Essay
‘Mill’s Utilitarianism can lead to wrong moral decisions’ (40 marks)
- Module
- G572 - AS Religious Ethics
- Institution
- OCR
Essay of 2 pages for the course G572 - AS Religious Ethics at OCR (A* essay- 37/40)
[Show more]
Seller
Follow
Content preview
Mill’s Utilitarianism can lead to wrong moral decisions. Discuss (40)Developing Bentham’s ‘An Introduction to the Principles and Morals of Education’ John Stuart
Mill, Bentham’s pupil, wrote ‘Utilitarianism’ - an essay discussing how there should be
utilitarianist principles for all situations, otherwise known as rule Utilitarianism. Mill taking a
eudaimonistic approach (“actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness”),
results in several flaws that could lead to wrong moral decisions.
Firstly, Mill’s utilitarianism distinguishes what higher and lower pleasures are, depending on the
short or long term happiness of the action. At face value, Mill’s idea here weighed up against
Bentham’s would seem more attractive as it appeals to common sense that some pleasures are
higher or lower than others however Mill believes that pleasures of the mind are higher in quality
than pleasures of the body but without eating and drinking (Mill’s consideration of lower
pleasures) then none of his higher pleasures, like admiring artwork and reading poetry would
matter as people would starve. Mill also doesn’t take into the fact that some people, many
during his time, would not have access to nearly as many ‘higher pleasures’ as he would, so his
opinion does not fit everyone in every circumstance which is what rule utilitarianism is trying to
accomplish. Not only that but Mill says that “it is better to be a human dissatisfied than a pig
satisfied” implying that lower pleasures are such because they are short term and higher
pleasures because they last for longer. This may seem coherent as naturally, one would strive
for long-term pleasure however no one can really distinguish what a higher or lower pleasure is
as it is a matter of opinion. Therefore Mill’s point here is of no practical use.
Another flaw in Mill’s utilitarianism is that the theory is teleological so the decision of an action
being right or wrong is based on its consequences, not the action itself. Now, one may see this
as a good thing as the effects of an action, depending on the circumstance, could seem a more
necessary focus than the action itself but looking at Bernard Williams’ example of the jungle
where an explorer comes across soldiers who put the decision to the explorer whether he would
shoot one indigenous person (out of the twenty captured for their oppressive regime by the
soldiers) or let the soldiers shoot all twenty. Taking Mill’s utilitarianism the explorer should kill
the one person as the quality of happiness of nineteen people is more than the one. However
you cannot predict the future, because the soldier could just lie and then still kill all the other
people, so not looking at the action itself and whether it is intrinsically good or not could result
in long-term pain. A critique of Mill would be from Bernard Williams who would support this
point as he believed that no moral theory ought to demand the taking of an innocent life.
Although Williams’ approach is extreme so may not be seen as sensible, not every situation that
is approached with utilitarianism would result in lives taken, it does make the point that we
cannot apply rules expecting them to work for every situation because, to be frank, Williams’
example killing one person or allowing soldiers to kill twenty is different from deciding whether
to go to a party or stay at home and work.
The benefits of buying summaries with Stuvia:
Guaranteed quality through customer reviews
Stuvia customers have reviewed more than 700,000 summaries. This how you know that you are buying the best documents.
Quick and easy check-out
You can quickly pay through credit card for the summaries. There is no membership needed.
Focus on what matters
Your fellow students write the study notes themselves, which is why the documents are always reliable and up-to-date. This ensures you quickly get to the core!
Frequently asked questions
What do I get when I buy this document?
You get a PDF, available immediately after your purchase. The purchased document is accessible anytime, anywhere and indefinitely through your profile.
Satisfaction guarantee: how does it work?
Our satisfaction guarantee ensures that you always find a study document that suits you well. You fill out a form, and our customer service team takes care of the rest.
Who am I buying these notes from?
Stuvia is a marketplace, so you are not buying this document from us, but from seller naomiherodotou. Stuvia facilitates payment to the seller.
Will I be stuck with a subscription?
No, you only buy these notes for £5.99. You're not tied to anything after your purchase.
Can Stuvia be trusted?
4.6 stars on Google & Trustpilot (+1000 reviews)
48072 documents were sold in the last 30 days
Founded in 2010, the go-to place to buy revision notes and other study material for 15 years now