HRIR Exam Past Papers & Essay Plans
Essay plans for various Human Rights and International Relations essay questions. Also includes a list of all exam past paper questions, sorted by topics. Very helpful for preparing for the exam! Essay plans would also be helpful for the mid-term essay.
Exa...
HRIR: Exam Past Papers & Essay Plans
(1) Introducing Human Rights
(1.1) Cultural Relativism
- Critically assess the claim that human rights norms should be developed and enforced in a
culturally specific manner. (2017)
- Yes: morality is a social construct that is culturally dependent
- Western individualism and emphasis on civil & political rights
- Non-Western communal values and emphasis on economic, social &
cultural rights
- E.g. Asian Values (Singapore), Islamic values, African Declaration of
Human Rights etc.
- Clear oversimplification though
- Yes: cultural imperialism and imposing Western values
- Int’l community and int’l institutions are overly dominated by the West, who
get to define values
- Feminist critiques
- Anti-Africa bias in ICC?
- No: Those advancing the exceptionalist claim do not genuinely & legitimately
represent those on whose behalf that claim is made
- Often flimsy disguise for totalitarian tendencies
- Islam & HRs scholars: much of Islamic fundamentalism do not align w/
Islamic texts / jurisprudence
- No: Religious freedom & tolerance not traditionally Western either
- Stoning in Bible; Harvard Law School not admitting women until 1950s;
colonialism & Section 377
- No: HRs is grounded in modern social, economic, & scientific developments
- Issue: implies countries whose HRs do not meet our standards are
‘backwards’ / ‘uncivilised’ → racist & Western-centric narrative
- Issue: does not explain why countries with similar levels of development
have vastly different conceptions & practice of HRs
- No: binaries of North/South or West/non-West obscures the contributions & agency
of states outside the Global North re: HRs (Sikkink 2015)
- History of HRs policies reveals: HRs policies have often been embraced by
the less powerful to try to restrain the more powerful
- Latin America drafted the first intergovernmental declaration of rights (the
“American Declaration”) 8 months before UDHR was passed in UNGA, 1948
- All the rights in the UDHR also appear in the American Declaration
- NGO & LatAm lobbying led to the inclusion of HRs language in UN Charter
- The language was not the language of Great Powers; adopted by
Great Powers only in response to pressures from smaller states &
civil society
- ‘The current human rights regime is a form of cultural imperialism that promotes the values
of Western states’. Discuss. (2006)
- Cultural relativism
- Anti-Africa bias in ICC
, (1.2) General
- ‘The Security Council is increasingly linking human rights violations with peace and
security’. Why? (2006)
- “The movement of global justice has been a struggle against sovereignty.” Do you agree?
(2016) (2008)
- What are the problems attached to the universal enforcement of human rights? (2007)
(2) Theoretical Foundations
(1.1) Role of HR
- Choose at least two different theoretical approaches and critically assess how they
conceptualize ‘human rights’. (2018)
- What role do human rights play in international relations? Answer with reference to
different theoretical approaches. (2016)
- How convincing are realism and liberalism in their explanations of the role human rights
play in international relations? Do alternative approaches provide more convincing
frameworks? (2014)
- Which theoretical approach or combination of approaches best explains the state of the
current human rights regime? (2011)
(1.2) Emergence of HR
- How can the emergence of a universal human rights regime be best explained? Discuss
with reference to at least two different theoretical approaches. (2016)
(1.3) Others/Feminism
- Critically assess the feminist critiques of the current human rights regime. (2013)
- How persuasive are criticisms of the current international human rights regime? Discuss
with reference to at least one theoretical approach. (2010)
(3) The Global Application of Human Rights
(3.1) UN
- How effective is the UN in protecting and enforcing human rights? (2014)
- Thesis: other than UNSC, UN bodies are mainly for reporting & monitoring, so have
limited powers (requires state cooperation)
- UN in general:
- Increasing promotion of idea that HRs is ‘universal’ and ‘indivisible’
- Universality: applies to all humans
- Indivisibility: to guarantee civil & political rights, we must ensure
economic, social & cultural rights (& vice versa)
- Rejection of cultural relativism
- Has indirect enforcement powers & monitoring mechanisms
- If a state has signed up to something, the UN can monitor it
- UN Human Rights Council
- Embodies universality & indivisibility principles
- Monitors, advises, & publicly reports - universal periodic review of all UN
members’ HRs records
- Addresses HR violations and makes recommendations on them
The benefits of buying summaries with Stuvia:
Guaranteed quality through customer reviews
Stuvia customers have reviewed more than 700,000 summaries. This how you know that you are buying the best documents.
Quick and easy check-out
You can quickly pay through credit card for the summaries. There is no membership needed.
Focus on what matters
Your fellow students write the study notes themselves, which is why the documents are always reliable and up-to-date. This ensures you quickly get to the core!
Frequently asked questions
What do I get when I buy this document?
You get a PDF, available immediately after your purchase. The purchased document is accessible anytime, anywhere and indefinitely through your profile.
Satisfaction guarantee: how does it work?
Our satisfaction guarantee ensures that you always find a study document that suits you well. You fill out a form, and our customer service team takes care of the rest.
Who am I buying these notes from?
Stuvia is a marketplace, so you are not buying this document from us, but from seller annesmith. Stuvia facilitates payment to the seller.
Will I be stuck with a subscription?
No, you only buy these notes for £8.49. You're not tied to anything after your purchase.
