Class notes
Forensic Science - The Real CSI Notes
- Course
- FSC100
- Institution
- University Of Toronto (U Of T )
Forensic Science - The Real CSI Notes Lecture Notes
[Show more]
Seller
Follow
Content preview
Lec 1: Forensic Science - An Introduction & Defining the CSI EffectLaw and Science:
● Philosophical foundation of criminal justice system:
○ Protect the innocent
○ Ensure the truth emerges
● Law:
○ Defines certain behaviours as criminal
‒ Provides a framework of regulations & determines the standard of
evidence required for prosection.
○ Goal: Settle disputes, obtain a favourable outcome.
○ Relies on the adversarial system and arguments to resolve conflict.
○ Truth decided by the trial of fact (judge or jury).
○ Outcome-based
● Science:
○ Goal: Describe the workings of the natural world.
○ Relies on the scientific method, & refinement of hypothesis to validate issues.
○ Find out whether truth can be determined dependent on available evidence.
● Both law & science work within the criminal justice system but differ in goals &
methods.
Forensic Science:
● The application of scientific knowledge & techniques to legal matters (Bell, 2006).
● Forensic is derived from the Latin ‘forensis’ (knowledge).
○ People debate or discuss, judicial connotation
● Forensic methodologies draw from a wide range of disciplines (anything can be
evidence).
● Why is it important?
○ Science brings about objectivity (not influenced by emotion, bias, or opinion).
○ In the past, convictions were based on subjective evidence (eyewitness
testimony).
○ Today, scientific evidence allows criminal investigations to be more objective
(e.g., likelihood of matching DNA to certain individuals).
The Forensic Expert:
● A forensic scientist must remain an unbiased advocate for objective facts.
● May be called upon to solve as an expert witness.
○ Only declared an expert witness by a judge.
○ May offer an opinion on the work that was done and the significance of the
findings (can give an interpretation).
, ● Being an expert witness is a serious task.
○ Opinions of an expert witness may weigh heavily on the outcome of a case.
● Criteria for being declared or accepted as an expert witness.
○ Witness is of sound & unquestioned integrity
○ Witness is sufficiently trained & experienced
○ Science or technology presented meets the criteria of acceptance:
‒ Peer review
‒ Testing & validation
‒ Rate of error
‒ General acceptance
● Forensic experts must base their opinions/conclusions on facts established by reliable
methods.
● Lay witness: what was heard, saw, done, or experienced:
○ Requires no special training or technical knowledge.
○ Testimony must be factual (not opinion-based, no interpretation).
The Scientific Method:
● “Method of procedure that consists of observation, measurement, & experimentation, and
the formulations, testing, & modification of hypothesis” (Oxford Dictionary, 2018).
● Science adheres to strict guidelines to ensure integrity (known as scientific method).
○ Ensures observations free of bias
1. Formulate question
2. Generate a hypothesis
3. Collect data by observing & experimenting
4. Interpret data
5. Draw conclusions
● When a hypothesis is validated through experimentation, it becomes suitable as evidence.
Crime Scene Investigation:
● A crime scene investigation is a methodological process:
○ Follows set of principles & procedures that adhere to guidelines.
○ Not rigid or fixed (every crime scene is different).
● A dynamic & thoughtful process:
○ Requires an active approach (how pieces of evidence link to one another).
○ Experiences & observations are key.
● Grounded in the scientific method.
● Objectives:
○ Recognize & identify forensic evidence
○ Collect & preserve evidence
○ Reconstruct the crime
, ○ Assist in the formation of a theory or theories/hypothesis about the crime
○ Example: May ascertain the sequence of events leading to a crime, assist in
uncovering a motive, etc.
● Difference between a crime scene investigator & forensic scientist:
○ A crime scene investigator attends the crime scene.
‒ Properly recognizes, identifies, collects, & preserves evidence at a crime
scene.
○ A forensic scientist works in a forensic laboratory.
‒ Perform scientific analyses on evidence, submitted by the crime scene
investigator.
The CSI Effect:
● Overview:
○ Unrealistic expectations of the capabilities of forensics & crime scene
investigation.
