Class notes
International Law Notes
- Course
- International Law (PBL3001F)
- Institution
- University Of Cape Town (UCT)
- Book
- International Law
Includes case summaries and prescribed UN Resolutions.
[Show more]
Connected book
Book Title:
Author(s):
- Edition:
- ISBN:
- Edition:
1 review
By: lestieduppie • 1 year ago
Content preview
International Law NotesSources of International Law
Article 38 of ICJ Statute
Treaties
o 1973: International community recognized racism as a matter of
internal concern, not just domestic concern. = Created international
crime against humanity called “apartheid”.
o Art. 2 of the Vienne Convention on the Law of Treaties (form of intl.
law, AKA ‘treaty on treaties’, 1969)
A treaty is an international agreement concluded between
States in written form and governed by intl. law, whether
embodied in a single instrument or in two/more related
instruments, and whatever its particular designation.”
Oral treaties are rare
Designations: Conventions, charters etc.
o Bilateral v multilateral v universal
How a treaty binds certain or all states (rare – e.g. UN Charter)
International, regional etc.
o Purposes: Rule-setting v institution-establishing
Some treaties do both
Rule-setting: Intl. Human Rights Treaty etc.
Institution-establishing: UN Charter, Charter of AU etc.
o When a treaty is binding:
When a state CONSENTS
Becomes a ‘party’ to a treaty
Who can consent on behalf of a State?
o Art. 7-8 VCLT: Two classes of officials – 1)
executive; 2) head of state, head of govt &
foreign minister
o Automatic authority (head of state, head of
govt. & foreign minister) vs requirement to
- Signature: Not bound, produce ‘full powers’ (must prove that
but must not act
executive has given him power of authority)
contrary to object and
purpose of treaty. o Section 231 of SA Constitution
- Ratification: Bound Expressing consent: Art 11-14 VCLT
o Signature AND/OR ratification
Treaty-drafting state determines
whether ratification is req.
E.g. Art. 48 of Intl. Covenant on Civil and
Political Rights 1966
Monoism: Internationl law If consent is doubted: look at INTENTION
takes precedent; do not need of parties.
to pass effecting legislation.
Dualism: Need to pass
effecting legislation.
, Sign but no ratification = Art. 18 VCLT
(e.g. SA and ICESCR = long period of time
betw. Signing and rat.) => NOT BINDING!
(if rat. req., but not given)
Still not actively work against
object and purpose of treaty
No authority to sign treaty acc. to
domestic law = Art. 46 VCLT => STILL
BINDING!
STANDARD OF MANIFEST
ICJ in Cameroon v Nigeria (2002)
VIOLATION = if violation of
- Concerned delimitation treaty between two states = Did domestic constitutional law is
treaty needed to be signed AND ratified? objectively obvious => NOT
- Nigeria: Not binding because not ratified. BINDING!
- Cameroon: Never said it had to be ratified, therefore it is Cameroon v Nigeria: Authority to
binding if signed. => ICJ decided in their favour.
sign must be a well-publicized
rule of domestic law
o
What if treaty conflicts with domestic law? Treaty obligation
will take priority (protects integrity of treaty regime, puts onus
on govt. to ensure due diligence)
o Reservations
Art. 2(d) of VCLT: “Unilateral statement…made by a State,
when signing, ratifying, accepting, approving or acceding to a
treaty, where it purports to exclude or to modify the legal
effect of certain provisions of the treaty in their application to
that State.”
Art. 19-23 of VCLT: Codifies rules set out in Reservations case
Not allowed if:
Expressly excluded
Expressly allows only certain types of reservations
Res is contrary to the object and purpose of the treaty
Consequences of invalid reservation:
State is not party to the treaty
State is bound by whole treaty, without benefit of the
reservation (severance)
o Problematic because it “forces” a State to
become party to the treaty against their wishes
i.e. without reservation
Fisheries Jurisdiction; Reservations.
Interpretation (Art. 31-33 of VCLT)
Art. 31: Interpreted in good faith in accordance with
the ordinary meaning to be given to terms in their
context, and in the light of its object and purpose.”
o ICJ in Competence case at 8.
