experts
▪ Staff/funding, member states provide staff as international civil servants, annual
funding, each member has to pay its due every year and it is usually the amount
is on a complex formula that has to do with the population and other things
o Conversion
▪ IO
▪ Plenary organs
• Forums where decisions are taken by state representatives
• Most famous is UNGA
• Every September, high level diplomats are invited to give opening
speeches, lots of media attention
• UNGA splits up into 6 different groups
• Work with different voting rules
• How decisions are taken
• Majority decisions (50% +1), or some require super majority (60 or 70%)
IMF if 85%
• Some work in the unanimity
• Weighted voted, each member state has a share of voting power (world
bank or IMF), USA has 70% of the power..
• One vote per state
▪ Secretariat
• Executive power
, • Implement decisions taken by legislative bodies
• Manage different programs
• Bureaucracy of international organizations
• Variations on the size of the secretariat
• WTO is a good example of that
• IOs like UN or EU with larger secretariats (tens of thousands of staff
members)
• Composed of international civil servants
o People, staff members hired by IOs to manage programs and
implement decisions
o Not representatives of their countries
o There to implement decisions and policies to the best of their
abilities without any bias, to be impartial
• Can take a different name, but often take the form of a “secretariat”
• Antonio Gutierrez current SG of the UN
▪ Courts
• Judicial powers
• There for disagreements between states
• States will create courts in IOs that perhaps in a later point there may be
disagreements between, solving disagreements with a third party is
beneficial
• Ex: ICJ
o Main court of the UN system
o Provide dispute resolution, legal advice to UNSC and other
councils, closest to what we have as a universal court
o Lots of treaties include a clause saying the dispute can be
brought to the ICJ
o ICJ is legally binding, has an optional jurisdiction, need the
clause in the treaty about the ICJ, enforcement is pretty weak,
no strong follow-up or sanctions
o US v Nicaragua, US lost to the ICJ but decision wasn’t enforced
o Output
▪ Decisions and activities
▪ Norm-setting
• Up to states to follow
• States adopt different norms
▪ Operational activities
• IOs are provided specific resources and are actively implementing
programs and policies
• Ex: peace operations, states provide funding, staff, military, and UN
manages the resources and run the operation
Is Multilateralism Under Threat?
, - The UK leaving the EU, attitude of Trump administration but US more generally about
multilateral organizations, are we witnessing a backlash of multilateralism, a moment in history
where states are slowly withdrawing time, attention and resources from IOs for their own
individual policies
- Skepticism about the real commitment of great powers like the US, China or India to
multilateralism
- This questions is lurking around a lot of IOs recently
Can IOs Produce Solve Global Problems?
- Big promises made, very little results
- Ex: Paris agreements, SDGs
- Can IOs really deliver?
Can IOs be Reformed to Accommodate Rising Powers?
- To reflect new powers
- Lots of IOs like UN, IMF... created shortly after WWII, great powers are different than they are
today
- France and UK were the winner of WWII, but some of these countries are no longer great
powers, perhaps now middle powers
- How can IOs accommodate the new powers like China or India, make more space for them,
more responsive to their interests
- If they are not, the concern that countries will turn to other IOs or create alternative
organizations
- Western powers staff most IOs
- Rising powers have little weight in terms of staff members in UN or UN Agencies
Why do States Create IOs?
- Theoretical level
- Basic question
- Answer: to achieve goals and objectives valued by states
- But in depth, why is there is much variation in the design of IOs?
- What is the added value of IOs that states cannot do by themselves?
How Autonomous from States are IOs?
- Tension: IO vs state sovereignty
- States create IOs to achieve specific things, and delegate powers to them, but how far can IOs
use this powers?
- Are they puppets? Or can they do things on their own?
- What is the broader impact on world politics?
- How is the power used? Impact on political outcomes
Historical Overview: From the Concert of Europe to the League of Nations
- Everything that came before the UN
- Historical context on IOs and cooperation before the UN in 1945
The benefits of buying summaries with Stuvia:
Guaranteed quality through customer reviews
Stuvia customers have reviewed more than 700,000 summaries. This how you know that you are buying the best documents.
Quick and easy check-out
You can quickly pay through credit card or Stuvia-credit for the summaries. There is no membership needed.
Focus on what matters
Your fellow students write the study notes themselves, which is why the documents are always reliable and up-to-date. This ensures you quickly get to the core!
Frequently asked questions
What do I get when I buy this document?
You get a PDF, available immediately after your purchase. The purchased document is accessible anytime, anywhere and indefinitely through your profile.
Satisfaction guarantee: how does it work?
Our satisfaction guarantee ensures that you always find a study document that suits you well. You fill out a form, and our customer service team takes care of the rest.
Who am I buying these notes from?
Stuvia is a marketplace, so you are not buying this document from us, but from seller christinakoikaran. Stuvia facilitates payment to the seller.
Will I be stuck with a subscription?
No, you only buy these notes for CA$11.42. You're not tied to anything after your purchase.
Can Stuvia be trusted?
4.6 stars on Google & Trustpilot (+1000 reviews)
82871 documents were sold in the last 30 days
Founded in 2010, the go-to place to buy study notes for 14 years now