○ Not new, a century ago, this was known as the ‘Sherlock Holmes Effect’
○ Result of inaccurate depictions in media:
‒ Roles & responsibilities
‒ Capabilities
‒ Nature of evidence
‒ Procedures & time frames
● Analysis:
○ Potential impact on the real criminal justice system.
○ CSI is unique b/c it presents a different model of police procedurals, offers shows
present forensics as a cog in the criminal justice wheel.
‒ ‘Without a Trace’ - federal point of view
‒ ‘Law and Order’ - judicial process
‒ ‘Cold Case’ - closure & eyewitnesses
● Impact:
○ General impact is on public perception of crimes & investigations.
○ Impact on court & the legal system:
‒ Jurors
‒ Prosecution (higher rates of acquittal)
‒ Defence (higher rates of acquittal & conviction)
‒ Judge
○ Impact on criminal activity
● Responding:
○ Being aware that this phenomenon exists (becoming more critical of your
interpretations & point of view).
○ Differentiate between education & awareness
, Lec 2: History of Forensic Science & Crime Scene Investigation
Roots of Criminal Investigation:
● Forensic science is a relatively new career field/discipline.
● Its roots can be traced to approximately 1248:
○ China: the first postmortem examination gave information about the cause of
death.
○ Interdisciplinary nature of forensic science & crime scene investigation:
‒ Many pioneers in other fields became relevant and contributed to the
development of crime scene investigation.
● ‘Kin policing’ in early clan life.
○ All clan members were responsible for determining sanctions to impose on
violators (large groups of families determined whether or not someone was guilty
or not).
○ Kin policing was absolute and the punishments included corporal punishments to
executions.
● Among ancient Hebrews, law enforcement became the responsibility of kings, high
priests, & elders.
○ Certain individuals (individuals with power) were appointed to apprehend &
punish.
○ Continued into Roman rule
● In ancient Babylon, which took place approximately in the 1700’s B.C.,
○ One of the earliest & most complete written legal codes was created (hammurabi).
‒ 282 rules
‒ Messengers were assigned to carry out the law
‒ Created the foundations for the establishment of a judicial system.
● 5th century B.C., Romans adopted the first written laws:
○ Twelve tables (‘Law of the Twelve Tables’)
‒ Rights & responsibilities of the Roman citizen
‒ Legal procedures
‒ Property ownership, building costs
‒ Punishment for crimes
○ Designated police officials called Quaestores Parricidi (formed the foundation of
modern-day police detectives).
○ Through the conquest of the Mediterranean, the Romans influenced the written
legal systems of Western Europe.
● From the collapse of the Roman Empire through the early Middle Ages, formal law
enforcement was non-existent as a tool for social control.
○ Individual offences committed by the guilty were punished through:
‒ Trial by ordeal
The benefits of buying summaries with Stuvia:
Guaranteed quality through customer reviews
Stuvia customers have reviewed more than 700,000 summaries. This how you know that you are buying the best documents.
Quick and easy check-out
You can quickly pay through credit card or Stuvia-credit for the summaries. There is no membership needed.
Focus on what matters
Your fellow students write the study notes themselves, which is why the documents are always reliable and up-to-date. This ensures you quickly get to the core!
Frequently asked questions
What do I get when I buy this document?
You get a PDF, available immediately after your purchase. The purchased document is accessible anytime, anywhere and indefinitely through your profile.
Satisfaction guarantee: how does it work?
Our satisfaction guarantee ensures that you always find a study document that suits you well. You fill out a form, and our customer service team takes care of the rest.
Who am I buying these notes from?
Stuvia is a marketplace, so you are not buying this document from us, but from seller Fuuya993. Stuvia facilitates payment to the seller.
Will I be stuck with a subscription?
No, you only buy these notes for CA$13.66. You're not tied to anything after your purchase.
Can Stuvia be trusted?
4.6 stars on Google & Trustpilot (+1000 reviews)
84866 documents were sold in the last 30 days
Founded in 2010, the go-to place to buy study notes for 14 years now