, Art 31(2): Context of treaty = Preamble, annexes,
agreements made in relation to the treaty etc. (holistic
interpretation)
Art 31(3): Other factors = subsequent agreements,
subsequent practice, other applicable rules of intl. law
o ICJ in Legal Consequences case
Art. 32: Suppl. Means of interp.
o Preparatory work : ’travaux preparatoires’
o Circumstances of conclusion of treaty
VCLT interp. rules are consistent with customary intl.
law = Costa Rica v Nicaragua
Termination (Section 3 of VCLT)
Express provision
o Specified end date and time
o Right to withdraw
Breach
o Gives rise to intl. responsibility of the breaching
State = Claim of ‘state responsibility’
Supervening Impossibility of Performance
Fundamental Change of Circumstance
Termination by Subsequent Treaty
Disuse
Customary International Law
o Definition:
Art. 38(1)(b) of ICJ Statute: “A general practice accepted as
law.”
Asylum case: “Constant and uniform usage, accepted as law.”
o TWO ELEMENTS: State practice + opinion juris (belief that something
is legally obligatory)
e.g. giving immunity to govt. official
State Practice: AKA ‘material element’
Things that states actually do (treaties, judicial
decisions, national legislation, policies, executive
decisions, UN GA Resolutions etc.)
Akehurst: “State practice covers any act or statements
by a state from which views about customary law may
be inferred.”
Duration = North Sea cases, para.73
Uniformity:
o Asylum case = constant and uniform
o Anglo-Norwegian Fisheries case
o North Sea = ‘extensive and virtually uniform’
incl. ‘specially-affected states’(States that are
particularly connected)
o Nicaragua case = ‘settled practice’
Generality:
o Specially-affected states
, o North Sea cases
Opinio Juris: AKA ‘psychological/subjective element’
Belief that a certain actin is legally acquired
Necessary for customary intl. law (where ‘law’ in ‘rule
of law’ refers to intl. law)
o Lotus case (PCIJ)
o North Sea: State practice must be accompanied
by a “general recognition that the rule of law or
legal obligation is involved.”
o Nicaragua case: Need “evidence of a belief that
this practice is rendered obligatory by the
existence of a rule of law requiring it.”
Can we distinguish OJ from state practice?
o Based on state practice
Therefore: Dynamic
o Reflects non-hierarchical, decentralized nature of intl. legal system
o Consent expressed through practice of states
All states can contribute
o Universal - default (Nicaragua case), regional (Asylum case), or
bilateral (Rights of Passage case)
o Changing CIL:
Must act contrary to old CIL to establish new CIL
How can we establish a new rule of CIL if we must show opinio
juris?
Nicaragua: “Reliance by a state on a novel right or an
unprecedented exception to the principle might, if
Requires: shared in principle by other states, tend towards a
1) Uniformity modification of CIL.”
2) Widespread o i.e. changing CIL depends on the reaction of
acceptance other states (accept/deny)
Silence, protest and acquiescence
Must states react to the practice of other States to
signal acceptance/rejection of a rule of CIL? Not always
Silence = acquiescence
o Specially-affected states will usually expressly
disagree, so silence = passive agreement
o Acquiescent states are now bound by the CIL
Requires: Can protesting against another State’s practice stop the
formation of a CIL?
CONTINUOUS
Persistent Objector States
PROTEST!
o Must classify as a POS to not be bound by the
CIL
o Must protest from the beginning, and
CONTINUE to protest as it develops
The benefits of buying summaries with Stuvia:
Guaranteed quality through customer reviews
Stuvia customers have reviewed more than 700,000 summaries. This how you know that you are buying the best documents.
Quick and easy check-out
You can quickly pay through EFT, credit card or Stuvia-credit for the summaries. There is no membership needed.
Focus on what matters
Your fellow students write the study notes themselves, which is why the documents are always reliable and up-to-date. This ensures you quickly get to the core!
Frequently asked questions
What do I get when I buy this document?
You get a PDF, available immediately after your purchase. The purchased document is accessible anytime, anywhere and indefinitely through your profile.
Satisfaction guarantee: how does it work?
Our satisfaction guarantee ensures that you always find a study document that suits you well. You fill out a form, and our customer service team takes care of the rest.
Who am I buying this summary from?
Stuvia is a marketplace, so you are not buying this document from us, but from seller attiyaomarjee. Stuvia facilitates payment to the seller.
Will I be stuck with a subscription?
No, you only buy this summary for R229,00. You're not tied to anything after your purchase.
Can Stuvia be trusted?
4.6 stars on Google & Trustpilot (+1000 reviews)
53249 documents were sold in the last 30 days
Founded in 2010, the go-to place to buy summaries for 14 years now