A detailed, in-depth summary of chapter 4 of the book Politics by Andrew Heywood. The summary includes all terms and definitions and is sufficient scope for an exam. This book is often used for first-year political science courses.
Summary of Introduction to Political Science Part 2- Final
Summary Introduction to Political Science Part 1- Midterm (Readings and Lectures)
All for this textbook (20)
Written for
Universiteit van Amsterdam (UvA)
European Politics And Global Change
7321E020FY
All documents for this subject (12)
Seller
Follow
natyprycova
Reviews received
Content preview
CHAPTER 4 – DEMOCRACY AND LEGITIMACY
- Democracy is here just because it hasn’t collapsed yet
o All other regimes use the virtues of democracy
Legitimacy and political stability
- The problem of political obligation → why should citizens be obliged to a certain authority?
- What are the conditions that encourage people to see authority as rightful and underpin the
stability of a regime
- Legitimacy → (rightfulness) – transforming power into authority
- Legitimising power
o Weber – systems of domination
o 3 kinds of authority
▪ 1. Traditional authority
▪ 2. Charismatic authority
▪ 3. Legal-rational authority
- Max Weber
o One of the founders of modern sociology
o Importance of social action of meaning and consciousness
o Interests: social satisfaction, law, power, organization to religion
o Encouraging the development of capitalism
- Tradition → something that is handed out or transmitted from the past to present
- 1. Traditional authority
o Legitimate because it has always existed, earlier generations have accepted it
o Small tribes and groups → patriarchalism and gerontocracy
o Power of heritage and privilege → Saudi Arabi, Kuwait, Morocco
o Survival of monarchy in modern societies → UK, Belgium, NL
- 2. Charismatic authority
o Based on individual’s charisma, capacity of a leader
o De Gaulle, Kennedy, Thatcher – for them it was based on formal powers
o More appropriate examples: Mussolini, Hitler, Khomeini, Castro
o 2 consequences:
▪ It often has no limits
▪ It is hard for the system t outlive its main figure
- 3. Legal-rational authority
o Most modern states, constitutional
o Attached to an office rather than a person
o Less efficient
- Charisma → capacity to establish leadership through psychological control over others
- Limitations of Weber → tells us little about the challenges
- Beetham: power can only be considered legitimate in 3 conditions
o 1. Power must be exercised through established rules
o 2. Rules must be justified in terms of shared beliefs
o 3. Legitimacy must be demonstrated as expression of consent
Legitimation crisis and revolutions
- Alternative to Webber → neo-Marxists – Habermas. Offe
- Focus on the machinery through which legitimacy is maintained
, - But based on unequal class power
- Contractions between the logic of capitalist accumulation and popular pressures of
democracy
- This has lead to expansion of social responsibilities of the state
o Cannot satisfy both according to Habermas
- Habermas
o Frankfurt school of classical theory
- It is increasingly harder for governments to govern → overload
- Rise of the New right → response to legitimation
o Less responsibilities to the state → reaction to fiscal crisis of the welfare state
Democratic legitimacy
- Democratic legitimacy is now accepted as the only meaningful form of democracy
- 1. Consent
o Citizens are implicitly giving consent to govern – when they participate in the process
(voting)
- 2. Compromise
o Rival groups and interests find a way to live together without fighting
- 3. Feedback system
o Long-term stability
- Is democracy failing to deliver?
o Sense of disenchantment and disaffection
o Emergence of politicians such as Trump
o Example: Arab spring (relative democracy in Tunisia to complete chaos in Syria)
- Ispopulism a democratic force?
o Resembles it → popular sovereignty and majority rule
o But it acts in odds to democracy
o Viewed as a threat to democracy
- Liberal democracy
o 1. The right rule is gained through success in regular competitive elections
o 2. Constraints on government imposed by constitution, protection of minority rights
o 3. Civil society
- Fiscal crisis of the welfare state → the crisis in state finances that occurs when expanding
social expenditures coincides with recession and declining tax revenues
- Revolution → a popular uprising, involving extra-legal mass action, which brings about
fundamental change as opposed to merely a change of policy or governing elite
- Reform → change brought about within system, usually by peaceful and incremental
measures – reform implies improvement
- Consent → assent or permission, in politics usually an agreement to be governed or ruled
- Performance legitimacy → the capacity of a regime to generate public acceptance and a
sense of rightfulness through the delivery of favourable economic and social outcomes
Non-democratic legitimacy
- Non-democratic regimes are by nature illegitimate, but some of them can survive for many
decades
o Of course coercion and repression
- But there are 3 key forms of non-democratic legitimation
o 1. Elections (although they might be one-party) → to keep democratic façade
The benefits of buying summaries with Stuvia:
Guaranteed quality through customer reviews
Stuvia customers have reviewed more than 700,000 summaries. This how you know that you are buying the best documents.
Quick and easy check-out
You can quickly pay through credit card for the summaries. There is no membership needed.
Focus on what matters
Your fellow students write the study notes themselves, which is why the documents are always reliable and up-to-date. This ensures you quickly get to the core!
Frequently asked questions
What do I get when I buy this document?
You get a PDF, available immediately after your purchase. The purchased document is accessible anytime, anywhere and indefinitely through your profile.
Satisfaction guarantee: how does it work?
Our satisfaction guarantee ensures that you always find a study document that suits you well. You fill out a form, and our customer service team takes care of the rest.
Who am I buying these notes from?
Stuvia is a marketplace, so you are not buying this document from us, but from seller natyprycova. Stuvia facilitates payment to the seller.
Will I be stuck with a subscription?
No, you only buy these notes for £5.58. You're not tied to anything after your purchase.
